Live data from Hacker News

GitHub is down again

githubstatus.com

131–140 of 425 posts

Re: GitHub is down again

#131
post #2

Status page currently says the only issue is notification delays, but I have been getting a lot of Unicorn pages while trying to access PRs. Edit: Looks like they've got a status page up now for PRs, separate from the earlier notifications one: https://www.githubstatus.com/incidents/smf24rvl67v9 Edit: Now acknowledging issues across GitHub as a whole, not just PRs.

Yeah I've been seeing a lot of 500 errors myself, latency seems to have spiked too: https://github.onlineornot.com/

Re: GitHub is down again

#132

pretty clear that companies like microsoft are actually terrible at engineering, their core products were built 30 years ago. any changes now are generally extremely incremental and quickly rolled back with issue. trying to innovate at github shows just how bad they are.

It's a general curse of anything that becomes successful at a BigCorp. The engineers who build the early versions were folks at the top of their field, and compensated accordingly. Those folks have long since moved on, and the whole thing is maintained by a mix of newcomers and whichever old hands didn't manage to promote out, while the PMs shuffle the UX to justify everyones salary...

im not even sure id say they were "top", id more just say its a different type of engineer, that either doesnt get promoted to a big impact role at a place like microsoft, or leaves on their own.

Re: GitHub is down again

#133
post #6

Of course they're down while I'm trying to address a "High severity" security bug in Caddy but all I'm getting is a unicorn when loading the report. (Actually there's 3 I'm currently working, but 2 are patched already, still closing the feedback loop though.) I have a 2-hour window right now that is toddler free. I'm worried that the outage will delay the feedback loop with the reporter(s) into tomorrow and ultimatel…

have you considered moving or having at least an alternative? asking as someone using caddy for personal hosting who likes to have their website secure. :)

> have you considered moving or having at least an alternative

Not who you're responding to, but my 2 cents: for a popular open-source project reliant on community contributions there is really no alternative. It's similar to social media - we all know it's trash and noxious, but if you're any kind of public figure you have to be there.

Re: GitHub is down again

#134
post #119

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I wonder who left the team recently. Must be someone bagged with shadow knowledge. Or maybe they send devops/devs work to another continent.

nah, they're just showing us how to vibecode your way to success

If the $$$ they saved > the $$$ they lose then yeah it is a success. Business only cares about $$$.

Re: GitHub is down again

#135

Good thing we have LLM agents now. Before this kind of behavior was tolerable. Now it's pretty easy to switch over to using other providers. The threat of "but it will take them a lot of effort to switch to someone else" is getting less and less every day.

Are we sure LLM agents aren't the cause of these increasing outages?

Re: GitHub is down again

#136
post #78
post #7

If you'd have asked me a few years ago if anything could be an existential threat to github's dominance in the tech community I'd have quickly said no. If they don't get their ops house in order, this will go down as an all-time own goal in our industry.

Github lost at least one 9, if not two, since last year's "existential" migration to Azure.

Is there any reason why Github needs 99.99% uptime? You can continue working with your local repo.

Re: GitHub is down again

#137
post #74

What are good alternatives to GitHub for private repos + actions? I'm considering moving my company off of it because of reliablity issues.

Gitlab.com. CI is super nice and easily self hostable.

And their status history isn't much better. It's just that they are so much smaller it's not Big News.
Post reply on HN