Live data from Hacker News

Life in a Studio Apartment with My Wife and Two Sons

gregkroleski.com

131–140 of 187 posts

Re: Life in a Studio Apartment with My Wife and Two Sons

#131

Earlier quoted context omitted.

That has its own set of trade-offs. Prepare for at least an hour commute each way by BART if you work in SOMA, for instance.

Huh? I literally live at the end of the line and my commute is 30 minutes...

I used to commute via BART from Pittsburgh in the East Bay and it was easily an hour on BART alone.

Re: Life in a Studio Apartment with My Wife and Two Sons

#132
This is one reason I think we should do a type of zoning in-between urban and suburban. Even if you divide a normal residential suburban lot into 9 pieces, if you do two stories, then every little lot could contain 578 square feet, which is 178 square feet more than their 400 square feet apartment.

http://runvnc.github.io/tinyvillage/

Re: Life in a Studio Apartment with My Wife and Two Sons

#133
post #19

This isn't so bad. The Netherlands is the most dense population of any country outside Taiwan and families dwelling in small spaces continues to this day. There is a 12-member family spanning 3 generations all living in the same small house next door to me. Our tiny 60 square meter home is considered normal for our area. By American standards, SF seems like tight living, perhaps. But by world standards, space is not…

> Our tiny 60 square meter home is over 50% larger than the one in the article? It's the difference between a studio and a nice one bedroom, or maybe even cramped 2 bedroom.

That really depends on how the space is arranged. I'm in just about that size, but my place is wheelchair-accessible with room for attendant care, so the bathroom is huge compared to normal, the entrance corridor is nearly wide enough for, say, a Smart ForTwo (or a chair with a drip and someone alongside), so the basic living area works out to "small bachelor/studio". That's a bit extreme, but a bad layout can really eat into the usefulness of your floor space without a corresponding drop in cost.

Re: Life in a Studio Apartment with My Wife and Two Sons

#134

There are Orthodox Jewish families in Israel which have very few rooms for very large families. (Among the ultra-Orthodox in Israel the fertility rate is 10 children per family). Often these families have very little income which includes state support for their large families, and esp in large cities such as Jerusalem can little afford larger accommodations. In SF, NYC (where I live) and other US localities, the iss…

> Among the ultra-Orthodox in Israel the fertility rate is 10 children per family

There are not typically 10 children at once in the home BTW. The older children will be away at school, around 14 for boys, 17 for girls.

What you do is have 3 bedrooms: parents, boys, and girls. Depending on the boy/girl ratio you can have up to 2 triple-bunk-beds in a room.

Doing that you can easily sleep 12 children in the house (if you had to).

There is no living room, instead there is a dining room with a huge table (large enough to seat everyone at once) that doubles as a multi-purpose room for homework, and other activities.

Children are encouraged to play outside (there's hardly room inside).

For possessions there is not usually a need to store much since you'll pass things on to other people, your children, relatives, friends, neighbors, etc. and they with you, so most items are in active use. (For example, once the kids are older and you don't need a triple-bunk-bed you pass it on to someone else.)

This also means you don't need to spend as much as you might expect on stuff. If you don't have a lot of money you can go your entire life without once buying new clothes, or other gear for the kids.

Re: Life in a Studio Apartment with My Wife and Two Sons

#135
post #89

This is off topic, but in March 2016, I'll become a dad for the first time and I was wondering if some more experienced parents could answer a question for me. That article has a black board with a tally of diapers changed today. The count was up to thirty. Is that somewhat accurate/possible??? If so, holy shit, I'm investing in cloth....

Congratulations! 30 seems high but not off the chart for a young baby.

My main comment, though, is that modern diaper technology is the bomb and you should definitely not go for cloth.

1. strips that change color so you can see with a glance from across the room if they need a change (if baby just wearing a diaper)

2. the wicking effect and absorbent substance in the diaper really do keep the baby's skin dry, even when they pee their diaper (not 100% but way better than cloth)

3. baffles around the thigh made of various materials prevent leakage in ways washable diapers cannot

4. well-designed diapers are super easy to put on, and more importantly, to take off and convert into a sealed bundle of mess -- they have integrated tape fasters not only to keep the diaper on the baby, but also to fold it up into a little kind of poo burrito, fastened with tape

But all those features are just minor differentiators, what you are fundamentally paying for when you buy disposable diapers is "not having to store and deal with a mountain of small towels with human feces on them". It's way, way worth it.

Here in Tokyo I pay about ¥13 per diaper, delivered by Amazon. It works out to about USD $40-60 per month per kid in diapers.

The only argument for cloth diapers is perhaps the pollution one, although I have heard (and want to believe) that the energy consumed and detergent pollution makes the difference insignificant.

Still, you are committing bag after bag of plastic into the landfill with disposables. But... if I had to improve my "eco" rating, disposable diapers would probably be the very last thing I looked at. You will have so many things to deal with when your baby is born -- anything that makes that easier is worth it and disposable diapers help several times every day.

Re: Life in a Studio Apartment with My Wife and Two Sons

#136

What's a good way of storing clothes if you don't have a closet?

I live in Japan, where a lot of people live in spaces that small (and smaller). My wife and I did too (before having kids though) and what is common in Japan is these expandable bars that you can put up between any two strong walls.

In our case, we put one up over the middle of our bed, and hung all our clothes on it (even hanging-optional stuff like T-shirts). You had to kind of tunnel through it when getting into bed, but this let us make use of the otherwise useless airspace over our bed. It also formed a kind of soft wall or curtain that made the area where your head was darker than the rest of the main room. That was handy when one person wanted to sleep and the other was still working.

Re: Life in a Studio Apartment with My Wife and Two Sons

#137
post #93
post #91

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Parent here. That is a common thought amongst new parents - the cost of disposable nappies. However, when you factor in the cost and time of keeping the cloth nappies clean then there may not be much difference at all. I recall reading somewhere (don't have a reference sorry) that cloth nappies are more environmentally damaging than disposables, perhaps due to the additional energy used for washing, or the impact due…

That's very interesting - thanks so much for sharing your experience with me!! I'll rethink the idea of cloth!! :)

Read an article about this a while ago, can't remember exactly where. This is location dependent. In places where there's tons of water cloth is better. Where there's little water, disposables are environmentally better.

Re: Life in a Studio Apartment with My Wife and Two Sons

#138
post #89

This is off topic, but in March 2016, I'll become a dad for the first time and I was wondering if some more experienced parents could answer a question for me. That article has a black board with a tally of diapers changed today. The count was up to thirty. Is that somewhat accurate/possible??? If so, holy shit, I'm investing in cloth....

30 is very high. ~16-18 is a reasonable top end, and doesn't last very long (maybe 1-2 months at most).

Re: Life in a Studio Apartment with My Wife and Two Sons

#139
post #7

The more I read such articles, the more I think you'd have to be nuts to choose to live in San Francisco. And yet, clearly, plenty of people do choose to live in San Francisco.

Eh I moved my family (stay at home wife and two kids). If you are willing to live outside of the trendy areas you can find OK places. Unfortunately single family homes (like we inhabit now) are not rent-controlled. We're currently trying to decide between moving to a multi-unit building with a 3-bedroom place or staying and putting up with the ridiculous rent. The multi-unit building would still be high rent but at least it would be locked in forever.

It definitely costs my startup employer (and myself), especially factoring in preschool. It also steals a job and "juice" from the local economy - we'd have already hired a nanny if rents were merely 2x a normal city, and we'd happily spend more buying from local craftspeople. The money goes into my landlord's retirement account basically doing nothing.

Re: Life in a Studio Apartment with My Wife and Two Sons

#140
post #89

This is off topic, but in March 2016, I'll become a dad for the first time and I was wondering if some more experienced parents could answer a question for me. That article has a black board with a tally of diapers changed today. The count was up to thirty. Is that somewhat accurate/possible??? If so, holy shit, I'm investing in cloth....

No, 30 is too high, but you will have very frequent changes during the first few months. I'll echo other advice: wait a bit, the poop often comes in phases.

By the time they hit six months it is less frequent, then after a year you may only have 3-6 diapers a day.

Remember with cloth that you have to scrape the poop into the toilet, you can't just toss it in a bag and have a service come pick it up (in which case you aren't saving money anyway).

I'm as environmentally conscious as anyone but disposable diapers are one of the few luxuries I choose to enjoy and I don't regret it for even a second.

Post reply on HN