Live data from Hacker News

CARA – High precision robot dog using rope

aaedmusa.com

131–140 of 188 posts

Re: CARA – High precision robot dog using rope

#131
post #127

It's just a gut feeling but I'd trust a feedback based backlash elimination mechanism more than rope based, especially in the long run and/or with a large deployed base.

But, why?

Like I said gut feeling. I suppose over time there may be some play in the axles, for example. Something feedback could compensate for but a rope could not.

Anyway good engineering requires extensive testing over many hours of movements.

Re: CARA – High precision robot dog using rope

#133
post #117

What a horrible video is this, with the robotic translated AI voiceover? Update: Ah, weird, if I watch the non-embedded one on youtube it is the original in English with normal sound. It's the one embedded on his web site which has AI translation to German.

That's not the video's fault, but YouTube's. YouTube has started adding automatic AI voiceover translations to all videos, unless the uploader explicitly disables them for each single video. It's opt-out and the option is well-hidden, so most uploaders will not disable it. As an end user, there's nothing you can do to prevent from seeing them. But you can change the audio track to the original while the video is play…

> YouTube has started adding automatic AI voiceover translations to all videos, unless the uploader explicitly disables them for each single video.

WHAT?!? It a time when there is a growing animus towards AI generated content, for many content creators this would be tantamount to slander

Re: CARA – High precision robot dog using rope

#134
post #127

Earlier quoted context omitted.

But, why?

Like I said gut feeling. I suppose over time there may be some play in the axles, for example. Something feedback could compensate for but a rope could not. Anyway good engineering requires extensive testing over many hours of movements.

> Anyway good engineering requires extensive testing over many hours of movements.

He actually discussed this in an earlier video for his initial tests on the capstan drive. He ended up testing the rope he used for around 358 hours (two weeks) on continuous use in the drive itself with very low backlash

https://www.aaedmusa.com/projects/capstandrive

https://youtube.com/watch?v=MwIBTbumd1Q&t=10m

Re: CARA – High precision robot dog using rope

#135

Why spend so much effort to achieve an "exact" gear ratio? Having more zeros does not equal to being more "precise". Also, I wonder how resistant this mechanism is to wear and fatigue.

> Also, I wonder how resistant this mechanism is to wear and fatigue.

He actually discussed this in an earlier video for his initial tests on the capstan drive. He ended up testing the rope he used for around 358 hours (two weeks) on continuous use in the drive itself with very low backlash

https://www.aaedmusa.com/projects/capstandrive

https://youtube.com/watch?v=MwIBTbumd1Q&t=10m

Re: CARA – High precision robot dog using rope

#137
post #48

Earlier quoted context omitted.

That would be a terrible path for someone with this extreme level of demonstrated talent, motivation, and follow-through. Much better for someone to fund a startup run by him.

Why would you put someone with clear talent at building stuff in charge of running a startup? He'll get bogged down in lawyers, day to day operations and growth strategies. Hire him and put him in R&D in some robotics company.

Yes but also the robotics industry notoriously has an extremely low shipping rate. So choose your bog I guess?

Re: CARA – High precision robot dog using rope

#139
post #44

I've watched and re-watched Aaed's videos on the capstan drive, it's great stuff. High speed, high torque, compliance, effectively no backlash. It's fascinating to watch a legit engineering mind at work.

I haven't watched the one about the dog, but the one with the initial explication of capstan drives [0] was excellent. I've been dreaming about it for the last year, especially since about the same time another person started working with the da Vinci robot actuators which use cables to generate find motion. 0. High Precision Speed Reducer Using Rope: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=MwIBTbumd1Q 1. Building a DIY Surg…

The "DIY Surgical Robot" vid is so good. And it's also posted over a year ago with no follow-up. Damn.
Post reply on HN