Live data from Hacker News

The crash of the global flower trade

bloomberg.com

131–137 of 137 posts

Re: The crash of the global flower trade

#131
post #17
post #10

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Not really. The response from the Dutch government was that they did want to help, but did not want to hold the responsibility for paying back the loan from the countries. Which would have been the case with Eurobonds. Instead, they wanted to help but had some financial reform obligations tied to it, which Italy and Spain were not happy with.

Not really. "Mr Hoekstra also infuriated some of his finance minister colleagues this week when he suggested that Brussels “investigate” why some economies did not have the fiscal headway to fight a downturn — a veiled dig at Italy and others for failing to reform in benign times. An EU diplomat quoted by Volkskrant described the slight as a “middle finger to the south”."

They are angry of course but is Mr. Hoekstra wrong factually or even arguably morally?

Re: The crash of the global flower trade

#132

Cut flower export sounds like climate travesty; they are not essential, they are fragile (requiring energy-intensive cold chain logistics and air-freight) and after all that effort... they have a shelf-life of a week. If there is an industry that should be strictly localized, it's this one.

The argument I regularly hear is that there would be more energy spent heating local greenhouses than flying the flowers.

Source?

Re: The crash of the global flower trade

#133

Cut flower export sounds like climate travesty; they are not essential, they are fragile (requiring energy-intensive cold chain logistics and air-freight) and after all that effort... they have a shelf-life of a week. If there is an industry that should be strictly localized, it's this one.

Completely agree. At the same time this wouldn't be the focus of my ire, look at the risk impact of July and beef production - a nightmare and arguably also not essential as we have cheaper, more resource efficient and more nutritious options.

Re: The crash of the global flower trade

#134
post #91

Earlier quoted context omitted.

They also propagate pests. The olive industry in Italy is being decimated and the flower trade is suspected to be at the root.

reference: https://www.theguardian.com/world/2019/sep/09/deadly-olive-t...

Thank you. This is quite worrisome to me personally, as my family lives on the south of Spain and a good deal of our livelihood is from olive farming. It feels like being tied to the railroad and watching a train barrel down toward you from the distance.

Re: The crash of the global flower trade

#135
post #8

I'm really sorry for the Dutch but their response to the crisis to Italy and Spain has been: "you should have saved some money!". I hope now they realize this crisis affects all in one way or another, either with direct deaths or with indirect sales crash, which can translate also into deaths. It's really hard for me now to feel pity for flowers when they didn't care about people dying...

Please don't take HN threads into nationalistic flamewar.

https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html

Not sure what it is about flowers that brought out such extremes this thread, but...wow.

Re: The crash of the global flower trade

#137
post #59

Earlier quoted context omitted.

When has it ever been fine to throw virgins into volcanoes? And slavery has always been opposed by huge numbers of people, theses things have never been considered "fine" or comparable to having flowers in a vase.

Whilst I agree with your general point, some of what you said isn't quite right. Human sacrifice has a long history. Though it was, as far as I'm aware, a rare and drastic thing to do. For example there were a few instances in classical Roman history when human slaves were sacrificed. This was done in very dire situations, think pandemic or important battle, and often in earlier Roman periods. It was also actually qu…

> having flowers in a vase is completely normal

Why?

Post reply on HN