Live data from Hacker News

Zoom outage caused by accidental 'shutting down' of the zoom.us domain

status.zoom.us

131–140 of 324 posts

Re: Zoom outage caused by accidental 'shutting down' of the zoom.us domain

#131
post #32

A few years ago I had a .us TLD. I eventually decided that I probably shouldn't be reliant on a country code for my domain, it's the same reason why I don't use .io I'm not saying that this couldn't have happened with a gTLD But why put your brand at the mercy of a government like that?

> But why put your brand at the mercy of a government like that? Literally every single TLD is administered by a government. .com itself is under jurisdiction of USA and operated by Verisign

> Literally every single TLD is administered by a government.

False. I’m not sure what you’re trying to assert, but governments don’t necessarily need to control/admin gTLDs, and as far as ccTLDs go, they’re under jurisdiction of the corresponding nation, usually, but they’re going to be “administered” by a tech company that holds a contract.

Anyway, “.com” does indeed answer to U.S. jurisdiction, despite being technically a gTLD, but registrations are not restricted to US-based entities. The main things that keep “.com” associated with the USA include the history/legacy of this quintessential “original” domain, as well as a general support from major countries that provide a “second-level” commercial domain, such as “.co.uk”.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/.com

Re: Zoom outage caused by accidental 'shutting down' of the zoom.us domain

#132
post #48

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Also after dividing the number of outages by the number of customers? I'm not a customer (wouldn't buy my domain overseas) and have no solid opinion on GoDaddy besides that I hate the name. I hear the horror stories also. I'm just wondering if this is a knee-jerk reaction

I've used about 12 registrar's and dns providers and they are trash top to bottom - literally the worst and most difficult to do everything from basic setup to how they do things just plain weird compared to other hosting providers. They also aren't the cheapest option so other than brand recognition I don't get why people use them.

Let’s not get carried away.

Network Solutions still exists.

Re: Zoom outage caused by accidental 'shutting down' of the zoom.us domain

#134
post #65
post #50

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I don't think that's a real risk

It wouldn't be the first time a ccTLD has been retired after its country ceased to be, though it would be the most disruptive given how popular it is, hence the uncertainty as to what they'll do this time.

That territory is not going to "cease to be", it's just going to change hands. The uncertainty was entirely created as an easy way to get views.

Re: Zoom outage caused by accidental 'shutting down' of the zoom.us domain

#135
post #85

That seriously devalues MarkMonitor's services. MarkMonitor claims to be a "an ICANN-accredited registrar and recognized industry leader since 1999". The whole point of paying for MarkMonitor is that they're an expensive service for valuable domains and are not allowed to screw up. GoDaddy should not be involved here at all.

MarkMonitor isn't at fault here. If you register a ".ps" domain, it doesn't matter if you use MarkMonitor or Namecheap, they can't help you when the ongoing genocide results in the removal of Palestine as a country and ".ps" no longer is a valid country code top level domain. Similarly, if you register a .us domain instead of a ".com", ".net", or ".org", MarkMonitor can't help you when GoDaddy inevitably screws up. H…

[flagged]

Re: Zoom outage caused by accidental 'shutting down' of the zoom.us domain

#136
post #85

That seriously devalues MarkMonitor's services. MarkMonitor claims to be a "an ICANN-accredited registrar and recognized industry leader since 1999". The whole point of paying for MarkMonitor is that they're an expensive service for valuable domains and are not allowed to screw up. GoDaddy should not be involved here at all.

MarkMonitor isn't at fault here. If you register a ".ps" domain, it doesn't matter if you use MarkMonitor or Namecheap, they can't help you when the ongoing genocide results in the removal of Palestine as a country and ".ps" no longer is a valid country code top level domain. Similarly, if you register a .us domain instead of a ".com", ".net", or ".org", MarkMonitor can't help you when GoDaddy inevitably screws up. H…

>>> This block was the result of a communication error between Zoom’s domain registrar, Markmonitor, and GoDaddy Registry, which resulted in GoDaddy Registry mistakenly shutting down zoom.us domain.

That sounds like MarkMonitor is at least partly at fault here.

Re: Zoom outage caused by accidental 'shutting down' of the zoom.us domain

#138
post #85

That seriously devalues MarkMonitor's services. MarkMonitor claims to be a "an ICANN-accredited registrar and recognized industry leader since 1999". The whole point of paying for MarkMonitor is that they're an expensive service for valuable domains and are not allowed to screw up. GoDaddy should not be involved here at all.

[flagged]

Re: Zoom outage caused by accidental 'shutting down' of the zoom.us domain

#139
post #85

That seriously devalues MarkMonitor's services. MarkMonitor claims to be a "an ICANN-accredited registrar and recognized industry leader since 1999". The whole point of paying for MarkMonitor is that they're an expensive service for valuable domains and are not allowed to screw up. GoDaddy should not be involved here at all.

[dead]

Re: Zoom outage caused by accidental 'shutting down' of the zoom.us domain

#140

Earlier quoted context omitted.

> GoDaddy runs the root dns for .us .us is not the “root DNS” and your misidentification is muddying the waters. .us is a TLD (Top-Level Domain) and more specifically, a ccTLD (cc = ‘Country Code’). https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/.us And the English Wikipedia says that its registrar is a subsidiary of GoDaddy named “Registry Services, LLC”. The root DNS servers and registry are not run by GoDaddy or a subsidiary. http…

[flagged]

.us is not a root name server. The root name servers are one more degree removed.
Post reply on HN