Live data from Hacker News

Plex: Important notice of a potential data breach

news.ycombinator.com

131–140 of 194 posts

Re: Plex: Important notice of a potential data breach

#131

question: why use Plex over Kodi?

I'd say it comes down to how diverse your clients and your media library are. Plex can transcode your content on the server and then stream it to clients, which means the clients don't necessarily have to be powerful. Kodi is more of a file browser, it just opens the content from whatever storage and plays it directly.

Re: Plex: Important notice of a potential data breach

#133

Earlier quoted context omitted.

> a hacker could still compromise a system that has the key in memory. Security is about layers. Simply because a hacker “could” do something, does not mean it’s a bad idea. Getting the encryption key when it’s not stored in the database requires the hacker to now have access not to just the database but to another system as well.

Invariably some developer would just store the key in a column next to the email address so they could process any transaction directly in the query. But the hackers would have to know what algorithm was used :) That's a layer, right?

> some developer would just store the key in a column next to the email address

I think that depends on where you work. Process. Code reviews before allowing merge/pull requests can help.

Re: Plex: Important notice of a potential data breach

#134
I have a feeling that this breach is older than what they're letting on.

On July 27th, I received ~7 emails, about 10 minutes apart, warning me of a new device logging in my Plex account. It didn't correlate with any activity on my part, and the IPs were all over the place (for context I'm in France). Here is some of the IPs that were used :

  - 191.101.41.35 (US)
  - 185.199.103.40 (US)
  - 103.43.200.58 (India)
  - 2001:16a2:def3:200:40cf:530f:ff72:1747 (Saudi Arabia)
Fortunately the password is only used on Plex, and I just generated a new one and signed out my devices, and that was it.

Re: Plex: Important notice of a potential data breach

#135
post #98

It's funny that everyone here is expecting airtight security practices, proper vulnerability disclosure and general trustworthiness from an app that's a tiny step above the likes of BitTorrent and PopcornTime.

That's like saying torrents are only used for piracy, TOR only for buying drugs, and crypto only for laundering money.

What percentage of torrent use or Plex use is not for piracy?

Re: Plex: Important notice of a potential data breach

#137
I noticed last week that my plex server was using a lot of CPU when I was not watching plex. Since I almost never use it, I just killed the server process thinking that it was running amok because of some bug.

It all became clear when I got this email last night. I was suspicious, but now I'm pretty certain that my account was exploited, and my local media was being streamed by a 3rd party.

Re: Plex: Important notice of a potential data breach

#138

I like that they're up front about this. Solved the problem in a couple of minutes. I use a password manager with a very long randomly generated password for everything, so a hashed password leaking is essentially meaningless to me. Notifying me immediately so that I can change it ASAP is what matters. The burner e-mail I use for stuff like this is listed in 25 other data breeches, too. I don't really care. Plex is a…

> I don't really understand the freak outs here.

Because most people reuse the same email address and password, and are potentially way more exposed than you are.

Re: Plex: Important notice of a potential data breach

#139

I like that they're up front about this. Solved the problem in a couple of minutes. I use a password manager with a very long randomly generated password for everything, so a hashed password leaking is essentially meaningless to me. Notifying me immediately so that I can change it ASAP is what matters. The burner e-mail I use for stuff like this is listed in 25 other data breeches, too. I don't really care. Plex is a…

> data breeches

First I thought of the pants that the crew of the Enterprise wear and second was the diaper thing that the monkey you use to save in Mega Man Legends wears[0].

(As an aside, an image search for "data star trek" will have you believing that he does not wear pants on that show.)

[0] https://duckduckgo.com/?t=ffab&q=data+mega+man+legends&atb=v...

Re: Plex: Important notice of a potential data breach

#140
post #134

I have a feeling that this breach is older than what they're letting on. On July 27th, I received ~7 emails, about 10 minutes apart, warning me of a new device logging in my Plex account. It didn't correlate with any activity on my part, and the IPs were all over the place (for context I'm in France). Here is some of the IPs that were used : - 191.101.41.35 (US) - 185.199.103.40 (US) - 103.43.200.58 (India) - 2001:16…

Plex is implying the passwords were salted and hashed:

> all account passwords that could have been accessed were hashed and secured in accordance with best practices

Post reply on HN