Live data from Hacker News

Slack Said to Draw Interest from Amazon

bloomberg.com

131–140 of 236 posts

Re: Slack Said to Draw Interest from Amazon

#131

Whatsapp: 500 million users for $18b. Slack: ~10 million users for $9b? This doesn't make much sense to me. What's the rationale behind this?

Just guessing: Maybe the user base is more "business-y" and therefore valued higher than the general public?

Re: Slack Said to Draw Interest from Amazon

#132

Whatsapp: 500 million users for $18b. Slack: ~10 million users for $9b? This doesn't make much sense to me. What's the rationale behind this?

Those are 10mm mostly enterprise users. A lot of them are on paid plans on company budgets.

Different product means different user economics.

Re: Slack Said to Draw Interest from Amazon

#133

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Chime is for video. Slack is for text.

Chime is for both, it's just not very good at text.

You mean it's not very good at emojis, bot integration, and other fun features that exist with other platforms.

Re: Slack Said to Draw Interest from Amazon

#135
post #114

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Agreed. These purchases seem to work the best when they're used for defensive purposes and to round out a product offering that already has a substantial userbase . Whatever gadgets they might hang off the app, they're fundamentally a way for people to talk to each other. If you don't have the people, why would you need a slick implementation? As you mentioned, the app would go out of vogue and users would move on. A…

> Of all the mega-corps, Amazon is one of the few that has all the pieces and user-engagement, but no social component. Honest question, since I might be out of the loop here in Europe, but what user engagement pieces does Amazon have then ? I use Amazon for shopping and AWS, and would have no idea what other products they have that are dominating a market. Is this about Kindle ?

This would possibly be a first step for AWS to start moving up the stack.

Re: Slack Said to Draw Interest from Amazon

#136

Too late to buy, Slack is such old news now and their market is super saturated. This could have been a decent decision several years ago, but not now.

https://trends.google.com/trends/explore?q=slack

Although the search data would indicate Slack is still super hot - I tend to agree (anecdotally) that the market is saturated, first movers have already ... moved, and most likely growth will be slow.

Re: Slack Said to Draw Interest from Amazon

#137
I think it would make much more sense for Apple to acquire Slack. Both companies are known for their emphasis on good design and UX.

Slack and Amazon appear to have very difficult cultures, so that would be a very interesting acquisition. If I was an engineer at Slack, I would really, really hope that the company could continue to operate independently, as a subsidiary. I would not be happy if I was forced to work for Amazon for the next x months before I could cash out and leave.

Re: Slack Said to Draw Interest from Amazon

#138

Serious question..... but also more me fleshing out my thoughts on messaging apps.... What is the point in buying a messaging app? - instant messenger - ICQ - Skype - Yammer - WhatsApp They all seem to be popular for a short time and then fad away. What does owing one of these get a company? The case against owning them is that they all go out of favour and you only have a small window, say up to 5 years, where your…

We all asked the same question about Facebook. All social networks before Facebook had faded away. But, Facebook didn't. Potential Slack buyers think that Slack is also here to stay in a similar manner. EDIT: I'm not saying Slack is Facebook. One reason why I think Slack may survive longer than ICQ, Skype etc is how well integrated it is with all other services. For a tool to replace Slack, it should also provide the…

A consumer to consumer N-N network is much harder to coordinate a migration than a corporate N-N network, for one.

Also messengers aren't as N-N since you end up only talking to a small number of people after a while and don't actually want to move all your contacts.

I don't want to move all my FB contacts either but the number of connections I sort of care about is still likely more than 100.

Re: Slack Said to Draw Interest from Amazon

#139

Too late to buy, Slack is such old news now and their market is super saturated. This could have been a decent decision several years ago, but not now.

wouldn't it's have been a bad decision a few years ago considering you're saying it's old news now?

Re: Slack Said to Draw Interest from Amazon

#140
post #111
post #76

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Is all data on slack just available for viewing? If it were so I think its customers would have raised this as an issue by now.

Public slack, yes. But you also have enterprise slack, which is hosted on an organizations' own machines. I imagine they don't have access to that data.

There is currently no way to run Slack and store the messages on your owganizations own machines.
Post reply on HN