Live data from Hacker News

Microsoft Needs Windows Lite

philipbohun.com

131–140 of 203 posts

Re: Microsoft Needs Windows Lite

#133
post #2

The blog post sums up why users of Windows might want this. However, this is not what Microsoft wants or needs. Microsoft is doing just fine by providing businesses what they need: a platform that can be tightly controlled and is easy to administer for large user counts.

I don't believe businesses "need" Microsoft. Microsoft is entrenched in corporations for a variety of reasons and none of them because Microsoft is technically any good.

Most businesses of any sophistication need specialised software developed only for Windows.

The local car dealership runs factory diagnostic software on Windows.

The two-way radio shop tunes and programs radios using vendor software written for Windows.

Your dentist runs their practice management software runs on Windows, and they Windows software to control other expensive equipment like X-ray machines and 3D scanners.

Re: Microsoft Needs Windows Lite

#134

No they don't. Why should they bother? * Costs them money to make * Costs them money to maintain * Will only be used by a TINY subset of ultra-enthusiasts (no, neither HN or Reddit are majorities) * Every user on it is less telemetry and less advertisement The reality is that most users don't care, and will just use whatever seems to work fine. Finding out that 'oh yeah, feature/software X does not work on Windows Li…

- people complain but have no choice

- tolerance is too high

- Every sysadmin is quietly annoyed but knows it gives then $$$.

- Companies are never going to change anytime.

Re: Microsoft Needs Windows Lite

#135
> Windows Lite is a stripped down version of Windows. No telemetry, no spying, no ads, no AI, no .NET, nothing. Windows Lite is just win32 with a lightweight shell and graphics drivers.

Not going to happen.

Win32 is stuck in Windows XP, most modern development has been on .NET, even if the core components are implemented in C++, exposed via COM.

PowerShell is all about .NET and COM interop.

Re: Microsoft Needs Windows Lite

#140

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I don't believe businesses "need" Microsoft. Microsoft is entrenched in corporations for a variety of reasons and none of them because Microsoft is technically any good.

Most businesses of any sophistication need specialised software developed only for Windows. The local car dealership runs factory diagnostic software on Windows. The two-way radio shop tunes and programs radios using vendor software written for Windows. Your dentist runs their practice management software runs on Windows, and they Windows software to control other expensive equipment like X-ray machines and 3D scanne…

That's the catch-22 problem. The underlying logic and software rarely care about the platform. They are usually just built Windows because that is the default OS on anything that is not a Mac.
Post reply on HN