Earlier quoted context omitted.
I would have no problem with public speculation about the manner of or motives behind the death of any of my friends or family. Most speculation is a bunch of hot air, but such threads also provide a place to talk about the deceased and his works, and to talk about other, related things. I, for one, appreciate the vast majority of conversation attached to this HN post.
On several scuba and climbing sites I visit, there is a strict separation between mourning a death and speculating/analyzing the cause. It may be a little different here, but the experience with risky sports is that a thread examining the cause may include suggestions that the person was somewhat at fault. Many of the people mourning someones passing would prefer such discussions not be interleaved with celebrating t…
Unfortunately, the method by which posts get to and stay on the front page ensure that HN will never be able to perform this sort of segmentation.