Live data from Hacker News

Why Does Everyone Hate AI?

paulkrugman.substack.com

131–140 of 156 posts

Re: Why Does Everyone Hate AI?

#131
> Why Does Everyone Hate AI?

Because it was invented after they were 35.

"1. Anything that is in the world when you’re born is normal and ordinary and is just a natural part of the way the world works.

2. Anything that's invented between when you’re fifteen and thirty-five is new and exciting and revolutionary and you can probably get a career in it.

3. Anything invented after you're thirty-five is against the natural order of things."

Re: Why Does Everyone Hate AI?

#132

> Why Does Everyone Hate AI? Because it was invented after they were 35. "1. Anything that is in the world when you’re born is normal and ordinary and is just a natural part of the way the world works. 2. Anything that's invented between when you’re fifteen and thirty-five is new and exciting and revolutionary and you can probably get a career in it. 3. Anything invented after you're thirty-five is against the natura…

it's past someone's bedtime!

Re: Why Does Everyone Hate AI?

#133

Outside software, AI is synonymous with low quality and low effort. As in, "I don't care enough about you to bother with you myself, I'll have the AI do it". Covers news articles, emails, customer service, products, art, jobs, etc. The actual quality of the AI output is irrelevant.

This is a big part of it. When you spent less time making something than you expect consumers to spend watching it, the message it sends is an insult. Doubly so if the product also has quality problems inherent in AI art, video, music, not only does it communicate "your attention is not worth my time" but also "your attention is not worth putting in effort to keep".

But it's easy to avoid by paying for stuff, yet people are very unwilling to do that ... so what's the solution?

Re: Why Does Everyone Hate AI?

#134

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Corporate gives them money. I have no choice in that decision. Corporate expects me to use it. I have no choice there either. Yes, I'm trying to leave. Guess how fun AI has made that process

I think the solution is to find a shop of like-minded individuals, unionize, and then use the tools as much or as little as you want.

speedrun unemployment and destitution for "morals"

Re: Why Does Everyone Hate AI?

#135

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I think the solution is to find a shop of like-minded individuals, unionize, and then use the tools as much or as little as you want.

speedrun unemployment and destitution for "morals"

Nothing to do with “morals,” everything to do with owning the means of production. The C-suite is only powerful on paper. They’re not the only ones who get to put their feet on the table while AI eats the world.

Re: Why Does Everyone Hate AI?

#136

Outside software, AI is synonymous with low quality and low effort. As in, "I don't care enough about you to bother with you myself, I'll have the AI do it". Covers news articles, emails, customer service, products, art, jobs, etc. The actual quality of the AI output is irrelevant.

I would argue a different case: When AI is noticeable, it is obvious the person doesn't care enough to bother with you.

I'm a heavy user of AI, but it has not changed the amount of time I invest in certain things, rather, I think it has unequivocally raised its quality. In some cases it has also raised the ceiling at how good I can do things, so I'm investing more time, effort and creativity now.

For example: I'm currently working on a workshop on AI security. This is obviously time boxed by all my other obligations, and I can spend maybe 60 hours to prepare it, hopefully in a quality that my captive listeners don't have to suffer.

The newest models provide me with at least 3 major benefits:

- I have merciless feedback and criticism always available. A lot of it I might disagree with, but I'm quick to dismiss. Same with ideas. If 9/10 ideas are bad, but I'm able to dismiss them quickly, I got one good idea quicker than I can take a shower.

- I can research much more broadly by querying LLMs than just consulting Google et al. A lot of interesting minor breaches, blog posts, or forum discussions I would have missed without letting Claude and Gemini run deep research sessions.

- I can quickly generate fictional scenarios and examples. In that workshop I would like to go through some scenarios on risks of using AI Coding Agents. Creating those scenarios in the past would have cost me days, and now it is a matter of an hour or two.

My coding, writing and general life-planning has equally benefited from LLMs. I've successfully planned a vacation with Claude while on the flight to that vacation, and I've not had to fix a major bug in my software in 3 months. I'm not moving a lot faster, but I'm moving a lot more deliberately.

Re: Why Does Everyone Hate AI?

#137

Outside software, AI is synonymous with low quality and low effort. As in, "I don't care enough about you to bother with you myself, I'll have the AI do it". Covers news articles, emails, customer service, products, art, jobs, etc. The actual quality of the AI output is irrelevant.

This is inverse survivorship bias.

People notice low quality AI slop, but they don't notice high quality AI output. So they associate AI with low quality.

Re: Why Does Everyone Hate AI?

#138
How does AI meaningfully improve the lives of average people? (Spoiler: it doesn’t)

AI has already permanently changed the software development industry. That’s indisputable. Maybe it’ll also change many other industries.

But what does it change? Your employer can now pay the richest men on earth a portion of your salary instead of you. That’s it. There is presently no other meaningful benefit to AI outside cancer research etc, which of course no one has a problem with.

The problem is that there is approximately no one left in this country who believes that efficiency improvements in business will actually lead to savings on products in their lives. They just believe the rich will get richer and that everything that actually matters in their life will get more and more expensive while companies use AI to build subscription products that are just as expensive as when they used to employ 30% more people.

Oh and despite a complete lack of benefit to human beings these SaaS products are now the basis for our entire economy while driving up compute and power costs for actual people.

The only people who like AI are the people who directly benefit from the reduced labor costs.

Why the fuck would anyone else want this.

Re: Why Does Everyone Hate AI?

#139

Given the amount of people on HN happily using LLMs for their everyday work and extolling the virtues of LLMs, "everyone" might be a bit excessive

The anti-AI crowd is incredibly vested in letting you know that they hate AI, so it feels like, for example, "everyone hates AI" because they are pretty vocal about it. This phenomenon is a prime example of the false consensus effect, which is further amplified by availability cascade and vocal minority dynamics.

I personally like AI, but I'm not very vocal about it. I'm too busy using AI to do things.

Re: Why Does Everyone Hate AI?

#140
post #109
post #29

Because it's hate worthy. It removes jobs without, at least currently, substituting an equal amount of new jobs (and even if it did, they wouldn't apply to the same people who lost theirs. It serves for spam, public manipulation, and mass surveillance. It constitutes massive copyright fraud. It fills the web with slop. It's added to products despite that users say they don't want it there, and even say they dislike i…

SEO filled the web with slop way before AI

And AI made it 1000x faster, more convincing, and expanded its scope, even allowed spam to get automated back and forth.
Post reply on HN