Live data from Hacker News

Gun Mistakes in Fiction Writing: Handgun Edition

swiftsilentdeadly.com

121–122 of 122 posts

Re: Gun Mistakes in Fiction Writing: Handgun Edition

#121
post #29

I guess my pet peeve of "firing an arrow" is also a gun mistake of sorts. It can be found in many fantasy books. A bow is not a gun, there's no gunpowder involved. If a commander orders his archers to "fire" what should they do, set their bows on fire?

What's the correct term? Loose? I'm sure I've heard that before. I know nothing about arrows except to identify the pointy end.

"Loose" is kind of for a volley of arrows, not aimed, just pointing in the general direction of the attacking horde. Otherwise, you shoot them, not fire them. In English.

Re: Gun Mistakes in Fiction Writing: Handgun Edition

#122

Earlier quoted context omitted.

More justified for what?

IT mistakes are frequently glaring plot-holes that render entire sections of the story impossible. Gun mistakes are generally a choreography problem, a weapon that's possible but just hasn't been manufactured, or someone learning information about the gun's state via the wrong channel (where such an information channel does exist). Sure, sometimes a bullet impact throwing someone off a cliff is plot-relevant, but I c…

So... you cannot track anyone through their GPS because GPS is receive only.

You can "hack" their phone and get the location data from there, but I think the "we'll track them through their GPS" crap predates smartphones.

Post reply on HN