Live data from Hacker News

22 years in, Magic: The Gathering is the brainiest it’s ever been (2015)

avclub.com

131–135 of 135 posts

Re: 22 years in, Magic: The Gathering is the brainiest it’s ever been (2015)

#131
post #42

This is nowhere near the brainiest Magic has ever been. I've been playing almost since the beginning and it's been disappointing to see how the game has been simplified. It seems like all competitive standard decks now are creature decks, which is a shame because control and combo decks used to be a huge part of the meta game and required a lot of skill to pilot. I think Wizards deliberately eliminated combo and cont…

Are there any other games that are "Brainier" than Magic?

Doomtown

Re: 22 years in, Magic: The Gathering is the brainiest it’s ever been (2015)

#132
post #3

Does anyone else feel revulsion at the notion of a "mythic rare?" Magic feels like a cross between a brilliant game and a video poker machine.

It was pawned off on the community extremely well, most people were actually "glad" about it being introduced, and its purpose was hidden at the start. Originally, they were meant for cards that were too strange to come up often in limited play, so this slot was just to get the weird effects to show up less in drafts. However, over time, it turned into every single card that would be a great high priced single turns…

Mythics didn't get sold as a way of rarefying complexity (you're thinking of the New Order revisions). Mythics were just a blatant ripoff of the Pokemon TCG (or a precursor), like foils were 9 years earlier. Here's what MaRo wrote in that article[1] you mentioned:

> Magic is the only major trading card game currently printed with only three rarities. If we want to stay competitive in attracting new players we have to keep up with the industry standards.

> We want the flavor of mythic rare to be something that feels very special and unique. Generally speaking we expect that to mean cards like Planeswalkers, most legends, and epic-feeling creatures and spells.

[1] http://magic.wizards.com/en/articles/archive/making-magic/ye...

Re: 22 years in, Magic: The Gathering is the brainiest it’s ever been (2015)

#134
post #37

Earlier quoted context omitted.

> You would probably spend you $15 to go see a two hour movie I wouldn't. > spending under $7.50 per hour That's absurdly expensive.

The average price of a movie ticket is $8. The average price of the popcorn is also $8. (Lots of citations with a Google search.)

Yea, I would not see a movie in theaters, and I haven't for years.

Re: 22 years in, Magic: The Gathering is the brainiest it’s ever been (2015)

#135
post #37

Earlier quoted context omitted.

> You would probably spend you $15 to go see a two hour movie I wouldn't. > spending under $7.50 per hour That's absurdly expensive.

Is it? Flying a plane is $500 an hour. Golfing a good course is $100 an hour. Waterskiing can be $50 an hour. Skiing is $20?? An hour. Recreation is serious stuff in the US.

Flying a plane isn't $500/hr unless you're flying first class, and it's not exactly what I would call entertainment or recreation. I wouldn't do the rest of it, anyways.
Post reply on HN