Live data from Hacker News

Malicious compliance by booking an available meeting room

clientserver.dev

131–140 of 380 posts

Re: Malicious compliance by booking an available meeting room

#131
post #92
post #14

If I was in the room, I'd be relieved. I always found that meetings at large companies dragged on unless there was a forcing factor (like a doorknock) that got someone to bring it to an end.

I've been in 90 minute standups, the 10 minute standup pedants would be my heroes.

Did anyone faint?

Re: Malicious compliance by booking an available meeting room

#133

The backstop forcing function to end meetings is the conference room being booked for the next slot... One of the things I noticed during COVID when everyone was remote was that meetings would never end on time b/c there was no contention for meeting rooms.

I wish they added a feature to Teams where it will just automatically disconnect everyone from the meeting at the scheduled end time.

Teams used to have a pop up that said “your meeting is ending in 5 minutes” but it wouldn’t do anything else to actually effectuate the meeting ending. They should add a feature where it starts playing “it’s closing time” music

Re: Malicious compliance by booking an available meeting room

#134

I thought one of the reasons we call it a standup is because everyone just, stands up, and does a ytb. So you don't need a meeting room. Nice story.

The only time I've actually stood up during a standup was when I interned at Ubisoft. We would have ~25 people in a room all standing on the perimeter and we'd say what we were working on one by one. As an intern I really liked it because I got to hear what problems everyone was working on.

Re: Malicious compliance by booking an available meeting room

#135
post #114
post #92

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I've been in 90 minute standups, the 10 minute standup pedants would be my heroes.

Wow, was it actually 90 minutes of standing?

For me, yes. I was working remote from a surprisingly loud coffee shop so I had to pop out in the back alley. The rest of the team (even those in office) was all connecting on zoom so I doubt it.

Re: Malicious compliance by booking an available meeting room

#136
post #59

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Heh some people are on time, some people are late. It's seemingly a culture thing, and neither side understands the other. You say "of course nobody will stop at 9:50am" and that is exactly what I would do.

> neither side understands the other. Being late is viewed as rude or lacking respect for others by a lot of people. Do people who are habitually late view prompt people as rude for being on time?

It's considered at least weird to show up to some parties exactly on time, yes.

Re: Malicious compliance by booking an available meeting room

#138
TFA's author is ascribing malice to the team booking the room during the last 10-minute slice of the hour, but I think there is a simpler and more charitable explanation based on having been in a similar situation: The team might prefer that particular room for a specific reason, frequently have to adjust their stand-up times for various reasons, and just took the only available slot.

Re: Malicious compliance by booking an available meeting room

#139

When it's a meeting I run/control my rule is that I will wait 150 seconds for people who are late, after which I start the meeting. You can join later, that's fine, but I'm not waiting longer than 150 seconds. Waiting 150 seconds feels like waiting a long time. Whereas being 2.5 minutes late feels like being on time. So I find that phrasing it this way is more impactful. (by now you probably figured out that I am not…

> (by now you probably figured out that I am not very popular ar work)

I bet your colleagues appreciate it if you’re similarly strict about ending meetings on time.

Post reply on HN