Live data from Hacker News

Please remove mitsuhiko/*

github.com

121–130 of 445 posts

Re: Please remove mitsuhiko/*

#121

The tip4commit website is vulnerable to Heartbleed: https://filippo.io/Heartbleed/#tip4commit.com Don't sign in or register or you may have more to worry about than undesired tax liabilities. EDIT: It's fixed now.

Did you tell them? EDIT: I did https://github.com/tip4commit/tip4commit/issues/147

I'm sure he sent them a notification about their new account on his website on which, if they create an account, they may or may not find information of value to them.

Re: Please remove mitsuhiko/*

#122
post #87

I do not normally rant, but tip4commit and its ilk are some of the most infuriating people in the world to deal with, since they're opting other people's projects into something that has all sorts of legal/taxation consequences and think that "we have no way to remove you once you get opted in" is an acceptable answer. I'd push complaints further up to GitHub, since I'm sure something in the way this works violates t…

Those projects are in the public domain. If there are purposes that you don't want your project to be used for then forbid it in the license. When you put your contact information in the public domain and then complain about being notified when somebody has given you money, I feel like you're complaining just for the sake of complaining. Set up filter rules or don't put your contact information on the internet. If I…

> Those projects are in the public domain.

This is completely wrong.

> If there are purposes that you don't want your project to be used for then forbid it in the license.

This is completely inapplicable.

> If I was denied the chance to receive a donation for a contribution I made to an open source project essentially because the "project owner" doesn't agree then I'd be very annoyed.

Start your own project.

Re: Please remove mitsuhiko/*

#123
post #94

Earlier quoted context omitted.

If a project name was trademarked, you might be able to get them for trading on that name, maybe?

Can you trademark open source project names?

Absolutely. Mozilla, Firefox, OpenOffice, Apache, Debian, etc are all registered trademarks and can not be used by others without permission.

Re: Please remove mitsuhiko/*

#124
Even ignoring all the legal implications, it's pretty damn rude to reach out to people contributing to open source projects on their own free time without asking for anything in return and offer them a few measly dollars for hours of work.

Re: Please remove mitsuhiko/*

#125
The Django project has done their complaint the right way. They asked to be removed, voiced the reason why and then have threatened to open a complaint to the email provider, Mandril, for unsolicited email, i.e. spam. See here: https://github.com/tip4commit/tip4commit/issues/111

This is probably the tactic that people should use for sites that do email mining and unsolicited emails. Good for them.

Re: Please remove mitsuhiko/*

#126
post #91

Earlier quoted context omitted.

> How can there be taxation consequences unless ... Tax? Perhaps not, but the OP was talking about tax and other legal consequences. These can vary wildly from country to country. My local legislation requires applying for a permit before asking for donations. If a 3rd party would add my projects to this website, I could face criminal charges and the proof of burden would be on me.

you say 'before _collecting_ donations'. just don't _collect_ if you don't want to.

soliciting contributions in UK. Moot point as to how someone else soliciting a contribution on your behalf without your permission is seen.

I think that people who set Web services up really need to think about what territory the service is designed to operate in and which legal system(s) they have the time and resources to examine.

Re: Please remove mitsuhiko/*

#127

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Maybe contacting their hosting provider could be an additional way to approach the problem, since, from what I can tell, the messages they send to contributors are spam.

We (Django) already threatened that a while back. They still insist they will not remove projects or stop collecting donations on behalf of non-consenting projects. All they did was manually disable some of the spam coming toward our committers.

Who holds the trademark for Django? That person or organisation might have standing in some jurisdictions to ask for it to be removed.

(IANAL, TINLA)

Re: Please remove mitsuhiko/*

#129

The tip4commit website is vulnerable to Heartbleed: https://filippo.io/Heartbleed/#tip4commit.com Don't sign in or register or you may have more to worry about than undesired tax liabilities. EDIT: It's fixed now.

Thank you very much! I am quite surprised because I remember fixing this issue in the same day patch became available and I run update recently. Upgrading the distro, hopefully it fixes the problem.

Re: Please remove mitsuhiko/*

#130
post #91

Earlier quoted context omitted.

> How can there be taxation consequences unless ... Tax? Perhaps not, but the OP was talking about tax and other legal consequences. These can vary wildly from country to country. My local legislation requires applying for a permit before asking for donations. If a 3rd party would add my projects to this website, I could face criminal charges and the proof of burden would be on me.

you say 'before _collecting_ donations'. just don't _collect_ if you don't want to.

I should have said: you need permit before asking for donations (corrected in GP). As I said, if my projects were listed on this site, I could face criminal charges, regardless whether any money ever changes hands.
Post reply on HN