Live data from Hacker News

Jack Ma Again Endorses Extreme Overtime as Furor Rages On

bloomberg.com

141–150 of 264 posts

Re: Jack Ma Again Endorses Extreme Overtime as Furor Rages On

#141

Earlier quoted context omitted.

What does a badly paid Bloomberg reporter have to gain by making me feel like Jack Ma is a mean person?

Bloomberg reporters get bonuses for writing stories that affect the market. Seriously.

That's a serious accusation. Do you have evidence to back that up?

Re: Jack Ma Again Endorses Extreme Overtime as Furor Rages On

#142

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Should make them most likely to try to please their owner. Whoever gets to write something for Jack that is charitable without even being asked to do has a lot to gain. I think that what they write has little connection to truth in a situation like this but with that said I have no idea nor do I really care to form an opinion yet.

Sure but isn’t Ma smart enough to say what he wants to say, I don’t think he wants newspapers to alter his message.

Both pieces cover what he said without altering his message, they just highlight different parts to completely change the tone and fit their editorial guidelines. Ignore anything that isn't a quote, and he is saying people that don't want to work extreme hours just don't love money.

Re: Jack Ma Again Endorses Extreme Overtime as Furor Rages On

#143
post #7

I find 12 hours a day to be too much. And 6 days a week is throwing the mental health of a person off a cliff. I’ve frequently found, personally and observing others, that productivity drops after 6h of continuous work especially if it forces you to think a lot (which is pretty much always in software - you still need to apply your brain to connect the plumbing between APIs) Anything after 6h should either be menial…

I fully agree! Have found exactly the same thing for me, i.e., I can do about 6h of mentally consuming things a day.

Re: Jack Ma Again Endorses Extreme Overtime as Furor Rages On

#144
post #138
post #18

It’s interesting to compare the Bloomberg article with this one from the South China Morning Post, titled “Alibaba founder Jack Ma says companies forcing staff to work overtime are ‘foolish’”. Two articles reporting on the same statements and drawing completely different conclusions. It’s getting harder to find the truth. [1]: https://www.scmp.com/news/china/society/article/3006127/alib...

It will be easier to understand if you've followed the movement. Most of those companies are not forcing their employees to work 996 on paper. But if you don't, then first, your team leader will give you some hint to ask you to stay longer. If you still don't, you will be fired for any number of reasons (KPI is too low for example). Because of that, the company actually don't need to force it's employees. It just kee…

Nice comments, but may I suggest that you check your spellings before posting? Lots of things I had to interpret what you meant to say based on mispellings.

Re: Jack Ma Again Endorses Extreme Overtime as Furor Rages On

#145

Jack Ma's comment on this matter is full of logical fallacy. Forcing employees to stick to the 996 schedule with no overtime pay is not equivalent to someone finding their own passion and work restless towards their own goal. He somehow mixed up these two completely different things while avoided talking about the lack of overtime pay or even basic respect for employees in many corporations. Labeling people who deman…

Well, 996 is good thing to balance the imbalance. There are plenty of people looking for positions with good pay, and for those who can afford to worry about 'quality of life', they can simply move on to other positions and have other people enjoy these good paid jobs. So everyone will have their chance to get exploited and move on afterwards. Once most people are happy with what they have, no one would work for 996 companies and things will change. It is exactly the same thing as manufacture jobs moving to Asian countries. It is very good for Asian workers.

Re: Jack Ma Again Endorses Extreme Overtime as Furor Rages On

#146

I'm bit worried about the person(or the group) manning the 996.ICU github. The page states,"This is not a political movement". But, the Chinese govt won't ignore for long, any kind of movement which maligns the reputation of China.

If the chinese gov't wants to protect their reputation, wouldn't they do better to abolish 996-type working conditions?

You only need take a look at what's happening to human-rights lawyers and the victims of the melamine-contaminated infant formula scandal in China.

Re: Jack Ma Again Endorses Extreme Overtime as Furor Rages On

#147
post #42

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Bloomberg did it again - false reporting?* It is very weird. Others reports this: “No one likes working at a company that forces you to do ‘996’. Not only is it inhumane, it’s unhealthy and even more unsustainable for long periods – plus workers, relatives and the law do not approve of it,” he said. “In the long term, even if you pay a higher salary, employees will all leave.” https://www.techinasia.com/alibaba-found…

You're still not covering the core of his argument. He also says: >“If you find a job you like, the 996 problem does not exist; if you’re not passionate about it, every minute of going to work is a torment,” Ma said in a post on his Weibo account on Sunday. The point he's making is not that 996 is bad, he's saying it's bad for people who aren't passionate about what they do. It only works for people who are passionat…

Sounds very B/W. "You either love it, or it's a torment."

I think there's a lot of gray space between, that is actually fine. "I don't completely love the job, but it can be fun sometimes, and it pays the bills."

It sounds like something someone trying to manipulate you would say, if I think about it. The usual: "taking two extreme sides and creating a false dichotomy".

Re: Jack Ma Again Endorses Extreme Overtime as Furor Rages On

#148
I wonder how many processes are not automated because of peer pressure of 996. Heard stories about when India was just opening as a outsourcing hub, people would use notepad to create HTML pages. As that means more billable hours. No syntax highlighting, macro and other support. Something similar must happen for 996 to be practical.

Re: Jack Ma Again Endorses Extreme Overtime as Furor Rages On

#149
post #138

Earlier quoted context omitted.

It will be easier to understand if you've followed the movement. Most of those companies are not forcing their employees to work 996 on paper. But if you don't, then first, your team leader will give you some hint to ask you to stay longer. If you still don't, you will be fired for any number of reasons (KPI is too low for example). Because of that, the company actually don't need to force it's employees. It just kee…

Nice comments, but may I suggest that you check your spellings before posting? Lots of things I had to interpret what you meant to say based on mispellings.

In case you're not trolling, it's likely that the commenter you're replying to doesn't speak English as a first language.

Considering the topic of this post (and the hanzi in their comment), I'd venture to say s/he speaks some dialect of Chinese as a first language.

Re: Jack Ma Again Endorses Extreme Overtime as Furor Rages On

#150
post #138

Earlier quoted context omitted.

It will be easier to understand if you've followed the movement. Most of those companies are not forcing their employees to work 996 on paper. But if you don't, then first, your team leader will give you some hint to ask you to stay longer. If you still don't, you will be fired for any number of reasons (KPI is too low for example). Because of that, the company actually don't need to force it's employees. It just kee…

Nice comments, but may I suggest that you check your spellings before posting? Lots of things I had to interpret what you meant to say based on mispellings.

Sorry, I'm not a native speaker, that may lead to some problem because Chinese grammar can be very different to English. Maybe I should start to use grammarly from now on.

Sum up the post:

1. What Jack Ma is trying to do, is equalizing Personal strive and overwork (for him).

2. In China, company have many ways to force employees stay in long hour without literally say so. For example "When boss don't leave, you don't leave", and/or giving out tasks that you can't finish without overwork.

Post reply on HN