Live data from Hacker News

Eleven v3

elevenlabs.io

131–140 of 168 posts

Re: Eleven v3

#131

I am interested in TTS for reading web pages and LLM responses but it's too expensive. At this price point I can't look at it. I will continue using local TTS, not as great but instant, allows tracking text as it read it and works offline.

This is the feature that has me using Edge at work. Having the browser read every blog/article at 2x speed with word highlighting is awesome.

Re: Eleven v3

#132

I am interested in TTS for reading web pages and LLM responses but it's too expensive. At this price point I can't look at it. I will continue using local TTS, not as great but instant, allows tracking text as it read it and works offline.

Give us a try, I think we are what you are looking for

https://narrationbox.com

Re: Eleven v3

#133
post #130

Earlier quoted context omitted.

But it's not an actual person. It's an "AI". Do you want a future where you don't hear actual people anymore? I want to listen to music, audiobooks, poetry, novels, plays, with actual humans talking, that's the whole fucking point.

What difference does it make?

Are you seriously even asking that question?

It’s like having a robot that can give you a hand-job and someone saying, “well it’s a robot…” and you saying “what difference does it make?”

You tell me? What difference does it make talking with an old friend versus an ai simulation of an old friend?

What difference does it make seeing the artist who actually painted something talking about why they painted it, versus get sent an image an ai made in stable diffusion?

The difference is we are human and live in a society with other humans and we make connections with them because of their personalities, experiences, life story, emotions etc.

Perhaps you’re ok with staying alone at home with ai friends and ai generated everything but it seems quite strange to me.

Re: Eleven v3

#134
post #14
post #10

English sounds really great, congrats! other languages I've tried doesn't sound that good, you can hear a strong english accent

German sounds okay.

Not a native speaker by any stretch, but all the voices sounded like 'intercom announcer' or 'phone assistant' to me. Not natural in the slightest.

Re: Eleven v3

#135
post #130

Earlier quoted context omitted.

What difference does it make?

Are you seriously even asking that question? It’s like having a robot that can give you a hand-job and someone saying, “well it’s a robot…” and you saying “what difference does it make?” You tell me? What difference does it make talking with an old friend versus an ai simulation of an old friend? What difference does it make seeing the artist who actually painted something talking about why they painted it, versus ge…

I know a man who was pissed off after realizing the personalized-looking emails from the bank was machine generated. What do you think about those?

Re: Eleven v3

#136

For reference in case anyone is wondering, it is based on: https://github.com/152334H/tortoise-tts-fast The developer of tortoise tts fast was hired by Eleven labs.

'was'. I departed almost half a year prior to v3's release this week.

Where are you now? What are you working on?

Re: Eleven v3

#137

Sounds absolutely amazing, like 99% indistinguishable from real professional voice actors to me. I couldn't find any pricing though. Anyone know what they charge for it?

Ouch. Professional Voice Actor here.

As a user of audible, I do follow some authors but I've found better luck following certain voice actors. It's almost like the voice actor is the critic, and by narrating a story they are recommending it to me. Anybody can take a robot voice and apply it to anything, meaning that just because my favorite robot voice "Robot McRobot" read book XYZ doesn't mean I'll enjoy book XYZ. But because your voice is inherently scarce, you are only likely to read books that "work" for you.

I don't know what the process is for matching voice actor to book, but that process is inherently constrained because the voice belongs to a real human, and I enjoy the output of that process.

That said, while Audible is kind of expensive, I'm afraid that they'll reduce their price and move to robot voices and I'll lose interest entirely despite the cheaper price.

Re: Eleven v3

#138
post #87

From the example: "Oh no, I'm really sorry to hear you're having trouble with your new device. That sounds frustrating." Being patronized by a machine when you just want help is going to feel absolutely terrible. Not looking forward to this future.

It's also impossible to turn off in my experience. I have like 5 lines in my ChatGPT profile to tell it to fucking cut off any attempts to validate what I'm saying and all other patronizing behavior. It doesn't give a fuck, stupid shit will tell me that "you are right to question" blah-blah anyway.

I imagine they design these AI's to condescend to you with the "you right to question..." languages to increase engagement.

That said, they probably also do this because they don't want the model to double down, start a pissing contest, and argue with you like an online human might if questioned on a mistake it made. So I'm guessing the patronizing language is somewhat functional in influencing how the model responds.

Re: Eleven v3

#140
post #64

We’re using elevenlabs in a new prototype, and it gets confused by its own voice which my mic picks up. Unless I wear headphones, it thinks I’m talking, and it gets into a loop. I hope this release fixes that bug!

This is not a model issue - you just have not properly implemented acoustic echo cancellation on your end.

Various elevenlabs competitors don’t run into this problem on the same machine.
Post reply on HN