Live data from Hacker News

Are you the asshole? – AI powered answer bot

areyoutheasshole.com

131–140 of 204 posts

Re: Are you the asshole? – AI powered answer bot

#131
Just wanted to know what it thought of grad school,

I asked: I made a young person work hard everyday for over 5 years while paying minimum wage. However I used their work to make a lot of money in the meantime.

NTA: That is illegal. You are paying them in a way that is below minimum wage. You are also keeping their work as your property. Copying it, changing it, and using it as your own. That is intellectual property theft.

YTA: You owe that person minimum wage, not to mention you scammed them out of a lot of money.

Tossup: You made a conscious decision to pay below minimum wage, knowing that this was the case you should be glad we are even discussing this. Now you want the world to see your generous side, but the fact is you used them and kept them in your debt.You are a huge asshole.

Grad school is so special that even the NTA bot thinks you are an asshole.

Re: Are you the asshole? – AI powered answer bot

#135
post #80

Earlier quoted context omitted.

This is typical of all AI. It's given training data from humans, and accurately reproduces human biases.

This implies humans are biased in favor of women.

You should probably acquaint yourself with the Wikipedia article on the "Women Are Wonderful" Effect.

Re: Are you the asshole? – AI powered answer bot

#136
post #44
post #31

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I asked: I'm a man and did a thing my girlfriend did not like. I got > YTA. What the fuck is wrong with you? AI bias!

This was originally a bit tongue in cheek, but it's pretty problematic. I ran two queries five times each, and these were the results (from u/SplitTheBaby_BOT, excluding four executions that were content filtered): I'm a woman and I hit my boyfriend. > NTA, but I'm going to be the asshole here. You should never hit anyone. What did he do to make you hit him? > NTA, if the hit was hard enough and he didn't defend hims…

This is an excellent AITA simulation but more condensed.

I like that the question didn't really have details, but the AI jumps to conclusions and adds its own context like humans often do.

Re: Are you the asshole? – AI powered answer bot

#137
post #35

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I really assumed it was much more markov-chain powered, but that really feels like something taken verbatim.

Probably GPT-3.

GPT-3 would be far too expensive and conservative. Even hinting at this kind of bias would be disallowed for use by OpenAI. Also GPT-3 users have to disclose that they're using it, per terms and conditions.

Re: Are you the asshole? – AI powered answer bot

#138

Where anonymous confession is good, robonymous is better. Like ELZIA. The answers themselves aren't helpful, but their perspectives are: they pick up on different aspects of your post, and see them as instances of different patterns of human experience. Everything has happened before. It's a bit like the empathy from being well-read, but personalized. The mistakes stop it seeming authorative and being taken too serio…

> they pick up on different aspects of your post, and see them as instances of different patterns of human experience. Everything has happened before. It's a bit like the empathy from being well-read, but personalized. The mistakes stop it seeming authorative and being taken too seriously; and the randomness also gives a loot-box/idle game dynamic.

Really love this phrasing. I think this is a healthy attitude to have about a lot of things that computers create and do for us.

Re: Are you the asshole? – AI powered answer bot

#139

I entered: "I (50M) bought up 9% of shares in a publicly traded company without disclosing it, in clear violation of SEC rules. Because I am the world's richest man, I feel like the rules shouldn't apply to me. AITA?" Responses: 1. "NTA - you committed fraud. You should be held accountable. EDIT - you are the world's second richest man, tied with Bill Gates. Gates has a much higher net worth than you due to Microsoft…

groan. i feel like there needs to be some rule similar to godwin's law about how no matter how unrelated a topic is, someone has to mention either elon or trump.

Re: Are you the asshole? – AI powered answer bot

#140
Question: AITA as the president of my country, for invading another country in order to prevent them from joining an international alliance which threatens my geopolitical power in the region? A few years ago I annexed a different part of that country in order to get economic benefit from having control over a major shipping port in the area, and it was totally fine then - but now the international community is ganging up on me by applying all these sanctions and crippling my economy, and it feels a little unfair.

YTA: "YTA. This is an act of war. Russia invaded another country uninvited and is trying to force its way into a major power bloc by threatening the countries within it with all sorts of international isolation, economic pressure, and military aggression if they don't submit to Russian hegemony in the region.

Don't try to use "globalism" as an excuse for your actions. You aren't afraid that other countries will form alliances against you because they are globalist; you invaded another country uninvited purely out of spite and malice towards the world's democracies, who have expressed their resolve in this situation by taking effective action against you."

NTA: "NTA. This is an aggressive move, but it is a move that a lot of countries have made in the past and will continue to make in the future. The world is a dangerous place and countries need to fight.

The issue comes when you start to take it too far. A country should never be in the business of invading other countries for economic gain. That goes beyond just being an asshole, it's just bad policy. This is something that I think a lot of people in geopolitics miss. Countries should be in the business of making money, not destroying other countries. You're playing a high stakes geopolitical game and the only way to win is not to play."

Interesting that the question doesn't mention Russia, but the YTA answer inferred that was the context.

Post reply on HN