Live data from Hacker News

Sunsetting Secret Santa and Reddit Gifts

reddit.com

131–140 of 166 posts

Re: Sunsetting Secret Santa and Reddit Gifts

#131

Earlier quoted context omitted.

At least they have still kept old.reddit.com around, which thankfully doesn't have most of the new bullshit. The day they kill that is the day reddit will be truly dead.

They are trying so hard not to have that Digg moment but we'll see if it succeeds when they sunset old.reddit.com...

There needs to be a replacement if they are going to have a diff moment. I’m open to hearing about alternatives.

Re: Sunsetting Secret Santa and Reddit Gifts

#132
post #97

Earlier quoted context omitted.

And then banning the bubbles that engage in wrongthink.

Honestly, I think there has been very little banning of bubbles for "wrongthink", it's mostly been banning of bubbles for "wrongbehavior".

I think it’s wrongthink or potential wrongbehavior. An example is there was a exhibitionist nsfw subreddit, and it was shut down because people kept flagging non-offending posts as nonconsensual. Even though the literal subjects would post stuff like “that’s me, it’s cool.” The sub was removed.

Tons of examples like this. It’s not that big of a deal and no major harm.

Just part of the reason I think Reddit sucks and I don’t go there.

The little serendipitous fun of the internet was all over Reddit. Now it feels like a totally lame person lames over everything.

Re: Sunsetting Secret Santa and Reddit Gifts

#133

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Good point! I’m squarely on the right in today’s climate and I think I’m more classically liberal than reddit’s authoritarian left that I had in mind when I wrote that. I suppose I meant to say “orthodox leftist thought”. It’s hard not to get turned around here in opposite world.

What does authoritarian left mean?

Think soviets but for much less consequential topics (eg, being kicked out of a Facebook group by believing that only some cops are bastards, not ACAB).

It’s so banal to experience, but occurs.

Re: Sunsetting Secret Santa and Reddit Gifts

#134
post #99

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Replace www with old: https://old.reddit.com/r/announcements/comments/nw2hs6/sunse...

Yes, but they will probably sunset it one day with an announcement like this one.

I wonder what their analytics are on the amount of people who use old.reddit.com vs not. My guess is that once it hits a certain low threshold they'll decide to get rid of it. That will be a sad day.

I also fear they will pull what Twitter did and severely limit their API which will essentially kill third party apps and everyone will have to use their official apps.

Re: Sunsetting Secret Santa and Reddit Gifts

#135

"We made the difficult decision to shut down Reddit Gifts and put more focus on enhancing the user experience on Reddit" Oh, enhancing user experience sounds good: so they'll reinstate the old reddit UI back as the default, the one that doesn't block viewing threads in a mobile browser half the time?

I don't mind the new UY but what I don't understand is how after all this time basic functionality of the site still doesn't work. Like, at least once a week you get logged out and can't log in or you click on a subreddit or a post and it won't load the content. I just don't understand how this is still going on and they are putting resources into avatar microtransactions and the live streaming. Does anyone use the live streaming stuff on reddit?

Re: Sunsetting Secret Santa and Reddit Gifts

#136

Earlier quoted context omitted.

This was some comfort years ago, but these days, the vast majority of reddit users are mobile and new-reddit, whose UX's favor more meme/video mindless scrolling and throwaway comments. So while the old reddit experience is there in looks it feels more hollow nowadays. You go into a common interest subreddit and where 8 years ago you might have found interesting discussions now it's all memes, inspiration photos, etc…

I am convinced even had Reddit kept the old design, it would still suck now, because any site focused on a universal demographic will inevitably get most people coming in on mobile, and mobile inherently discourages longform text and encourages images. I find that for various special-interest, hobbyist forums, you need some kind of friction to prevent low-effort posters from taking over, and ensure more people are pa…

Friction is a feature, so few people seem to get that.

Re: Sunsetting Secret Santa and Reddit Gifts

#137
post #116

Earlier quoted context omitted.

You can only do that if you can afford it: I'm pretty sure reddit never made money and was bleeding it quite profusely. At some point you have to start making money, but reddit (and most other internet/digital companies) valued growth at all cost. Now they are probably billions in the hole and they have to look for outside investment. You also make the strong assumption that executive staff/founders actually care abo…

I wonder if a community-owned project similar to a food cooperative could work with sites like Reddit. Have people pay a membership fee for a share in the project. Non-members still have access but with basic ads.

I’ve been through a few online communities that tried this (netslaves, plastic) and co-op ended up being “pay me what I would like to run it.”

I remember the shutdown thread on netslaves where the owner asked for money and multiple community members offered to run it or chip in and the owner said no. They wanted the amount they wanted because they also wanted to run their other projects.

I don’t fault them as it’s their site and they can run it as they wish. But just to point out the difficulty of community projects that require money.

Even with food co-ops, there is frequently drama.

Maybe the closest would be to have some sort of online kibbutz.

Re: Sunsetting Secret Santa and Reddit Gifts

#139

Earlier quoted context omitted.

This was some comfort years ago, but these days, the vast majority of reddit users are mobile and new-reddit, whose UX's favor more meme/video mindless scrolling and throwaway comments. So while the old reddit experience is there in looks it feels more hollow nowadays. You go into a common interest subreddit and where 8 years ago you might have found interesting discussions now it's all memes, inspiration photos, etc…

I am convinced even had Reddit kept the old design, it would still suck now, because any site focused on a universal demographic will inevitably get most people coming in on mobile, and mobile inherently discourages longform text and encourages images. I find that for various special-interest, hobbyist forums, you need some kind of friction to prevent low-effort posters from taking over, and ensure more people are pa…

I don’t want to argue, just maybe help you expand your horizons a bit. I am 85,000 words into my novel with almost all of those written on my IPhone using Scriviner. I like to sit in my backyard and actually purchased a big comfy writing chair recently.

After my last laptop broke I simply decided I didn’t need another one. Like most people on this site I have a beast of a desktop computer I write code on all day and then like to get away from to write my novel.

I’ve been able to maintain 2k words per day with some 5k days when I am really jiving with the scene I am writing. All from my iPhone. Times they are a changing.

Re: Sunsetting Secret Santa and Reddit Gifts

#140

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I am convinced even had Reddit kept the old design, it would still suck now, because any site focused on a universal demographic will inevitably get most people coming in on mobile, and mobile inherently discourages longform text and encourages images. I find that for various special-interest, hobbyist forums, you need some kind of friction to prevent low-effort posters from taking over, and ensure more people are pa…

I don’t want to argue, just maybe help you expand your horizons a bit. I am 85,000 words into my novel with almost all of those written on my IPhone using Scriviner. I like to sit in my backyard and actually purchased a big comfy writing chair recently. After my last laptop broke I simply decided I didn’t need another one. Like most people on this site I have a beast of a desktop computer I write code on all day and…

You are an outlier, writing a novel from a phone keyboard (and, of course, writing a novel at all). The general public that Reddit targets does not invest the same energy in longform text from their phones. The device you see as a means to relax and focus on your novel, for most Reddit users is a more cumbersome means of expression, and moreover most of them are operating within an app that encourages inane content.
Post reply on HN