Live data from Hacker News

CD Projekt is remaking the first Witcher game in Unreal Engine 5

gamedeveloper.com

131–140 of 228 posts

Re: CD Projekt is remaking the first Witcher game in Unreal Engine 5

#131
post #21

> Now we know that it's a ground-up remake of the game that introduced Geralt of Rivia to Witcher fans outside of Poland. I was always of the impression that it was Witcher III that achieved this. I'm Polish so I genuinely don't know. Were the previous two installments popular outside of Poland?

Its not great data, but peak Steam player counts:

Witcher 1 Enhanced Edition: 12,685

Witcher 2 Enhanced Edition: 12,884

Witcher 3 Wild Hunt: 103,329

Re: CD Projekt is remaking the first Witcher game in Unreal Engine 5

#132

Sometimes remakes can actually improve accessibility to an older game with a dated engine/mechanics and make it more enjoyable for newcomers to experience the earlier entries. See: Yakuza Kiwami and Yakuza Kiwami 2 (remade using the excellent Yakuza 0 engine/mechanics). I do own Witcher 1/Witcher 2 (bought no-doubt during some Steam sale for like $5-$15, tops), and I vaguely recall playing W1 for like a half hour, th…

I think yours is a pretty common experience considering that Witcher 3 was a huge mass-market success and Witcher 1 was a niche product made both by and for insane people. I say this as a shameless Witcher 1 apologist.

Re: CD Projekt is remaking the first Witcher game in Unreal Engine 5

#133

People complaining about this being a remake, but I'm assuming they made the remake as a way for their developers to get use to Unreal 5 before making Witcher 4 which is also built using Unreal 5. Easier to build a game you already know in a new game engine than to create a completely new game. Especially if you don't want the game to be filled with bugs. CD has always used in an house game engine for their games.

[deleted]

Re: CD Projekt is remaking the first Witcher game in Unreal Engine 5

#134
post #112

Earlier quoted context omitted.

If it doesn't count sales on GOG then it's not really reliable. GOG is owned by CD Projekt group, and one of the big points when releasing Witcher games was that people bought them on GOG so that all money went to the devs instead of paying the Steam tax.

How many people were aware of that campaign? Maybe in the Witcher/CDPR superfan groups, but on the scale of 12 million copies I can't imagine it budges the number that much. I don't know why we're only talking about the PC version anyway, there's apparently been 40 million copies sold across all platforms according to a quick Google search, so most people didn't even play on PC.

>I don't know why we're only talking about the PC version anyway

Because the post I was replying to was about the popularity of The Witcher in the west before The Witcher III, and the first Witcher game was a PC exclusive so there are no console sales to factor in to the comparison.

Re: CD Projekt is remaking the first Witcher game in Unreal Engine 5

#135
post #73
post #33

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Witcher 1 not so much, but Witcher 2 had a pretty good 360 port that a lot of people played in the West, and PC version did well too - across all platforms 1.7 million copies sold by 2012, another article I saw suggests 8 million by 2014. I think thats getting towards very roughly ~1/4 the success of Witcher 3, volume wise. Not bad, considering Witcher 3 volume includes a portable Switch release. > https://www.euroga…

> Not bad, considering Witcher 3 volume includes a portable Switch release. I've seen the Switcher. Wasn't actually half as bad as I anticipated. All the more surprising that CDPR is abandoning their own engine in favour of UE5.

I don't think they're abandoning it, they are just going to hire a new team to remake W1 in Unreal Engine, while the core team works on new games using proprietary tools

Re: CD Projekt is remaking the first Witcher game in Unreal Engine 5

#136
post #6

I don't know why, this makes me a bit sad. You can sort of feel a game engine when you're playing a game. The GTA trilogy lost a lot when they did their remastering project with a different engine. Although I'm sure it can be done well. StarCraft remastered was done really well, but I believe they built on top of their existing engine.

The GTA trilogy remasters actually run on the original game engine under the hood, the only thing they changed was the renderer (Unreal Engine instead of RenderWare).

The modern DOOM 1/2 releases on Android/iOS/Switch/Xbox/PS does something similar: it is using the original renderer but uses Unity to handle input and output for easier portability.

Re: CD Projekt is remaking the first Witcher game in Unreal Engine 5

#137
post #107
post #76

Earlier quoted context omitted.

> Their stock price is near 5 year low, how can they afford it? Stock price has nothing to do with how much money CDPR has in their bank accounts. Stock trading is basically a public opinion poll on the future of the company, but not a penny from those trades actually goes to company accounts.

and if a company is trading low, their trust is also low, am I wrong? They would will need to trick people into giving them money upfront (preorders?) or borrow from 3rd party to cover a product that will sell and bring cash. nevertheless, I didn't mean they can't fund it because of low stock price, they got lots of free money from Polish government development fund, but CDPR delivered only 4 big games and only 2 wer…

"Trust" is a broad term, so not the one I would use. It's more about expectations of future dividends (and expectations of other market participants' expectations of future dividends, and that goes on until some Nth derivative of the stock's underlying value, also because "growth" is a derivative of "future dividends")

Nearly every stock in Tech is down a lot this year. High growth, low profitability stocks are generally underwater. You'd have to compare their stock to similar companies to see if they are down more or less than those comparable peers.

Re: CD Projekt is remaking the first Witcher game in Unreal Engine 5

#138

I already played it, so I'm unexcited. Remakes these days generally seem like lazier ways to try to make money compared to making new art from scratch. I thought Cyberpunk was abysmal (though i loved the witcher games) so I wouldn't expect much from them anymore in any case.

What about Cyberpunk was abysmal to you? I really enjoyed the atmosphere and the gun-play. NPC animations left some to be desired, but overall I thought the graphics were super engaging and Night City was super fun to run around in.

When Cyberpunk launched it had game breaking bugs. A lot of people got their refund and forgot about the game (and rightly so).

Re: CD Projekt is remaking the first Witcher game in Unreal Engine 5

#140

Sometimes remakes can actually improve accessibility to an older game with a dated engine/mechanics and make it more enjoyable for newcomers to experience the earlier entries. See: Yakuza Kiwami and Yakuza Kiwami 2 (remade using the excellent Yakuza 0 engine/mechanics). I do own Witcher 1/Witcher 2 (bought no-doubt during some Steam sale for like $5-$15, tops), and I vaguely recall playing W1 for like a half hour, th…

I played W1 when it came out and it was great. But couldn't imagine playing it after Witcher 3 because W3 is in a different universe of quality and polish. A remake is fantastic news.
Post reply on HN