Live data from Hacker News

The Water Abundance XPrize winner makes water from air

fastcompany.com

131–133 of 133 posts

Re: The Water Abundance XPrize winner makes water from air

#132

Earlier quoted context omitted.

the CO2 exhaust isn't really carbon neutral is it?

It's using 'current carbon' which is basically the same thing. Plants grow using CO2 in the air, we burn the plants and that CO2 is released again. If we just left the biomass to rot on the ground it'd produce CO2 and / or Methane depending on the type of decomposition it underwent. Verses plants and animals lived millennia ago, died, got compressed by huge geological forces and finally we come along and extract it a…

but we still need to manufacture ammonia etc for fertilizer to grow the next year's plants...

Re: The Water Abundance XPrize winner makes water from air

#133

Earlier quoted context omitted.

It's using 'current carbon' which is basically the same thing. Plants grow using CO2 in the air, we burn the plants and that CO2 is released again. If we just left the biomass to rot on the ground it'd produce CO2 and / or Methane depending on the type of decomposition it underwent. Verses plants and animals lived millennia ago, died, got compressed by huge geological forces and finally we come along and extract it a…

but we still need to manufacture ammonia etc for fertilizer to grow the next year's plants...

Need to is a bit of a stretch. Manure, urine, nitrogen fixing legumes are all potential fertiliser.

In addition growing deciduous crops rather than annuals and good soil management practices and can help reduce or eliminate additional fertiliser requirement.

Post reply on HN