Hacker News Board Hacker News, browsed like a classic message board
Live data from Hacker News

Android Is Peeing on an Apple in Pakistan - Google Maps

google.com

Post reply on HN
Print view View original

121–130 of 200 posts

Re: Android Is Peeing on an Apple in Pakistan - Google Maps

#121

Post by iamdanfox »

drewhk wrote: post #30

Just for fun speculation. What if someone realized that Google is scraping/using his data. Then he decided to put in a "honeytoken" to check this assumption and at the same time pull a prank on Google. Once he realized that his assumption was correct, he published the coordinates -- as a mini revenge. Of course this is just some idle speculation, but I have seen honeytoken entries in printed dictionaries for example.

Otto Lindberg did exactly this to for a whole town in the 1930s!

Amazingly, the fake town (called 'Agloe') "became real — and then, strangely, undid itself and became a fantasy again" [1]

[1] http://www.npr.org/blogs/krulwich/2014/03/18/290236647/an-im...

Re: Android Is Peeing on an Apple in Pakistan - Google Maps

#122

Post by rmc »

johnjamesjacoby wrote: post #103
jblz wrote: post #15

Earlier quoted context omitted.

One can only hope that if this was intentionally done by an employee, they would be punished and possibly let go. This sort of thing is childish, unnecessary, and has no place in a professional organization. Quasi-related: http://jenmylo.com/2015/03/23/defending-drupal/

I'm discouraged by the replies to this comment. At best, this is a digital-urine covered Easter egg. At worst, it's a tasteless prank that will likely have repercussions for it's creator. And the level of effort required to complete this is unequal to it's hilariousness, so if nothing else, I find it likely whomever is responsible for this wastes a bunch of other time and resources in similar, unproductive, disrespec…

Actually it serves a very useful purpose. It demonstrates that Google Map Maker quality is highly unknown, that there essentially is no review process.

At least OpenStreetMap is honest and upfront and doesn't pretend there is a quality assurance team.

Re: Android Is Peeing on an Apple in Pakistan - Google Maps

#123

Post by V-2 »

madez wrote: post #19
anc84 wrote: post #10

Don't use OpenStreetMap they said, anyone can edit that and vandalised it they said, it will be full of errors and inaccuracies they said.

Also, never use Wikipedia for anything. Since everybody can change it, it's useless.

Well, I certainly wouldn't use it without crosschecking facts ;)

Re: Android Is Peeing on an Apple in Pakistan - Google Maps

#124

Post by joeblau »

ilamparithi wrote: post #114

Another gem here :) https://www.google.pt/maps/place/Takht+Pari+Forest/@33.50087...

Do you essentially have to be a Google employee to do this? I remember a few years ago when I annotated some custom maps, but no one ever saw my annotations publicly. Also my annotations were running routes and forest trails that weren't marked on maps at the time.

Re: Android Is Peeing on an Apple in Pakistan - Google Maps

#125

Post by minikites »

madez wrote: post #19
anc84 wrote: post #10

Don't use OpenStreetMap they said, anyone can edit that and vandalised it they said, it will be full of errors and inaccuracies they said.

Also, never use Wikipedia for anything. Since everybody can change it, it's useless.

Wikipedia is actually pretty bad, try following up on any of the references. If they're web references, the chances of it being a 404 page are almost 100% in my experience. Not to mention the editors being almost all white men and the opaque process that limits most "non-male" topics: http://www.dailydot.com/lifestyle/wikipedia-college-classes-...

Wikipedia is basically infotainment, the Buzzfeed of encyclopedias. See also: Wikigroaning: http://www.somethingawful.com/news/wikigroaning/

> For example, the article called "Knight." Then, find a somehow similar article that is longer, but at the same time, useless to a very large fraction of the population. In this case, we'll go with "Jedi Knight." Open both of the links and compare the lengths of the two articles. Compare not only that, but how well concepts are explored, and the greater professionalism with which the longer article was likely created."

Wikipedia is no substitute for a real subject encyclopedia.

Re: Android Is Peeing on an Apple in Pakistan - Google Maps

#126

Post by notahacker »

madez wrote: post #19
anc84 wrote: post #10

Don't use OpenStreetMap they said, anyone can edit that and vandalised it they said, it will be full of errors and inaccuracies they said.

Also, never use Wikipedia for anything. Since everybody can change it, it's useless.

Ironically, many pages of Wikipedia are useless because they're so difficult to permanently change...

Re: Android Is Peeing on an Apple in Pakistan - Google Maps

#128

Post by emodendroket »

aslammuet wrote: post #98
c_plus_minus wrote: post #59

Can't help but feel that if it were a similar prank pulled by Apple on Android, the comments wouldn't be half as forgiving.

Why he choose Pakistan?

I'm guessing that it's easier to sneak bogus edits in for Pakistan than for, say, New York City.

Re: Android Is Peeing on an Apple in Pakistan - Google Maps

#129

Post by EricBart »

happyscrappy wrote: post #87
c_plus_minus wrote: post #59

Can't help but feel that if it were a similar prank pulled by Apple on Android, the comments wouldn't be half as forgiving.

It is more appropriate for the Android demographic.

Don't take this too seriously.

Re: Android Is Peeing on an Apple in Pakistan - Google Maps

#130

Post by chiph »

Varkiil wrote: post #120
sjcsjc wrote: post #115

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Oh well, since we're on the subject http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Butt_Hole_Road

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/La_Mort_aux_Juifs They had some weird tastes in city names back then

Careful, you might end up in a https://www.google.com/maps/@35.8947544,-78.5993332,20z
Post reply on HN