Live data from Hacker News

Chrome removes claim of On-device Al not sending data to Google Servers

old.reddit.com

121–130 of 261 posts

Re: Chrome removes claim of On-device Al not sending data to Google Servers

#121

I know that I'm in a bit of a bubble with this one, but I am surprised there is still anyone using Chrome instead of Brave. I get the dependency on Gmail other Google-specific tools, but the built-in ad blocking and Google-free aspects of it made me switch instantly and haven't look back after years.

"I am surprised there is still anyone using Chrome instead of Brave."

Bubble indeed. No one should use Brave.

Re: Chrome removes claim of On-device Al not sending data to Google Servers

#123

It seems to me that adding AI to desktop apps and sending the data back to the mothership for processing is an amazing way to collect data from people who, for the most part, would be completely unaware it's even happening. Heck, most of them think the Internet is Chrome.

You mean that chrome is an internet explorer?

Re: Chrome removes claim of On-device Al not sending data to Google Servers

#125
post #96

My belief is that the AI business is all about data collection. The value isn't so much in the quality of the models (that's what enterprise customers and developers pay to get), but in the amount of data that comes "for free" to whoever hosts the models. And then it's worth whoever buys it thinks it is, like insurers or advertisers.

Yeah I was wondering how long it would take for a browser company to do something like this. It lets them scrape data without having to deal with anti-scraping provisions on websites, since now their training data collection gets spread across the entire Chrome userbase and they're able to offload the work of bypassing the Cloudflare captchas or whatever to their end users.

Re: Chrome removes claim of On-device Al not sending data to Google Servers

#126

It seems to me that adding AI to desktop apps and sending the data back to the mothership for processing is an amazing way to collect data from people who, for the most part, would be completely unaware it's even happening. Heck, most of them think the Internet is Chrome.

I called this out when it was announced on here. Supposedly the team lead replied to my comment saying this wouldn't happen. I rolled my eyes but asked will android be able to use those models for ex filtration. No reply. And apparently the original claim was not true either lol.

Maybe I'm misremembering it. Google is awful. My goodness. I hate Android and can't wait to be rid of it. Graphene and it's buddies can't roll it fast enough

Re: Chrome removes claim of On-device Al not sending data to Google Servers

#128
post #49

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Because some things only work in Chrome. It's a fact. It's terrible. We're the frogs being boiled, over the last decade. People sounded the alarms, but they were looked at like they had tin foil on their heads. Now, it's clear they were right. I'm speaking generally, of course. I use Firefox for all my personal stuff, except for those situations where it doesn't work.

>> Because some things only work in Chrome. What things? Looks like an urban myth.

The driver and store signup/portal for doordash returns a 403 forbidden on firefox.

Re: Chrome removes claim of On-device Al not sending data to Google Servers

#129
post #96

My belief is that the AI business is all about data collection. The value isn't so much in the quality of the models (that's what enterprise customers and developers pay to get), but in the amount of data that comes "for free" to whoever hosts the models. And then it's worth whoever buys it thinks it is, like insurers or advertisers.

Yes. It is seriously not a coincidence that all of the ai companies are now offense contractors for the department of war. It's also not a coincidence they want to ban vpns, and force people to verify themselves with IDs, biometrics and their phones for all of their activities. Meanwhile... Bots can run free.

Surveillance capitalism is so stupid.

Re: Chrome removes claim of On-device Al not sending data to Google Servers

#130

Surely there's a googler on here who actually knows whether they are doing this. Anyone actually know or is this post all about Chrome bashing and speculation?

Certainly. You think they're going to comment? That itself would be another headline article.
Post reply on HN