Live data from Hacker News

GitHub is down again

githubstatus.com

121–130 of 425 posts

Re: GitHub is down again

#121
Anyone have alternatives to recommend? We will be switching after this. Already moved to self-hosted action runners and we are early-stage so switching cost is fairly low.

Re: GitHub is down again

#123
List of company-friendly managed-host alternatives? SSO, auditing, user management, billing controls, etc?

I would love to pay Codeberg for managed hosting + support. GitLab is an ugly overcomplicated behemoth... Gitea offers "enterprise" plans but do they have all the needed corporate features? Bitbucket is a joke, never going back to that.

Re: GitHub is down again

#124
post #11

They should have just scaled a proper Rails monolith instead of this React, Java whatever mixed mess. But hey probably Microslop is vibecoding everything to Rust now!

Team is doing resume driven development

Re: GitHub is down again

#125
GitHub is the new Internet Explorer 6. A Microsoft product so dominant in its category that it's going to hold everyone back for years to come.

Just when open source development has to deal with the biggest shift in years and maintainers need a tool that will help them fight the AI slop and maintain the software quality, GitHub not only can't keep up with the new requirements, they struggle to keep their product running reliably.

Paying customers will start moving off to GitLab and other alternatives, but GitHub is so dominant in open source that maintainers won't move anywhere, they'll just keep burning out more than before.

Re: GitHub is down again

#126

3 outages in 3 months straight according to their own status history. https://www.githubstatus.com/history

I think the last major outage wasn't even two weeks ago. We've got about another 2 weeks to finish our MVP and get it launched and... this really isn't helpful. I'm getting pretty fed up of the unreliability.

Re: GitHub is down again

#127
post #74

What are good alternatives to GitHub for private repos + actions? I'm considering moving my company off of it because of reliablity issues.

Gitlab.com. CI is super nice and easily self hostable.

I heard that it's hard to maintain self-hosted Gitlab instances

Re: GitHub is down again

#128
It feels like GitHub's shift to these "AI writes code for you while you sleep!" features will appeal to a less technical crowd who lack awareness of the overall source code hosting and CI ecosystem and, combined with their operational incompetence of late (calling it how I see it), will see their dominance as the default source code solution for folks using it to maintain production software projects fade away.

Hopefully the hobbyists are willing to shell out for tokens as much as they expect.

Re: GitHub is down again

#129
post #6

Of course they're down while I'm trying to address a "High severity" security bug in Caddy but all I'm getting is a unicorn when loading the report. (Actually there's 3 I'm currently working, but 2 are patched already, still closing the feedback loop though.) I have a 2-hour window right now that is toddler free. I'm worried that the outage will delay the feedback loop with the reporter(s) into tomorrow and ultimatel…

have you considered moving or having at least an alternative? asking as someone using caddy for personal hosting who likes to have their website secure. :)

You are talking to the maintainer of caddy :)

Edit- oh you probably meant an alternative to GitHub perhaps..

Re: GitHub is down again

#130

That pink "Unicorn!" joke is something that should be reconsidered. When your services are down you're probably causing a lot of people a lot of stress ; I don't think it's the time to be cute and funny about it. EDIT: my bad, seems to be their server's name.

One of Reddit's cutesy error pages (presumably for Internal Server Error is similar) is an illustration that says "You broke reddit". I know it's a joke, but have wondered what effect that might have on a particularly anxiety-prone person who takes it literally and thinks they've done something that's taken the site down and inconvenienced millions of other people. Seems a bit dodgy for a mainstream site to assume all of its users have the dev knowledge to identify a joking accusation.
Post reply on HN