Live data from Hacker News

Medium is not the home for your ideas

hulry.com

131–140 of 377 posts

Re: Medium is not the home for your ideas

#131

I've been yelling about this for years, but please start & own your own blog. Use webflow, ghost or whatever you like, but wordpress is good enough for most people. HN audience can likely handle their own, but if ease-of-setup is an issue - I created StartABlog.com to help people do this (and we'll actually set up your site for you for free - https://startablog.com/start ). Own your platform. Own your content. Own yo…

[deleted]

Re: Medium is not the home for your ideas

#132
post #62

There's something dishonest about your profile appearing normal only to yourself, while the rest of the world is getting a 404. If you're suspended, fine, but tell the user, but why the need to hide this from them?

Soft/shadow banning. The idea is to make the spammer believe that he/she's still in the platform and they may only realize about the low engagement they have, so they may consider abandoning the platform.

If you mention them that they're banned, they might just use another account and persist in their spam.

The problem of this approach in this case is that user was not an spammer.

Re: Medium is not the home for your ideas

#133

Folks looking for a Medium alternative, please checkout https://diff.blog . It's an aggregator of developer and engineering blogs I built an year back. It has been growing steadily since. The reason why I built this was to solve the problem of disoveralibilty of self hosted blogs. It's hard for bloggers with self hosted blogs to reach a big audience. So a lot of them end up moving to a platform like Medium which give…

This is seriously awesome!

Is there plan for non-English blog posts? Dev community is mostly in English, but many blog posts around the world are in native language. Some blogs write in English and non-English and it's very hard for me to find content in my language.

This also prevents me from registering my blog on diff.blog as my blog contains English and non-English content.

Hope the best for your project!

Re: Medium is not the home for your ideas

#134
post #64

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I was going to ask a similar Q, but I'll hitch my comment to yours... (and give you an upvote as well) To get around Google thinking that your personal hosted version is a copy, can you pepper the medium version with links back to your domain/blog ? Would that help ?

Just use their import tool, it's designed specifically for that purpose. https://help.medium.com/hc/en-us/articles/214550207-Import-a... It sets up a canonical tag and backdates your post to prevent just that from happening.

That makes sense

Re: Medium is not the home for your ideas

#135

I've been yelling about this for years, but please start & own your own blog. Use webflow, ghost or whatever you like, but wordpress is good enough for most people. HN audience can likely handle their own, but if ease-of-setup is an issue - I created StartABlog.com to help people do this (and we'll actually set up your site for you for free - https://startablog.com/start ). Own your platform. Own your content. Own yo…

What's the best static site generator that meets the following requirements: a) Doesn't use node.js. b) Has built-in syntax highlighting for C#, SQL, PowerShell and Rust at a minimum. c) Is also good at "photo journals" or galleries. I played around with Hugo, but the themes were ugly and it was very weak at managing pictures associated with an entry instead of the entire site.

I recommend https://gohugo.io the speed of rendering makes it possible to write your posts with a close to realtime rendering response. It also has a big community and lots of themes available.

Re: Medium is not the home for your ideas

#136

For tech-minded people, a static site generator and github-pages is a great solution. Zero cost. Zero ads etc. Not likely to change or go away. Easy to move to paid for hosting Or GitHub’s next competitor if that is ever needed etc.

I guess that the issue here could be GitHub policies, maybe they don't like your post 'because reasons' and you're in the same situation as with Medium (I understand it's not as common).

The ideal case is that you own the platform.

Re: Medium is not the home for your ideas

#138
post #65

I've been yelling about this for years, but please start & own your own blog. Use webflow, ghost or whatever you like, but wordpress is good enough for most people. HN audience can likely handle their own, but if ease-of-setup is an issue - I created StartABlog.com to help people do this (and we'll actually set up your site for you for free - https://startablog.com/start ). Own your platform. Own your content. Own yo…

I agree. Many years ago I was really happy with medium as a reader. And the feed algorithm was decent enough. By no means the perfect content but for the most part it pushed forward things I was interested in. However, the monetization model turned medium(originally a decent blogging platform) into tumblr and it was a race to the bottom from that point. Any website that asks you to register in order to read a blog po…

> this is still a terrible thing to do.

What’s the alternative, assuming the blogger doesn’t want to give everything away for free?

Re: Medium is not the home for your ideas

#139
post #62

There's something dishonest about your profile appearing normal only to yourself, while the rest of the world is getting a 404. If you're suspended, fine, but tell the user, but why the need to hide this from them?

Indeed. It seems shady until you realize why sites do this. Probably the only way to truly understand is to run a site with user generated content for a while. There will be people using your site that just need to go away. They're different from your typical pharmaceutical spammer because they genuinely think they're not doing anything wrong. If you tell them to stop posting affiliate links to timeshares, they'll pu…

Appreciate that perspective, makes sense. But it's still fundamentally injurious to the other person, and furthermore, in an uneven power dynamic. Also, your power doesn't automatically mean you're right. I wonder how to solve it.

Maybe shadow banning is quite fair and necessary and the answer is for people to educate themselves about it and go to other places where it won't happen to them. #rollyourown

These matters are not simple at all. I'm still trying to decide on whether Fb ultimately is a 'public square' vs. a 'private publisher', as is basically the whole world.

Re: Medium is not the home for your ideas

#140
post #111

I've been yelling about this for years, but please start & own your own blog. Use webflow, ghost or whatever you like, but wordpress is good enough for most people. HN audience can likely handle their own, but if ease-of-setup is an issue - I created StartABlog.com to help people do this (and we'll actually set up your site for you for free - https://startablog.com/start ). Own your platform. Own your content. Own yo…

One thing you really miss when leaving Medium is the audience. It is easy for people search Medium for a topic they are interested in and find it within the first couple of articles. If you are trusting Google to be your entry point for traffic you have to play all kinds of gross games with your content for SEO purpose and if you are adding value to an already well explored topic there will be someone out there troun…

> and also Medium pay content authors really really well.

This to me is the key thing, and what Medium's stated goal was: to re-think the way we pay for content. You may feel fine giving away your content for free, but it's perfectly reasonable for people to want to be paid for the value they create, and I like Medium's model way better than advertising.

Post reply on HN