Live data from Hacker News

46% of Americans didn't read a book in 2023

nathanbransford.com

131–140 of 181 posts

Re: 46% of Americans didn't read a book in 2023

#131

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Well, can you name a computer game that is a great artistic work? There are many that are good , but I can't say there are any that are on a par with, say, "The Lord of the Rings" or "War and Peace" or "1984". I'd love to hear of one that was though.

Cosmology of Kyoto, according to Roger Ebert.

Looking about, that does sound fascinating. Seems like the kind of game that could have a modern remake.

Re: 46% of Americans didn't read a book in 2023

#132

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Sadly, I agree with you. Between work and kids it just has to go. I am also blessed with no sleeping problems which means that I fall asleep the moment i go to bed. I try to read at least one book per year during vacation. I read so much when I was younger. I am not certain I will get the habit back when I get older.

Same. Can't say I miss it, either. Reading a book at this stage in my life (busy with kids) feels self-indulgent and selfish.

Why not read with your kids?

Re: 46% of Americans didn't read a book in 2023

#133

And worst than that, I wonder about the quality of the books for the other 54%. Reading a book by itself is not a virtue.

I'm quite sure even before the internet has been a thing, most people only read cookbooks, car/sport magazines and Twilight equivalents by the time.

Re: 46% of Americans didn't read a book in 2023

#134
post #85

Earlier quoted context omitted.

This > reading scientific papers in PDF, listening to 2h conference talks is not equivalent to > Watching movies, playing a 60h narrative videogame

Why? All are important for a well rounded, interesting person.

Watching movies and playing video games are not required to be well rounded and interesting and they do not provide the same intellectual stimulus that reading papers and watching smart people give lectures do.

Re: 46% of Americans didn't read a book in 2023

#135
post #61

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Of the past yes, but what about the present and future?

The depth of a book is vastly different than the 10min youtube video summarizing said book. I’ve tried both modern and legacy form factors and honestly I’m on camp book more and more as the years go on. The modern stuff feels like total fluff compared to a book, which in turn feel like total fluff compared to the academic papers it is based on. These days I would rather spend 2 hours reading a good book or paper than…

I got back into reading books after a long hiatus and was pleasantly surprised by how much I missed them. The depth of thought and nuance is just totally different than an article or youtube video. I still consume plenty of modern media but feel like I get more out of books on average.

For anyone who wants to get back into reading books my advice is to start with whatever sounds fun. A lot of people fall into a trap of feeling like they need to read something useful or serious and just get turned off to the idea. But reading lighter books are still great and provide a lot that you won't get from tv and similar mediums. Over time your interests will evolve naturally into new areas.

Re: 46% of Americans didn't read a book in 2023

#136

I have found a high correlation in my life between book reading and general happiness. When I am in a period when I am reading books regularly, I am generally happy. Things are going well, I have good life balance. When I go a stretch without reading books, I am generally stressed out and in burnout mode at work, and home life is not great. Note - this is generally fiction. I read very little non fiction. Note 2 - mo…

Usually my reading rate of fiction increases dramatically when depressed.

Reading is, for me, a better form of pure escapism than gaming or movies.

Re: 46% of Americans didn't read a book in 2023

#137
post #8

Why do we obsess so much over legacy form factors? Watching movies, listening to 2h conference talks, playing a 60h narrative videogame, and reading scientific papers in PDF may not be as noble, but they are equally meaningful to me.

I think reading fiction has merit on its own. It's an active process where you have to fill in all the gaps of an imaginary world. This makes you take a hypothetical situation seriously, even if it is unreasonable at face value (magic doesn't exist, astrophage aren't real). Taking hypothetical situations seriously expands your ability to reason over anything, including abstract things.

Overall I think this readers to become more reasonable people, because life is full of unreasonable things. Things we can't explain, things that seem silly, but we nevertheless have to grapple with them.

Other fiction can fulfill a similar role, but I suspect that books are better at it because they require the reader to put in more effort.

Re: 46% of Americans didn't read a book in 2023

#138

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Sadly, I agree with you. Between work and kids it just has to go. I am also blessed with no sleeping problems which means that I fall asleep the moment i go to bed. I try to read at least one book per year during vacation. I read so much when I was younger. I am not certain I will get the habit back when I get older.

Same. Can't say I miss it, either. Reading a book at this stage in my life (busy with kids) feels self-indulgent and selfish.

Don't you allocate some time just for you? Labelling that as selfish seems very unhealthy.

Re: 46% of Americans didn't read a book in 2023

#139

But all my friends on Goodreads are claiming to finish a book a week Are... Are they LYING?? No one lies on the internet. EDIT: Wow I guess I hit a, nerve. Sorry folks. I use Goodreads and finish about a book a month. So I don't think a book a week is unreasonable/impossible. I just meant to allude to the fact that the platform has gotten a lot of attention for review bombing and profile manipulation. Anyways, here i…

I get through an average novel in 1-2 days, either in dead tree or ebook format on my phone.
Post reply on HN