Live data from Hacker News

Enjoy the Best, Not the Latest, Media

kartick.substack.com

131–136 of 136 posts

Re: Enjoy the Best, Not the Latest, Media

#131

Earlier quoted context omitted.

This is why I used to love Rotten Tomatoes: between the audience score, the critic score, and the top critic score, you get three telling data points about what sort of person us likely to enjoy the movie. I have read a lot less film criticism since Roger Ebert died though. It seems like recently anything remotely enjoyable on rotten tomatoes gets above 90.

I stopped loving Rotten Tomatoes after it was purchased by Comcast/Universal Studios and Time Warner/Warner Bros Studios.

Oh interesting I didn't know... when was that?

Re: Enjoy the Best, Not the Latest, Media

#132
post #94

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I genuinely enjoyed Mulhulland Drive, dislike Beethoven's ninth symphony (and most classical music) and Die Hard. True elitism is assuming your subjective preference is objectively better than other people's subjective preference. In the end, if you like something, that's all that matters.

There's no accounting for bad taste.

I'm not sure exactly what you mean. Can you define "bad taste"?

Re: Enjoy the Best, Not the Latest, Media

#133

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Your mention of taste is interesting as https://www.criticker.com engine basically recommends movies based on other people who have liked and disliked the same movies as you liked other films and it’s really effective!

This is awesome will check out later. Is this site good for smaller/older/more obscure recommendations?

It seems to be? I get a lot of recommendations I’ve never seen before. I think if you rate a lot of non mainstream stuff it’ll pair you with people who do the same and voila - new non mainstream stuff!

Re: Enjoy the Best, Not the Latest, Media

#134
post #87

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Can you name a book or film that is popular 20+ years after it was first released that is bland? Even Disney films - the most idealistic in many ways - can hardly be considered bland. The typical Summer bland film or airport book which really is bland and overladen with tropes is rarely popular after a few years.

Older disney films are as bland as it gets. Is that even serious question?

You think a flying car is bland? Or a nanny who flies on an umbrella and who takes her charges to cartoon races?

Look again, and compare them to a Summer release rom-com.

Re: Enjoy the Best, Not the Latest, Media

#135
post #26

As someone who apparently frequents much more pretentious online film circles than OP, the idea that the highest rated films and shows on IMDB represent the "best" of the mediums is kinda silly. The article uses Star Trek (2009) as its example of a mediocre film. Its IMDB rating is 7.9/10 from over 500k votes over 11 years -- surely this would place the film squarely in the "tried and tested" category. If I look on s…

Your mention of taste is interesting as https://www.criticker.com engine basically recommends movies based on other people who have liked and disliked the same movies as you liked other films and it’s really effective!

https://www.last.fm has a similar engine for music

Re: Enjoy the Best, Not the Latest, Media

#136
post #59
post #53

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Reading is amazing. Writing must be even crazier, to think all of what Murakami wrote came from inside his skull, that he has not only created those characters, but they live inside his simulation and create him as well.

Dreams can be pretty wild too

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Dreams_(1990_film) and https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Waking_Life are two of my favorite films.

Dreams can be wild, but the writer manufactures their characters from their mind while conscious. The intention and the agency over the creation sets them apart.

I have had only a 1 or 2 lucid dreams, but I couldn't hold the dream state for any appreciable amount of time that I achieved consciousness in the dream world.

I wonder how many writers employ dreams in the creation of characters, if they dream about the stories they write?

Post reply on HN