Live data from Hacker News

Brief structured respiration enhances mood and reduces physiological arousal

cell.com

131–140 of 174 posts

Re: Brief structured respiration enhances mood and reduces physiological arousal

#131

[flagged]

Apparently among the other things it develops are a contempt for most of humanity?

Saying that science done in Europe and the US about ancient Asian breathing techniques is embarrassing is way less offensive than thinking that Europe and the US are most of humanity.

Re: Brief structured respiration enhances mood and reduces physiological arousal

#132

I've taught most of my clients breathing exercises for the past 5-6 years. It's unnecessary to take it to the level of a formal pranayama practice to make fairly significant differences in physiological state, from which most everything else derives. The "coherent breathing" work that popped up sometime in the last ~15 years is pretty interesting, too.

Would you share some of your breathing lessons here?

I only ask because there are several other commenters on here offering breathing tips, and you sound like an expert on this.

Re: Brief structured respiration enhances mood and reduces physiological arousal

#133
From the blog post:

> Interestingly, those who felt the greatest boost in mood also experienced the biggest drop in heart rate variability.

A drop in HRV isn't generally good. So I check the paper, and found this:

> No significant changes were found in heart rate variability or resting heart rate over the course of the study in either of the groups (Figures 4C and 4D)

There was a reduction respiratory rate for those an increase in daily positive affect. Bottom line, unclear if this particular study points to a positive health outcome other than feeling happier.

Re: Brief structured respiration enhances mood and reduces physiological arousal

#134

[flagged]

I am beyond disinterested in football. Don't really like hamburgers much. And it's certainly debatable how mindfully I scroll. I find value in mindfulness and am open to suggestions and teachings on breathing and meditation.

But you'll need a heeeeeelllaaaa more data before you casually add "psychic powers" to the claims :-)

Re: Brief structured respiration enhances mood and reduces physiological arousal

#135

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Apparently among the other things it develops are a contempt for most of humanity?

[flagged]

Have you read the post you are defending?

Calling anybody who needs some evidence for psychic abilities a football-watching mindless drone is... Kind of a canonical insulting contempt.

Re: Brief structured respiration enhances mood and reduces physiological arousal

#137

[flagged]

anytime i read something like that i have to wonder: if it can make such a big difference, why can't i see that difference in the world? perhaps it really only goes as far as the child level party tricks. or perhaps psychic abilities don't really matter.

Re: Brief structured respiration enhances mood and reduces physiological arousal

#138

From the blog post: > Interestingly, those who felt the greatest boost in mood also experienced the biggest drop in heart rate variability. A drop in HRV isn't generally good. So I check the paper, and found this: > No significant changes were found in heart rate variability or resting heart rate over the course of the study in either of the groups (Figures 4C and 4D) There was a reduction respiratory rate for those…

From the paper:

Interestingly, change in respiratory rate was negatively correlated with change in daily positive affect (Figure S5; r = - 0.24, p < 0.05), suggesting that participants who showed the highest reduction in respiratory rate also showed the highest daily increase in positive affect over the course of the study (Figure S5).

Re: Brief structured respiration enhances mood and reduces physiological arousal

#139

From the blog post: > Interestingly, those who felt the greatest boost in mood also experienced the biggest drop in heart rate variability. A drop in HRV isn't generally good. So I check the paper, and found this: > No significant changes were found in heart rate variability or resting heart rate over the course of the study in either of the groups (Figures 4C and 4D) There was a reduction respiratory rate for those…

But as you said, the main finding reported was an increase positive affect.

Re: Brief structured respiration enhances mood and reduces physiological arousal

#140

I've taught most of my clients breathing exercises for the past 5-6 years. It's unnecessary to take it to the level of a formal pranayama practice to make fairly significant differences in physiological state, from which most everything else derives. The "coherent breathing" work that popped up sometime in the last ~15 years is pretty interesting, too.

Where should one begin with this?
Post reply on HN