Live data from Hacker News

Google just gave Sundar Pichai a $692M pay package

techcrunch.com

131–140 of 192 posts

Re: Google just gave Sundar Pichai a $692M pay package

#131

Earlier quoted context omitted.

[flagged]

No, not at all. You're taxed on equity at fair market value when it vests. It's only after that when you get taxed at a lower rate on the capital gains.

This seems to say the opposite. If your employer grants you a statutory stock option, you generally don't include any amount in your gross income when you receive or exercise the option

https://www.irs.gov/taxtopics/tc427

Re: Google just gave Sundar Pichai a $692M pay package

#132

Earlier quoted context omitted.

No, not at all. You're taxed on equity at fair market value when it vests. It's only after that when you get taxed at a lower rate on the capital gains.

[flagged]

What do you think happens with loans?

Re: Google just gave Sundar Pichai a $692M pay package

#133

Earlier quoted context omitted.

No, not at all. You're taxed on equity at fair market value when it vests. It's only after that when you get taxed at a lower rate on the capital gains.

[flagged]

Those share options need excising, which probably incurs income tax on the allocation Vs strike price. Then the shares are only worth something to inheritors if that company is doing useful work for its customers over an extremely long period of time. That is likely far more valuable than the tax going towards paying off the interest for a year on some vote-buying spending that happened 20 years prior.

Re: Google just gave Sundar Pichai a $692M pay package

#134

Earlier quoted context omitted.

No, not at all. You're taxed on equity at fair market value when it vests. It's only after that when you get taxed at a lower rate on the capital gains.

[flagged]

You're thinking of realized capital gains, not tax on the exercise/grant. I don't think there is a way to dodge the latter, and you can't take out a loan or pass down options you never exercised or stocks you were never granted.

Re: Google just gave Sundar Pichai a $692M pay package

#135

absolutely no one is smart or productive enough to justify $692m in pay. they could hire thousands of engineers for that money.

> absolutely no one is smart or productive enough to justify $692m in pay.

Upper management isn't paid based on how smart or productive they are. Google has like 400 billion yearly revenue. A CEOs decisions have enormous consequences, if a CEO can make slightly better decisions than another, it'd be easy to justify $692m in pay.

That said, I don't believe Sundar Pichai is a great CEO. He's might be an ok bean-counter, not sure, but I'm pretty sure one can get cheaper bean-counters.

> they could hire thousands of engineers for that money.

Yes and pray what would they do with them?

Re: Google just gave Sundar Pichai a $692M pay package

#136

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Poor CEO my abs. When ChatGPT came out Microsoft was singing victory songs, and predicted Google's imminent death. 3 years later Google has one of the best models and Microsoft is still borrowing OpenAI's model. Not only that, Google is running their models on their own hardware, not Nvidia's.

One of the things that a CEO drives is vision and innovation. Sundar misses the mark on these things. AI is a good example. Google invented the transformer architecture, but simply published it for its competitors to use. It took a code red in 2023 to finally push Google to develop products based on this. Cloud. Years late to the game. All it would have taken is a letter similar to the famous Bezos memo to eventually…

Google is up 800% under Sundar. I guess the blanket explanation of irrational markets can fill a cognitive dissonance shaped hole of any size hole.

Re: Google just gave Sundar Pichai a $692M pay package

#137
post #69

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I'm willing to fail as Intel's CEO for the low, low cost of $5m/year, and I can get it done in a year.

Sorry, we’re only considering applicants with a proven track record of failing as CEO

I've heard it's called falling, er, failing upwards.

Re: Google just gave Sundar Pichai a $692M pay package

#138

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Poor CEO my abs. When ChatGPT came out Microsoft was singing victory songs, and predicted Google's imminent death. 3 years later Google has one of the best models and Microsoft is still borrowing OpenAI's model. Not only that, Google is running their models on their own hardware, not Nvidia's.

One of the things that a CEO drives is vision and innovation. Sundar misses the mark on these things. AI is a good example. Google invented the transformer architecture, but simply published it for its competitors to use. It took a code red in 2023 to finally push Google to develop products based on this. Cloud. Years late to the game. All it would have taken is a letter similar to the famous Bezos memo to eventually…

> Google invented the transformer architecture, but simply published it for its competitors to use.

That's how innovation works in this industry. If companies didn't allow researchers to publish their work it would set us back decades. Researchers building on each other's work is how this industry was built.

> It took a code red in 2023 to finally push Google to develop products based on this.

So Google executed. Ability to execute is one of the things that makes a good CEO. Other CEOs have additional qualities such as vision, and getting others to believe in the vision. But not every CEO needs to be a Steve Jobs!

Plenty of innovations are coming out of Google, just look at Nano Banana Pro for example.

Re: Google just gave Sundar Pichai a $692M pay package

#139
post #84

Earlier quoted context omitted.

What data does Google have that OpenAI can't get at?

1. Proprietary Data (Youtube, docs, gmail, cloud logs, waymo, website analytics, ads, search, the list is huge) 2. Commercial Datacenters (theyre ahead at least) 3. Chip production (Google is manufactoring proprietary chips) 4. Consumer OS (Chrome, Andriod) 5. Consumer Hardware (Pixel) Basically google has access to data that OpenAI will never have access to, can lower costs below what OpenAI can, and is already a le…

You can't train LLMs on proprietary data, at least not if you want to make that LLM as accessible as Gemini. Otherwise random people can ask it your home address.

So it matters less than one would think. Also, ChatGPT can do 'internet search' as a tool already, so it already has access to say Google maps POI database of SMBs.

And ChatGPT also gets a lot of proprietary data of its own as well. People use it as a Google replacement.

Re: Google just gave Sundar Pichai a $692M pay package

#140
post #104

Earlier quoted context omitted.

No, these are RSUs, which - to your shock - are taxed as ordinary income upon payout (if that even occurs). He did not get some custom stock now that will appreciate in value magically, if and only if he meets targets - or certain types of options can also act like this. Even if GOOG stock grew so much, that this ended up being a $3B pay package, he'd be taxed as ordinary income on the full amount at payout - not eve…

Shocking? Taxed on payout is a discount versus ordinary stiffs who get taxed every year. A percentage taken from the increase of an amount every year, is more than the same percentage taken at the end; as the former foregoes the opportunity to earn a return on the amount taxed earlier. This is quite significant over longer periods. (I learned that from one of Warren Buffet's annual letters - I think he was explaining…

> A percentage taken from the increase of an amount every year, is more than the same percentage taken at the end

It sounds like you're describing a hypothetical tax on unrealized gains? Do you have a link to the Buffet letter?

Post reply on HN