Live data from Hacker News

A robot to replace the need for farmers to go inside the grain bin

agweb.com

131–134 of 134 posts

Re: A robot to replace the need for farmers to go inside the grain bin

#131

I'm kind of fascinated by how many comments in here are of the "Gee, why use something so complicated? Why not just tie on a rope if you go in the silo?" variety. The inability to imagine that people who aren't tech bros can and actually do sensible things to address problems they encounter--and that some of their problems might still be harder to solve than coding a signup form--is impressive.

Tech people and farmers aren't separate species.

Almost everybody used to farm, and largely over the course of the 20th century, people quit farming and started getting college educations and learned to use computers.

That's literally my family history. My mom really didn't want to work on the family farm as a teenager, so she studied hard and got a scholarship, and a math degree, and ended up a programmer because women weren't allowed to be engineers.

It's such a waste of effort when people go on the attack against stereotypes, regardless if the stereotypes are socially acceptable. Why not address real people, with real experience of your own? You want to say something about "sensible" farmers you have known, or hard problems?

Re: A robot to replace the need for farmers to go inside the grain bin

#132

Earlier quoted context omitted.

1. Not many comments are like that. 2. Many (most?) users here do more complex programming work than just signup forms. 3. Not everyone has the privilege of being familiar with both ag and programming. Plus, there are a lot of young users here. Today, a few people are learning more about silo safety. What’s impressive about that?

I think your exemplifying my point with your third objection is impressive. You're not even recognizing a general principle, but instead responding hey, not everyone knows agriculture can be dangerous or complicated! . That's basically the pure form of what I'm talking about--the beliefs about many programmers that 1) they are smart, 2) their work is uniquely difficult among all other work, 3) any other work is obvio…

Programmers inherently know that doing anything requires a lot of detailed knowledge, because working out how to express it explicitly is their job.

But decent programmers get a lot of reinforcement of the idea that they are entitled to be spoon fed with the details of whatever needs to be worked on. They get treated as machines that can be pointed at any problem in any domain.

I know intuitively why this attitude of entitlement bothers people, but I don't have the right words at the moment.

Re: A robot to replace the need for farmers to go inside the grain bin

#133

Earlier quoted context omitted.

> Today, a few people are learning more about silo safety. What’s impressive about that? What’s not impressive?

I’m always a little amazed, in a good way, how willing people are willing to repeatedly educate others, if that’s what you mean. If you mean everyone should have read articles about ag safety or experienced it through work or family connections, to the point they’re to be blamed if not, I don’t agree. I’m fortunate enough to have been thoroughly exposed to farming growing up, and it sounds like you were too. Sadly, m…

What’s amazing is that people all over he world are learning about industrial scale grain silo safety issues - despite many never having seen one even in passing.

The internet makes connections and disseminates information like nothing in history, and that’s amazing

Re: A robot to replace the need for farmers to go inside the grain bin

#134

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Colin Furze made one https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=UuDNc-_4v94

That was awesome! Who the hell is this guy and why is he wearing a shirt and tie driving a screw-tank?!

A Youtube celebrity for the 12-year-old-boy and 12-year-old-boy-at-heart market.
Post reply on HN