Live data from Hacker News

The car is not the future: On the myth of motorized freedom

blog.scaramuzza.me

121–122 of 122 posts

Re: The car is not the future: On the myth of motorized freedom

#121

Earlier quoted context omitted.

tokyo contradicts your statement.

How? No roads and only rail everywhere? Point-to-point transport that cost pennies? No waits for things to arrive? Tokyo with it's huge sprawl seems like the absolute antithesis of a 15 minute city.

for first, most people do not own cars and do everything via public transport/bicycle.

plus. it is often faster to use public transport than using a car, and cheaper...

supermarkets, grocery stores, hospitals, offices, appartments have generally no or little parking spots.

you will have to find dedicated parking spots which are pretty expensive, and will in fine have you walk around as if you were going to the station...

oh and yes, as i mentioned before lots of apartments don't have parking spots, so you will have to walk some to get to your car, and you will have to pay a hefty sum to rent the parking spot.

there are dentists/hairdressers/grocery stores/restaurants pretty much everywhere in tokyo. use google maps and try by yourself you will see.

people haul their stuff by hand or with their bikes.

people who don't have a very specific reason to own cars simply don't... there is no point. the building where i live has way less car parking spots than units (and it is illegal to own a car without a dedicated parking spot in japan).

people who have cars are generally one of: - do not actually live in tokyo - go in and out of tokyo often - need for work (cargo) - hobby / family need (haul a lot of stuff regularly or enjoy driving)

i'm specifically talking of tokyo, outside of tokyo you will find lots of parking spots and cars.

Re: The car is not the future: On the myth of motorized freedom

#122
post #69

Earlier quoted context omitted.

As an over 60 age is kind of an issue. Ebikes sort it though.

E-bikes help us to get up and down hills, but the safety issue doesn’t go away. Response times are slower across all sorts of dimensions (detection, response, mitigation, etc.), and an accident is more likely to end in hospitalization or actual death, e-bike or no. Well-traveled bike trails sound like fun, but I think it’s a no-go for general transport for the elderly. You can do it at that age, but I’m guessing the…

I guess it depends how elderly. For my kind of age group it's good. When you get to needing a walking stick maybe not a bike, although mobility scooters are kind of ebikes with extra wheels.
Post reply on HN