Live data from Hacker News

Persona makes signing in easy for Gmail users

identity.mozilla.com

121–122 of 122 posts

Re: Persona makes signing in easy for Gmail users

#121
post #91

The problem with persona is that it sends the same identifier to all websites (nominally your email address). That makes it super-easy for those websites to feed your activity to a central tracker like DoubleClick which will consolidate all usage information from all DoubleClick affiliated websites. Persona would be a lot more privacy-preserving if it generated a unique identifier for each website. A "persona" for ea…

To be fair, this is not really Persona's responsibility. Pre-Persona, if you used the same email address on every signup, you already enabled this sort of tracking. With Persona, you'd have to take the same precaution of having multiple Personas if you wanted multiple personas :).

Also some people do want a single identity for the entire Internet, or at least a lot of it. Many people use the same real-name identifiers on HN, Github, LinkedIn, etc. professionally.

Re: Persona makes signing in easy for Gmail users

#122

Earlier quoted context omitted.

The main things are ubiquity, ease of use, and privacy. - Persona works with any email address. This means you can reach anyone that hits your site, without forcing them to sign up with a third party provider. - I can answer the question "what email address do you want to log in with?" I can't answer the question "what is your OpenID?" nor can I remember which of the 13 buttons on Stack Overflow I used last. - OpenID…

http://profiles.google.com/xistence/ Or that was my Google OpenID at one point, not sure if it still acts like one or not.

While the HN community understood that, my mother was never going to grasp the idea of ownership of a URL as a login credentials. Many people don't even understand URLs and just Google for everything they want.

Email addresses have been used as login credentials for a while, so people are used to that. The explanation of Persona might be a little weird, but it's not as totally disabling to a nontechnical user as being asked to sign in with OpenID.

Post reply on HN