Live data from Hacker News

Dickhead of the Week: Instagram CEO Adam Mosseri

daringfireball.net

131–140 of 202 posts

Re: Dickhead of the Week: Instagram CEO Adam Mosseri

#131
Apple seems to be on a PR offensive after a few weeks of bad press and it seems they are employing their usual bloggers to entertain the developer audience. I dunno why devs participate in this PR circus.

And btw the author is wrong about comparing to facebook’s platform, which is still the most open, free to use large platform out there.

Re: Dickhead of the Week: Instagram CEO Adam Mosseri

#132

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Which is still gambling, just on the contents of the next box. It’s obfuscating the gambling, and it’s unfortunately working.

That doesn't meet any definition of gambling I'm aware of. It's equivalent to having a daily sale on a set of products.

If you purchase a lootcrate, a new lootcrate is revealed for you. Sorry if that wasn’t clear.

Re: Dickhead of the Week: Instagram CEO Adam Mosseri

#133
post #35

Watch “The Social Dilemma” on Netflix, see how far off the rails the industry has gone, then come back and tell me that Apple is the bad guy here. Someone needs to start standing up for what’s right, and Apple is probably the only one with the size and cash reserves to be able to do it. For all the free market cheerleaders, remember this: we already have laws in place preventing or regulating businesses from engaging…

So what about all the other gaming apps on the iOS store? Literally thousands of them are specifically designed to get (trick) kids to spend money on them. Apple is more than happy to enable In-App purchases for them and then promotes them heavily through its own advertising on the app store. How is Apple not part of the problem in this whole system?

Apple and Facebook have both been sued for this. Facebook were literally calling it friendly fraud and trying not to prevent it.

https://www.forbes.com/sites/erikkain/2019/01/25/facebook-tu...

The FTC alleges Apple allowed the same thing on their platform for three years after they became aware.

https://www.nytimes.com/2014/01/16/technology/government-and...

But what's really amazing is Google, Amazon and Microsoft have all been sued for the same thing too and it still not illegal to have games where kids can spend unlimited amounts and conduct unlimited transactions using obfuscated virtual currencies.

Re: Dickhead of the Week: Instagram CEO Adam Mosseri

#134
post #46

Earlier quoted context omitted.

You've clearly never played Fortnite. Epic doesn't sell loot boxes, they sell skins. You get exactly what you pay for, there is nothing sketchy about it.

While I agree it’s not sketchy in that you get what you pay for, the true cost of what you are paying is obfuscated casino-style from their player base, which is mostly kids. Case in point, my son will want to spend 2500 vbucks on a skin until I put that into real dollars for him - “are you sure, that’s $25 of your money” (a bit less with package bonuses notwithstanding). Perhaps this is my penance for working on Far…

Worked at Zynga? Damn dog, you don't deserve any time at the mic regarding MTX.

Re: Dickhead of the Week: Instagram CEO Adam Mosseri

#135

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Which is still gambling, just on the contents of the next box. It’s obfuscating the gambling, and it’s unfortunately working.

Either way, Apple takes 30% of the revenue. Apple isn't standing up to Epic's gambling, they''re profiting a lot from it and their only issue with Epic seems to be that they want to keep profiting from it. The Epic and Apple case started when Epic circumvented Apple for in app purchases and lowered their prices accordingly.

They don’t get a commission for the sale of the Fortnight software, or for marketing Fortnight on their own dime; do you believe that they don’t deserve to get any commissions for providing Fortnight a platform and publicity?

Re: Dickhead of the Week: Instagram CEO Adam Mosseri

#136
post #85

Earlier quoted context omitted.

For Facebook at least, it's not about 'ads'. Personalised ads are a distraction. Not being able to track outside of their platform takes away the ability to extend the profile they are building around the user. Their customers are interested in this profile because they can use that information to manipulate the user. And we're not talking about choosing Bosch over Whirlpool for a new dishwasher...

You're weirdly obliquely referring to political ads. Those are ads.

Not just ads, but yes ads.

If I friend/follow a lot of people, and I have a simple timeline, I see what they're thinking about.

But if there's an algorithm selecting which posts I see from my social circle, and it happens to shade one way versus another, there are no ads, no synthetic content, but I have still been manipulated.

FB experimented with this quite famously a while back, they used sentiment analysis to see if they could manipulate people into being more or less depressed.

Without informing users, obtaining their consent, or following any of the other rigorous requirements for doing psychological research that we demand from medical proactitioners.

Re: Dickhead of the Week: Instagram CEO Adam Mosseri

#137
post #85

Earlier quoted context omitted.

For Facebook at least, it's not about 'ads'. Personalised ads are a distraction. Not being able to track outside of their platform takes away the ability to extend the profile they are building around the user. Their customers are interested in this profile because they can use that information to manipulate the user. And we're not talking about choosing Bosch over Whirlpool for a new dishwasher...

You're weirdly obliquely referring to political ads. Those are ads.

Yes and no. Yes, in the literal sence. Political ads like "Vote for John Doe; the law and order candidate" when you profile as a conservative is fine. Pushing "We send the EU £350 million a week, let's fund our NHS instead" when you profile as conservative isn't, because it's a lie designed to provoke a reaction and rile supporters. Or filling your feed not with just ads, but "news". Yes, that's paid for too.

Edit: braythwayt said it far more eloquently than I...

Re: Dickhead of the Week: Instagram CEO Adam Mosseri

#138
post #35

Watch “The Social Dilemma” on Netflix, see how far off the rails the industry has gone, then come back and tell me that Apple is the bad guy here. Someone needs to start standing up for what’s right, and Apple is probably the only one with the size and cash reserves to be able to do it. For all the free market cheerleaders, remember this: we already have laws in place preventing or regulating businesses from engaging…

>Watch “The Social Dilemma” on Netflix I'm sorry, but that show was really, really dumb and unrealistic and I couldn't sit through it. 3 engineers (notably: cringey white dudes) are never following one single user and controlling his interactions like that and it did more harm than good by pretending it works that way. This implies someone is directly accountable, showing up to work every day and fucking with people'…

Why bring up the skin color of the people in the show? What relevance does it have? And I am brown Incase you were wondering as I know skin color is important to you

Re: Dickhead of the Week: Instagram CEO Adam Mosseri

#139
post #35

Watch “The Social Dilemma” on Netflix, see how far off the rails the industry has gone, then come back and tell me that Apple is the bad guy here. Someone needs to start standing up for what’s right, and Apple is probably the only one with the size and cash reserves to be able to do it. For all the free market cheerleaders, remember this: we already have laws in place preventing or regulating businesses from engaging…

apple is perfectly happy for epic to sell loot boxes as long as they get a cut

Re: Dickhead of the Week: Instagram CEO Adam Mosseri

#140
post #15

I might be one of the few, but I like the ads I see on Instagram and have purchased lots of things via IG ads. I can’t think of any other app/site where the ads have sucked me in. I realize this is besides the point, but I thought it was worth sharing in terms of how they might be doing personalization. For me, it’s so good that it actually works.

Stop clicking on ads and start blocking them.
Post reply on HN