Live data from Hacker News

Cambodia unveils statue to honour famous landmine-sniffing rat

bbc.com

131–140 of 141 posts

Re: Cambodia unveils statue to honour famous landmine-sniffing rat

#131
post #116

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Ukraine did not decide to go to war. I really don't know where you got the idea that they had any agency in preventing this short of giving Russia all of their territory and fleeing West. Since you're an immigrant into Europe maybe study the lay of the land a bit before having such outspoken opinions. You are effectively a mouthpiece for Russian propaganda which I have now idea where you picked it up (you're from Aus…

Ukraine decided war with Russia was worth the cost that would otherwise have been imposed on it by Russia, during negotiations. Both nations chose war, because their cultures require it . >Immigrant to Europe To me, this reads as a banal attempt at doxxing, since you have assumed yourself the position of arbiter of moral authority, which is being challenged by my assertions - but since you choose to frame things in t…

Wow. What a load of drivel.

> To me, this reads as a banal attempt at doxxing

You extensively comment on your history on HN when it suits you, and then you balk when that history is quoted and claim this is 'doxxing'? Sorry, but that's not how this works. Either you keep your history off HN or you can expect it to be quoted back at you when inconvenient.

> I can say with positive certainty that my cosmopolitan, multi-national, multi-language lifestyle, carried on over 4 decades, has well and truly led me to what I consider to be an elevated position: that all cultures are arbitrary and choose war instead of peace overtly, and often blindly.

Having lived in a few countries and always leaving those countries with a negative attitude (as you are doing now with Europe) sketches a very shallow level of engagement. You don't have an elevated position, you just believe you do and your comments here are testimony to how far off the mark you are.

> The simple fact is, our current set of nations, equally human, is currently too incompetent to attain the wishes of the greater human entity, which exists well and truly beyond the sphere of those claiming that "mouthpieces of Russian propaganda" are something to be worrying about.

They are something to worry about: they serve in Putin's army of useful idiots, and you are currently behaving like one of those.

> And the reason for that incompetence is, in my well-travelled and -spoken opinion

You can travel a lot and speak well but still spout nonsense.

> Because, as an American

Oh, this is hilarious.

> It is my learned opinion

You are coming across as someone who knows it all but fails to see the most basic stuff, that detracts from all of your other points.

> "Russians are evil" and "Americans are evil" are lies

Obviously they are, but I wasn't making any arguments along those lines. I know some fine Russians and I have more friends in the US than in Europe. I too have traveled a bit and spent some time abroad. It doesn't make me feel like I found the stone of wisdom and it certainly did not make me feel like I was qualified to start pissing on the cultures and leadership of the places that I've lived.

> And if you think this isn't applicable, in every single human case tested so far, then you need to travel more.

Because I haven't traveled enough? Or because we disagree and you think that by putting up some arbitrary bar you can pretend that you have the moral high ground?

> And not as a tourist: as a local.

Well, you are not a tourist: you are now a local. So we get to hold you to a higher standard than some random commenter.

> It's the only way to be sure you know what you're talking about with regards to world affairs...

Unbelievable. Anyway, I've yet to see such a pompous pile of junk on HN, you are dangerously misinformed and on top of that you come across as if you have achieved some level of enlightenment that gives you the right to pontificate to the lesser folks you interact with. I would suggest a more humble stance, one where you stop assuming that you know it all and start with actually listening a bit more.

I'm a pacifist at heart, but I also understand that if your country is attacked that you will defend it, and it is very clear who the aggressor is here and that there was no diplomatic solution other than to end up with Ukraine as a sovereign nation utterly destroyed. Russia (note: Russia, not Russians) has proven to be an utterly untrustworthy party to deal with at the diplomatic level. Their betrayal of Ukraine is horrific, mass murder, rape, daily attacks on civilians and civilian infrastructure. Many, many people dead, wounded and mentally destroyed for life. And here you are from your safe house in Vienna telling them that they should have engaged in more diplomacy? Unbelievable.

You like to travel? Good, I challenge you to go visit Ukraine and to spend some time there and befriend people, talk to them and get some actual perspective on this conflict. Then afterwards, you can go to Russia and do the same there. You will certainly come away with a slightly different point of view than what you have right now and since you feel the need to tell me to travel more (which is hilarious) I think it is fair for me to do the same to you.

Re: Cambodia unveils statue to honour famous landmine-sniffing rat

#132
post #101

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Wow. Do you believe that Russia is currently led my warmongers?

Yes, and I also believe that the Western mindset is stuck in a collective dialectic which disallows honest discussion on the subject, because in fact Europe has a lot to answer for on the topic of war, recently, and there is a lot of profit being made by those very European institutions responsible for collectivizing and propagating war-monger groupthink. Europe does not have altruistic arms dealers - it has war-mong…

> which has murdered millions of innocent human beings since 2003, however, and I no longer believe in Western moral authority which gives us the imperative to 'do something about their war criminals' without "first taking care of our own war criminals"

That goes back MUCH further than 2003.

> because we have far, far more heinously evil individuals still running the show with bloodied hands and with massive war crimes and crimes against humanity to answer for -

On this we agree, so what are you doing about it?

> yet we do nothing while bleating about Putin.

Yes, because Putin is currently waging a war of aggression against a much smaller nation which also matters.

The fact that there is more than one thing wrong with the world does not give you leeway to only see the one and ignore the other. Western leadership has often been found on the wrong side of many conflicts and the same goes for the current Russian leadership. But since you've chosen to throw your lot in with us Westerners we still sort of expect you to show some solidarity rather than to start carrying water for at least one enemy. Just so we can hold things together long enough to address all of those wrongs.

Europe has problems, there is no doubt about it. But it also has learned a lot of every expensive lessons and has the scars to prove that. You have yet to integrate or understand those lessons and yet you lecture us as though you've been invited to educate us poor backwards denizens with your superior insight. But all you've done is show the limits of your own understanding, of the history of the content, of how things go to where they are and how we are collectively trying very hard to improve things, which is hard and slow work.

A relatively small fraction of West-Europeans has visited the countries east of the line Berlin-vienna-Rome. In that sense Europe is more like two continents than one. In a nutshell, your viewpoint appears to be 'not my problem'. And I don't doubt it isn't your problem, you have no roots here and can pack up any day with your Australian passport to find a new home. But we actually live here and even though some of us have traveled as much (or maybe even more as you did) as you have and/or have lived in many different countries (which on HN isn't nearly as exceptional as you seem to think).

When you immigrate you accept that the country you immigrate to isn't perfect. But you do make a statement of loyalty, the country that accepts you accepts you with all your flaws and that's a two way street. You don't get to pretend you're some kind of alien from outerspace that expects the people around you to start living according to your ridiculously high and impractical standards. Because theory is fine, of course. The problem is that we don't live in your theoretical world where all conflict can be solved diplomatically so that nobody's holy houses and material gains get upset. Sometimes you really do get invaded, and sometimes you have to fight.

The country that I'm from has a long, long history of abuse that made us fabulously wealthy. This is not something to be proud of. At the same time it got invaded many times and somehow we managed to ultimately fight off the invaders or outsiders fought them off for us. I have no illusions about our leadership, but at the same time, when looking at the various alternatives it could be a lot worse. The last thing I would think of as an immigrant is to lecture the locals on how they should run their affairs. I would be the outsider and it would be up to me to learn, not lecture.

Re: Cambodia unveils statue to honour famous landmine-sniffing rat

#133
post #120

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Russia's intentions for Ukraine were not limited to only destruction of statehood and identity, but included the physical extermination of Ukrainians too; at least to such extent that Ukrainians would not be able to self-govern anymore: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/What_Russia_Should_Do_with_Ukr... This closely mirrors the actions of Russians in the 1940s against a number of countries in Eastern Europe. Exterminate…

If you are using Wikipedia as a source to determine "what Russia wants", instead of Russian sources, then whose propaganda are you truly propagating? Which is to say, your "What Russia Should Do with Ukraine" is just a projection of the, indeed very materialist, "Project for a New American Century" - so shall we castigate all Americans for callously allowing such totalitarian schemes to have been committed, in their…

Perhaps you use Wikipedia as a source for your information, but there are still a lot of people alive, like myself, from all the countries that are or have been neighbors of Russia, who know from first-hand experience how the Russians have treated all the territories that they have invaded, by killing the natives, deporting them to Siberia (where those deported were chosen for having "dangerous" professions, like school teacher or any other "intelectual"), installing Russian colonists in their former houses, stealing everything from the leftovers and then attempting to brainwash their children by teaching them that everything useful in the world has been invented by Russians and that the Russians are their "liberators", to whom they must be eternally grateful.

I would like to see which would be your opinion about Russians if you had the luck to live in a place close to them, so you would have seen your family kidnapped and sent to forced work in Siberia and everything they owned stolen from you.

This is something that the Russians have done everywhere around them, whenever they could, and it was always done unprovoked, before any of those neighbors had done anything against them. When those attacked by Russia during WWII have fought back, after Russia was among the victors, with the help of USA and UK Russia has extracted huge "war reparations" from those who have fought against the Russian aggression, besides transforming all the Eastern European countries into vassal states.

The traditional joke about Russia was: "Who are the neighbors of Russia? ... Whoever Russia wants."

So there is no wonder that anyone whose memories are intact will do anything to prevent the Russians from repeating such actions.

Re: Cambodia unveils statue to honour famous landmine-sniffing rat

#134
post #56

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Hot take: people get angry about veganism because they suspect, deep down, that vegans are right and feel guilty about eating meat. (Not taking the moral high ground here - I have put approximately zero effort into reducing meat intake at all.)

The real problem with veganism is that you are a social outcast around normies. That was the biggest problem that I had. Also, veganism is essentially a "fundamentalist" way of thinking -- all or nothing. Now, I advocate for people to experiment with eating less meat and animal products, not zero. Even if people cut the amount of meat they ate by 20%, it would have a huge environmental impact. Also, the type of meat…

Agree. Everything else is easy: taste, nutrition, cheap shopping... but if you decide to exclude animal products, prepare to face ostracism and you'll need to learn to cope with that. A simple and effective way is to ignore the blames and regards, let them flow to the ground without catching them.

Some people will get angry at you because you tried to do something good to much:

   - not trying: that's ok, everybody is free to keep his life as-is
   - trying 0-90%: that's ok, everybody is free to try doing some good
   - trying 90-100%: you're a fundamentalist, you can't change the world
My advice: don't argue:

   - "that's extremist" / "that's not natural" / [...] => That's an opinion, you won't change it. Smile and route to another subject.
   - "why are you [an extremist/unnatural/priest/...]?" => Question. Don't try to rant the full manifesto, you won't change their opinion neither. But if you feel confortable you may clarify a few inches of incomprehension :
      - Have you heard of vegansociety's definition[0]? I don't consider myself as an extremist.
      - I find Tofu very tasty!
      - I won't try to change your habits, just doing thinks the way I like them better.
Golden rule: don't get upset. You're always free to not being confortable discussing your choices.

0: https://www.vegansociety.com/go-vegan/definition-veganism

Re: Cambodia unveils statue to honour famous landmine-sniffing rat

#135
post #69

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I just can't help but imagine those long lived rats escaping and taking over our cities. We already struggle with the rat population and they only live 3 years, imagine if they lived 15. Also I love rats and totally agree they're tough pets because they don't live long enough. We had many of them growing up and spent a fortune removing tumors.

Some of the rats live to 80, sometimes 90 years old.

I had no idea.

I thought rats would make great pets but the idea that you get attached to a guy who would die in a couple years is quite discouraging. You updated my knowledge.

My grandmother had an African grey parrot she had inherited from someone.

Re: Cambodia unveils statue to honour famous landmine-sniffing rat

#136
post #135

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Some of the rats live to 80, sometimes 90 years old.

I had no idea. I thought rats would make great pets but the idea that you get attached to a guy who would die in a couple years is quite discouraging. You updated my knowledge. My grandmother had an African grey parrot she had inherited from someone.

Hey there, sorry to confuse you but that was a bit of a joke, real rats max lifespan is 7, but we have those other rats that will live to 80 or even 90... But yes, the parrot issue is real, people will get those without thinking for even a second about how old they can get. We have one in our family that has outlived three owners.

Re: Cambodia unveils statue to honour famous landmine-sniffing rat

#137
post #135

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I had no idea. I thought rats would make great pets but the idea that you get attached to a guy who would die in a couple years is quite discouraging. You updated my knowledge. My grandmother had an African grey parrot she had inherited from someone.

Hey there, sorry to confuse you but that was a bit of a joke, real rats max lifespan is 7, but we have those other rats that will live to 80 or even 90... But yes, the parrot issue is real, people will get those without thinking for even a second about how old they can get. We have one in our family that has outlived three owners.

Ah! Thanks for clarifying.

Re: Cambodia unveils statue to honour famous landmine-sniffing rat

#138

Fever dream interview question: 100 landmines are cleared per hero rat. How many rats needed to restore peace in Eurasia?

We have drones now which are cheap and recyclable. But it takes humans to decide how much work we're going to make for ourselves. No one likes those shitty kids that keep making messes because they are entitled or angry.

What?

Re: Cambodia unveils statue to honour famous landmine-sniffing rat

#139
post #116

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Ukraine decided war with Russia was worth the cost that would otherwise have been imposed on it by Russia, during negotiations. Both nations chose war, because their cultures require it . >Immigrant to Europe To me, this reads as a banal attempt at doxxing, since you have assumed yourself the position of arbiter of moral authority, which is being challenged by my assertions - but since you choose to frame things in t…

Wow. What a load of drivel. > To me, this reads as a banal attempt at doxxing You extensively comment on your history on HN when it suits you, and then you balk when that history is quoted and claim this is 'doxxing'? Sorry, but that's not how this works. Either you keep your history off HN or you can expect it to be quoted back at you when inconvenient. > I can say with positive certainty that my cosmopolitan, multi…

Okay, warmonger: Your nation is the #1 cause of terror and war in the world.

I shouldn't expect its citizens to be anything less than war-mongers, nor should I be surprised at the passive-aggress vitriol that gets triggered into being manifested at the moment their 'authority' is questioned. Such is life in a totalitarian-authoritarian society, such as America today.

After all, this is the nation that actively supported the worlds latest genocide and which refuses to prosecute its own war criminals, leaving the rest of the world to do it ..

Re: Cambodia unveils statue to honour famous landmine-sniffing rat

#140
post #125

Earlier quoted context omitted.

>At least, those were the demands I saw. In which documents, please? I would like to see for myself where Russia demands the extinguishment of sovereign Ukraine, that's bound to be interesting language.

https://www.independent.co.uk/news/world/europe/putin-ukrain... > “I have said many times that I consider the Russian and Ukrainian people to be one nation. In this sense, all of Ukraine is ours,” Putin said, according to Sky News.

Any politician can say anything they want - but where is it official state policy - i.e. actually documented?
Post reply on HN