Live data from Hacker News

MeTube: Self-hosted YouTube downloader

github.com

131–140 of 173 posts

Re: MeTube: Self-hosted YouTube downloader

#131

I don't understand one thing...why do you need to host it on a server? It can be just a standalone app on windows/Linux/mac. I recently just started using yt-dlp and have thought of making a simple app. Should I though? Are there any alternatives in existence of this kind?

What, like Stacher? https://stacher.io/

This looks like a good implementation. But I have to go to my desktop to explore more

Re: MeTube: Self-hosted YouTube downloader

#132
post #40

Earlier quoted context omitted.

What, like Stacher? https://stacher.io/

Or Seal for Android: https://f-droid.org/en/packages/com.junkfood.seal/

This is a very neat implementation! Exactly what I was thinking. I'm gonna try it out. Thanks for the suggestion!

Re: MeTube: Self-hosted YouTube downloader

#133

I don't understand one thing...why do you need to host it on a server? It can be just a standalone app on windows/Linux/mac. I recently just started using yt-dlp and have thought of making a simple app. Should I though? Are there any alternatives in existence of this kind?

yt-dlp is not even necessary. If just downloading videos from YouTube this can be done with much less code and complexity. I use a tiny C program to do it. Tiny shell scripts work just as well. What no one is discussing is that yt-dlp can no longer download itag 22 and itag 18 is now throttled.^1 This means yt-dlp has to download an audio file and a video file and use ffmpeg to merge the two. YouTube ad revenue just…

I also realised the same thing yesterday. I tried using a specific tag quality, for a playlist and many of the videos failed to download. So, I just set it to download the best available quality for video and audio.

Re: MeTube: Self-hosted YouTube downloader

#134

I don't understand one thing...why do you need to host it on a server? It can be just a standalone app on windows/Linux/mac. I recently just started using yt-dlp and have thought of making a simple app. Should I though? Are there any alternatives in existence of this kind?

yt-dlp is not even necessary. If just downloading videos from YouTube this can be done with much less code and complexity. I use a tiny C program to do it. Tiny shell scripts work just as well. What no one is discussing is that yt-dlp can no longer download itag 22 and itag 18 is now throttled.^1 This means yt-dlp has to download an audio file and a video file and use ffmpeg to merge the two. YouTube ad revenue just…

This has been the case for a while now. It may be temporary. Time will tell. Not being a video codec nerd, I do not find that itag 136 is any better than itag 22. Files are about the same size. But 136 needs separate audio file which creates need for ffmpeg and, generally, more temporary storage space.

Re: MeTube: Self-hosted YouTube downloader

#135

What I’d really like is a YouTube TiVo. There are about 100 channels that I watch religiously, but, release infrequently. I never want to miss a video from these channels. I also don’t want to open YouTube and sift through hundreds of releases from channels that release four times/day just to find the 1-2 videos that I actually want to watch (and will inevitably miss.) Just give me a priority feed of the stuff I actu…

This feels like it's covered by YouTube subscriptions, no? Subscribe to those 100 channels, bookmark your subscriptions page, and presto! You now have a priority feed of the stuff you want to watch and nothing else. Maybe you just don't want to create an account, which is fine (NewPipe is a great fit), but it's a bit weird to see you say that "making sure we don’t miss the things we love isn’t YouTube’s M.O." when th…

Hacker News.

Re: MeTube: Self-hosted YouTube downloader

#136

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I have hundreds of subs. With no way to create sub tiers the channels putting out multiple releases a day quickly overwhelm the ones with fewer.

So, you have hundreds of subs but only care about a hundred of them, and that's YouTube's fault? Why do you subscribe to channels whose content you don't watch?

I don't have this particular problem, but maybe they want YT to support these creators, even if they don't have time to watch it all.

Re: MeTube: Self-hosted YouTube downloader

#137

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I have hundreds of subs. With no way to create sub tiers the channels putting out multiple releases a day quickly overwhelm the ones with fewer.

So, you have hundreds of subs but only care about a hundred of them, and that's YouTube's fault? Why do you subscribe to channels whose content you don't watch?

Youtube’s fault is that subs get sorted at random and you have to scroll through to see that blue dot. It is hostile to a user by design and will never make pinnable subs or sort/grouping modes.

Re: MeTube: Self-hosted YouTube downloader

#138

Earlier quoted context omitted.

The problem is if one channel only uploads once a month and another channel uploads twice a day, I will see many videos from the frequent upload channels and might miss the infrequent uploads. If it was just a list of channels with their most recent video I'd see a new thumbnail and know to check that channel for any new videos.

I just unsubscribe from the spam channel because they're producing too much noise. I don't need content producers like that in my life, and making it less obvious that they're adding mostly noise is just disguising the problem, not solving it.

Good for you, but that’s not a solution if you have mixed interests, e.g. you want to get daily entertainment content to choose from and content that is deeper than that. You may not need it, but if you can’t do that anyway it’s indistinguishable from coping.

Re: MeTube: Self-hosted YouTube downloader

#140

Earlier quoted context omitted.

You don’t back up the data from your laptop to external media? :S

Where to? Some sort of server? where you could run some sort of software that would organizeand catalogue your files in a more readily usable format than digging into a laptop backup archive?

Depends on your setup. Usually the easiest thing to do is to have an external drive that you connect with USB and backup the files to
Post reply on HN