Live data from Hacker News

Samsung admits to posting fake user reviews on the web

techspot.com

131–133 of 133 posts

Re: Samsung admits to posting fake user reviews on the web

#131
post #114

Earlier quoted context omitted.

"Ethics" in Asia are not the same as the rest of the industrialized world. While I can't speak for Korean ethics, I've had dealings in other Asian countries where business ethics are really more like guidelines, elastic ones at that. I wouldn't be surprised if the execs who sanctioned this behavior on Samsung's part don't even understand that it was wrong.

Right ... and US companies are always ethical, and have always been that way? Or US companies have simply been burt so many times that they know not to play loose with the truth. It's probably worth noting that Korea "chaebol" (conglomerates) can be a little odd. They have a lot of power over the local government and media, so they end up thinking they are invincible. They are sometimes said to be very shady, at time…

Exactly. While the US of course (as mentioned below) have corporations that exert influence over government, overstep the law, etc., it is generally NOT tolerated by the general public.

That's where it's different in Asia, where such behavior is business as usual.

Re: Samsung admits to posting fake user reviews on the web

#132

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Big Tobacco in the USA is of course a shining example of the West's greater moral values /sarcasm

Microsoft Monsanto Exxon and so on...

Of course it happens in the US. I think that's covered enough here and elsewhere. But i believe the basic ideal of ethics is a cultural one. Consider that certain cultures in Asia, China for example, have been doing things a certain way thousands of years, and some of those ways are repulsive to the average American.

Re: Samsung admits to posting fake user reviews on the web

#133
post #31

Earlier quoted context omitted.

> And is it illegal? No, in most places it isn't. If a consumer was misled by a planted, phony review and bought an inferior product, he could go to civil court and demand monetary compensation, but civil courts largely deal with the kinds of damage claims that don't involve the legality of an action, only its harm. Just remember that an illegal action would be prosecuted in a criminal court. A claim of harm would be…

Posting fake positive reviews is illegal in Europe under the EU Unfair Commercial Practices Directive.

That's good news -- now if the U.S. will just catch up with the EU.
Post reply on HN