Live data from Hacker News

Publicly Funded Research Should Be Publicly Available

eff.org

131–135 of 135 posts

Re: Publicly Funded Research Should Be Publicly Available

#131
post #3

"Be publicly available" you mean available to everybody on earth even though they have not funded it ?

I asked a similar question a few weeks earlier.

The current system has foreign distributors receiving research papers practically for free, and reselling them for money world wide.

In many ways that is worse than freely available world wide.

it could be argued that they are mostly paying through prestige.

Re: Publicly Funded Research Should Be Publicly Available

#132
post #123

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Again, the post was addressing the absurd proposal that "If your university takes any federal money , all research has to be open."

All research the university does is different than all research the professor does. As long as they are at a university being funded by the public, the public has a claim to the research. If they want to do private research, they can switch to the private. If a person is being paid by the public, why should they be able to spend their time and resources working in private? Think of it like a general IP ownership agre…

The thing is how academics are actually paid doesn't work like that.

"The university" is not funded by the public. It's funded by Federal money, and State money, and tuition, and commercial grants and donations. Just claiming that's "being funded by the public" is claiming 100% of the output, while not providing 100% of the input.

Similarly, I'm not paid from a single source. I'm paid through a mix of state money, federal money, and yes, some commercial grants. If a commercial entity wants to pay for a portion of my lab's expenses and salary, why should "the public" be entitled to the proceeds?

That's the problem being argued against - not that public money should mean public access, but that "some public money" (no matter how small) suddenly entitles the public to everything.

Re: Publicly Funded Research Should Be Publicly Available

#133

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Steam doesn't work on 'any Linux' without jumping through many many hoops for most distros.

Which have you had problems with. I work Ubuntu Based, Fedora, and Arch have had no issues on these.

Gentoo to name one.

Re: Publicly Funded Research Should Be Publicly Available

#134
post #59

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Steam doesn't work on 'any Linux' without jumping through many many hoops for most distros.

While this used to be the case, with Valve's steam machines they seem to have a native client now[0]. [0] https://developer.valvesoftware.com/wiki/Steam_under_Linux

This is still the case, they had a native client for a while, but it is 32-bit and only well supported on Ubuntu and very similar distros.

Re: Publicly Funded Research Should Be Publicly Available

#135

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Which have you had problems with. I work Ubuntu Based, Fedora, and Arch have had no issues on these.

Gentoo to name one.

I had zero issues installing Steam and CS on my Gentoo workstations (two of them). This was 2 years ago.
Post reply on HN