Live data from Hacker News

Twitter forces all new users to enter a valid phone number

sucky.ninja

131–140 of 393 posts

Re: Twitter forces all new users to enter a valid phone number

#131

Handy tip: buy the cheapest pre-charged SIM and use it for this kind of verifications.

in the UK you can wander into any phone shop and get 5 SIMs for free

also: the phone companies allow you to receive SMS without putting a penny on them

Re: Twitter forces all new users to enter a valid phone number

#132

My wife and I cancelled our phone services a while back to save money since we rarely if ever have to call anyone and just use messaging to keep in touch with each other and friends. What are people like us supposed to do? I do have a Google voice number, but I noticed one or two places recently that won't accept that anymore.

> I do have a Google voice number, but I noticed one or two places recently that won't accept that anymore.

Mind sharing where? I've use my Google Voice number exclusively for 6 or 7 years now. Can't say I've ever ran into such a thing.

Re: Twitter forces all new users to enter a valid phone number

#134
post #102

Earlier quoted context omitted.

> twitter is just sillines Would you say the same about your phone number? If not, why? If I run my business on Twitter (or YouTube, or Facebook) is it that different from a bank?

No? I'm not clear on what the real point of this question is - twitter is a terrible platform to use for actual communication. Their sorting by "relevance" can cause recent messages to get lost in the shuffle and randomly mess with your visibility. It may be you're considering twitter as a business in which to coordinate product sales, but I'll assume it's for customer relations management, many companies that have a…

You may dislike Twitter (I do) but it is a large thing that exists and appears to provide sufficient value to people that dismissing it as 'silliness' just sounds empty-headed and naive.

Re: Twitter forces all new users to enter a valid phone number

#135

My wife and I cancelled our phone services a while back to save money since we rarely if ever have to call anyone and just use messaging to keep in touch with each other and friends. What are people like us supposed to do? I do have a Google voice number, but I noticed one or two places recently that won't accept that anymore.

If there are enough people like you, I'm sure they'll find some way to accommodate you. Maybe they will accept a scan of your passport or ask for a bank account number or some other piece of data that makes it at least a tiny bit harder to open an account.

Re: Twitter forces all new users to enter a valid phone number

#137

We're going this way as well (requiring & verifying phone numbers, not locking accounts). We don't have a problem with bots, but users in the "not so tech savvy" segment tend to switch/discard/forget their email address. Rather than try to recover their account with us, this group will subsequently just create a new one, and then wonder & complain that their profiles/settings/content/histories aren't carried over. We…

But why do you require phone numbers instead of offering them as an option alongside email? What about people who don't have a mobile number?

Re: Twitter forces all new users to enter a valid phone number

#138
post #86

Linking pseudonyms from two different networks (in this case, Twitter and the phone system) together is a classic and serious privacy leak. It's far from clear exactly what information Twitter, in its longtime effort to combat spam, has already collected on its users. Throwing a phone number into the mix expands to range of activities that can be unambiguously tied to the same individual. Given that Twitter certainly…

And they've been trying to collect phone numbers for years. Any time an account is suspended, they try to require a phone number for it to log back in, for example.

Re: Twitter forces all new users to enter a valid phone number

#139
post #60

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I agree. I would rather pay them some fee. But they don't seem to want to monetize their service via user fees.

Oh my god, paid Twitter would be amazing. Well, then again, something awful was a paid forum iirc, and it was still a den of villainy.

But on Something Awful, it was a feature, not a problem.

Re: Twitter forces all new users to enter a valid phone number

#140
post #120

The other component is that once they have the phone number, they can do anything with it they want, unless you leave the network. E.g. facebook once did the same, they required phone numbers "for two factor authentication". They promised to not use the numbers for anything else. A few years later they started sending SMS spam to users about what their friends did on facebook, and now facebook users can enter the num…

> Your only choice as individual user is to leave the platform.

That's not even enough anymore. You also have to make sure that every one of your contacts do not upload their address book to conveniently find friends like you who may or may not be on the network. And that they don't tag you in images, events, etc.

You're an entry in the Facebook database, whether you have or have had an active profile or not.

Post reply on HN