Live data from Hacker News

Dropbox (YC S07): Simple Tasks for Extra Space (768MB total)

dropbox.com

131–140 of 152 posts

Re: Dropbox (YC S07): Simple Tasks for Extra Space (768MB total)

#131
post #97
post #47

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Even less space is required. Dropbox stores duplicate files only once. So if many users store the same files the cost per user is practically zero. That's also the reason why uploads are so fast. If a file is already on the server it isn't uploaded again.

Is it really shared between accounts? So for example if I knew someone with Dropbox had a file that could have one of several contents and I wanted to know which of those contents they had I could try uploading the different versions and see which one uploaded faster? A little far fetched maybe, but I'm sure there's a way to exploit something somewhere using that....

Yes - this should work.

There are even other ways how you might be able to exploit this. I don't exactly know how Dropbox verifies if your file is already on the server. But if they only check a hash of the file it might be sufficient to know the hash of any file stored on Dropbox to gain access to the full file.

Of course, this is just a speculation and there might be more security precautions in place. Such as, e.g., sending the client various challenges about the hashes of particular byte ranges.

In addition, also the copyright implications of this are interesting. Consider that you've shared a directory with your friends and that you upload some copyrighted movie (that is already on their servers and not really uploaded). Are you then the one liable for the damages (if sued), or is the original (first) uploader of the file liable?

Re: Dropbox (YC S07): Simple Tasks for Extra Space (768MB total)

#133

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I'm a passionate amateur photographer, and after a bad crash where I lost years of work I became really neurotic about my multi-site recovery plan. Today I have Drobos and Time Capsules spread around my house and office, plus Dropbox and even a few rsync cron jobs all keeping me calm. Today, my Aperture library is 109GB, because I work with archival scans from medium format film. TL;DR: 100GB is a very small limit. H…

But do you really want to pull down 109GB on every laptop you install Dropbox on? Or would you manage that via multiple Dropbox accounts? From what I can tell, Dropbox hasn't yet tried out the "backup solutions" space, but I'm also hoping they will, as most of my machines are constantly running out of disk space.

> From what I can tell, Dropbox hasn't yet tried out the "backup solutions" space ...

I'd really love to see this too. Like a feature where you could choose whether you wanted to sync specific data or just back it up or something.

Re: Dropbox (YC S07): Simple Tasks for Extra Space (768MB total)

#134

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I'm a passionate amateur photographer, and after a bad crash where I lost years of work I became really neurotic about my multi-site recovery plan. Today I have Drobos and Time Capsules spread around my house and office, plus Dropbox and even a few rsync cron jobs all keeping me calm. Today, my Aperture library is 109GB, because I work with archival scans from medium format film. TL;DR: 100GB is a very small limit. H…

But do you really want to pull down 109GB on every laptop you install Dropbox on? Or would you manage that via multiple Dropbox accounts? From what I can tell, Dropbox hasn't yet tried out the "backup solutions" space, but I'm also hoping they will, as most of my machines are constantly running out of disk space.

There is a new feature called selective sync, which is available in the pre-release (>0.8) version of Dropbox [1].

https://www.dropbox.com/help/175

Re: Dropbox (YC S07): Simple Tasks for Extra Space (768MB total)

#135
post #89

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I was just thinking about this. This is the only reason that would keep me from switching to an ARM smartbook if a good one ever came out.

I'm sure if ARM based netbooks ever became actually popular Dropbox would take the time to compile an ARM version of the client.

Its a chicken and egg problem, really. Besides, I would appreciate the ability to wrangle my own dropbox client. From their api, it seems that each app which hooks into their API must have a secret key, so I wonder if an open-source client can be distributed minus the key.

Re: Dropbox (YC S07): Simple Tasks for Extra Space (768MB total)

#136
post #97
post #47

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Even less space is required. Dropbox stores duplicate files only once. So if many users store the same files the cost per user is practically zero. That's also the reason why uploads are so fast. If a file is already on the server it isn't uploaded again.

Is it really shared between accounts? So for example if I knew someone with Dropbox had a file that could have one of several contents and I wanted to know which of those contents they had I could try uploading the different versions and see which one uploaded faster? A little far fetched maybe, but I'm sure there's a way to exploit something somewhere using that....

Yes. I threw a 20MB e-book PDF into my Dropbox and it was instantly marked as uploaded. The only exploit would be that you could determine if a specific file was uploaded, not how many people had copies of the file or who those people were.

Re: Dropbox (YC S07): Simple Tasks for Extra Space (768MB total)

#137
post #5

Tell us why you love Dropbox = 128 MB. And to think of all the time and wasted energy we spent early on trying to get user feedback. Incentives are a wonderful thing!

It has been fun to watch this page: http://twitter.com/#!/search/i%20love%20dropbox

I noticed early Monday that lots of my friends were sharing their love for Dropbox on Twitter. Initially, I figured it was just impromptu declarations of love for the service. It wasn't until later that I discovered this page.

Re: Dropbox (YC S07): Simple Tasks for Extra Space (768MB total)

#138
post #109

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I wasn't at Dropbox particularly early, so that is more of a question for someone like Drew Houston. The first time I used the product, I knew it was awesome. The first time I talked to Drew about the big ideas, I knew it was going to be much bigger than what most people might think. The Cloud™ is one of those mega trends, and Dropbox is right in the middle of it.

It seems to me not a lot is going on from users point of views (features), did I miss something?

Isn't that the beauty of Dropbox? It just frickin works, you don't even notice it.

Re: Dropbox (YC S07): Simple Tasks for Extra Space (768MB total)

#139
The feature I need most. From the IPhone app, I would like to be able to select a file and email the file to myself or someone else - not the link to the file. Dropbox is blocked at work but sometimes I really need to get an important file from there. I'm a paying susbcriber. Keep up the good work!

Re: Dropbox (YC S07): Simple Tasks for Extra Space (768MB total)

#140

I work at Dropbox and came up with this page. Thanks for throwing confounding variables in this soft launch experiment, Hacker News. A few points that might interest yall: 1. We won't publish to facebook or twitter without your explicit permission. 2. We ask for information about your facebook profile because it will make Dropbox better. It's mainly about learning about our users without annoying surveys. We won't ma…

Why doesn't that Android client have the option to keep files sync'd? The whole point of Dropbox IMHO is to have your data when you need it, not maybe-if-I've-got-signal-and-I-can-wait-till-it's-transferred. At the moment The Android dropbox client is just a glorified SFTP client
Post reply on HN