Live data from Hacker News

Slow social media

herman.bearblog.dev

121–130 of 148 posts

Re: Slow social media

#121
post #92

I was about to say "Disallow forwarding". The problem with most networks (and in the old days, even emails), was that the bulk of the material I'd get from people I personally know were not original content, but memes, humor, or political content being forwarded. But this may serve an equivalent purpose: > And finally, there should be a reasonable cap on the number of times a user can post per day. Roughly 5 times pe…

>Roughly 5 times per day feels like the upper threshold of what you can post while being intentional about what it is you're posting

Not sure about social media, but in the days of forums I posted way more thoughtful and helpful posts on the forum I attended.

(I'll be honest, I didn't read the post yet. I'm doing this now)

Re: Slow social media

#122
>I think there should also be a reasonable cap on the number of connections that can be made. Something like 300 friends sounds right

What about a requirement "at least one direct interaction in a year"? Maybe with a reminder "you didn't catch up with X in 11 months, are you still connected"? This will both:

* Achieve the main reason of social network existence, i.e. give people an excuse to have a chat with a former friend and keep in touch. I sometimes thing about messaging a person I knew years ago, but it feels awkward enough that I don't do it usually.

* Naturally limit the number of connections, because now having connectione require (small but still) work. A very small dopamine addicted users may still try to collect connections, but I feel like this platform will be hostile enough for them and they will leave anyway, not finding what they want from SM.

Re: Slow social media

#123
I'm building an app builder (getmocha.com) and one of my favorite use cases I have seen is "small private social network":

some people are building custom, tailored social networks only available to their family, church, community, sports team, school, etc...

This was previously impossible but now AI changes that. I don't know if it will materialize, but a more federally distributed web with tons of small private social networks could be a future of healthy social

Re: Slow social media

#124

I'm building an app builder (getmocha.com) and one of my favorite use cases I have seen is "small private social network": some people are building custom, tailored social networks only available to their family, church, community, sports team, school, etc... This was previously impossible but now AI changes that. I don't know if it will materialize, but a more federally distributed web with tons of small private soc…

Yes, just put people in charge of the algorithm.

The feed (etc.) algorithm could be written in natural language and executed by AI.

Re: Slow social media

#125

I'm building an app builder (getmocha.com) and one of my favorite use cases I have seen is "small private social network": some people are building custom, tailored social networks only available to their family, church, community, sports team, school, etc... This was previously impossible but now AI changes that. I don't know if it will materialize, but a more federally distributed web with tons of small private soc…

>This was previously impossible

Isn't this what Mastadon is?

Re: Slow social media

#126
As a small +1 — I built mood.site to be an easy way to share galleries of images with people. The idea being like "hey send me some photo inspiration for the party we're planning" and having a throwaway way to do that (kind of like a pastebin for images).

People definitely use it for this, but what has really surprised me is people's capactiy for expression inside of the bounds of the program I created, and how people are clearly using in as a sort of ad hoc social network of loosely collected boards and inspiration. There are no actual _social_ features in the app (no discovery, etc.), but what has been sort of inspriring is that The Will is just there for people to find ways of expression outside the idea of a "feed" and "posting".

I think those models have indeed become synonymous with "social media", but my only point here is to bring up a possibility of "social media" as something that can be much more expansive and look very different compared to the primary models we think of today.

Another person favorite of mine along the same lines is how the comments section of this Pilsburry recipe for "veggie pizza" has become it's own sort of ad-hoc social media for grandmas to share their own experiences with each other about the dish: https://www.pillsbury.com/recipes/veggie-pizza/4b2c60ae-69e5...

Re: Slow social media

#127
I relate to so many points here. I have a desire to share my thoughts and ideas, but no format (except for my personal blog) feels right.

Just started building autogram.bio to help people create their personal corner of the web, and this post was exactly the motivation I needed to continue. Thank you!

Re: Slow social media

#128
Media was always already social. If I email my friend a link to a YouTube video, is the Internet a social network? I think what we think of when we think of 'social media' or a 'social network' is an integrated platform that lubricates particular potentials, like being able to create and share content with friends and fans. But there are other ways to realise those potentials, including ones that require the interfacing of different platforms (or media, in the McLuhanian sense), or what might be perceived as different platforms at one scale, and the same platform at another scale, as per my Internet example. And, the multiplicity of platforms, and the interfacing between them, might confer additional advantages and open up yet more potentials.

Re: Slow social media

#129
post #93
post #47

The author invented and then dashed against the rocks a few existing fediverse platforms in the course of a couple paragraphs. These things already exist and struggle exactly because people comfortable with the walled garden approach forgot what FB was like in 2006 when you only knew 15 people on there. The lack of critical mass of your personal contacts outside of the walls is exactly how FB and IG keep you from ven…

Do any of those networks limit the number of posts you can make a day? Do they limit forwarding? Or give users an option not to be shown forwarded messages? For me, unlimited posts (or rather, minimal friction in posting), and blind forwarding are what destroy social media. If you can make only 3 public/group posts a day, chances are lower they will be crap. I'm on Mastodon. It's only very mildly nice. The reality is…

> I'm on Mastodon. It's only very mildly nice. The reality is that it still suffers from all of this.

Most of it, at least - it does give the option to not be shown forwarded messages. There's controls on the home timeline to not show boosts, quotes, and/or replies.

Re: Slow social media

#130
Strava is the closest thing to effective social media that I use, because it is 'slow'.

You create 'content' by doing something orthogonal. You pay for access vs selling attention for ads. You only look at Strava when you are working out, so engagement is authentic vs contrived/performative. I care about my friend completing a run because I know they did it.

One of the best thing they did was allow the chance to add photos.

Post reply on HN