Live data from Hacker News

Google fires employee who protested Israel tech event, shuts forum

cnbc.com

121–130 of 368 posts

Re: Google fires employee who protested Israel tech event, shuts forum

#121

When I was at Google, Google was systematically silencing Arabs and Palestinians. They had brought in a specific team to comb through memegen and silence any pro-Palestinian (literally pro the people, while anti Hamas) messaging. While I was there, multiple Googlers actively reached out to me and other Arabs and asked them "Do you support Hamas?" These also weren't just low-level employees either. I had these experie…

[flagged]

Re: Google fires employee who protested Israel tech event, shuts forum

#122

Earlier quoted context omitted.

This needs to be emphasized more. It's not that they took a stance, it's definitely how they did it that warranted being fired over it.

What's a good way to take a stance?

I mean, this may be a good way to take a stance, for someone who deeply cares about a particular issue. But it's also definitely going to result in being fired, from any company. The two things aren't incompatible. Lots of good ways to take a stance have deprived lots of people taking those stances of far more than just their jobs, like their freedom, temporarily in many cases (like Dr. King) and permanently in many others (like Navalny). Making a stand is often laudable, but also often personally consequential.

Re: Google fires employee who protested Israel tech event, shuts forum

#123
post #61

Earlier quoted context omitted.

[flagged]

The ICJ didn't rule on whether or not Israel was committing genocide. It said Israel needed to take the steps to not commit genocide. https://www.reuters.com/world/middle-east/key-takeaways-worl...

The case against Israel brought forth by South Africa states quite clearly South Africa asserts Israel is violating the Genocide Convention [0]. The ICJ never corroborated this claim meaning there was not enough evidence to substantiate it.

[0]: https://www.icj-cij.org/sites/default/files/case-related/192...

Re: Google fires employee who protested Israel tech event, shuts forum

#124

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Honest question: Is this a common function of a union? For instance, I don't seem to recall hearing much about auto-workers taking ethical stances and being protected from termination by their union. But it's also not something I've paid much attention to, so maybe this is indeed something unions do. I'm genuinely curious.

The UAW recently called for a ceasefire: https://uaw.org/uaw-statement-israel-palestine/

That is not the same as what I asked about.

Re: Google fires employee who protested Israel tech event, shuts forum

#125
Lately it seems that more and more rank-and-file employees believe that a company has some sort of moral obligation to take their political opinions into consideration. Corporations aren't democracies. Unless you're an executive or high ranking decision maker, you're along for the ride. I don't ask my kids for their opinion about my home budget, what house I should buy, etc. So it is at work.

Expecting a company to kowtow to your belief system betrays a conceited/pretentious view of the world around you. If you don't like the job, leave it.

Re: Google fires employee who protested Israel tech event, shuts forum

#126
post #37

Earlier quoted context omitted.

A lot of work can be inherently political. If your company pivots into mass surveillance is it unreasonable to speak up if it's against your ethics framework?

That's the beauty of the free market, you have the freedom of choice. You can vote with your wallet or your feet. You can leave if your personal ethics and morality no longer align with the organization you're working for. A business doesn't owe you a paycheck simply because you think you're on the moral high ground.

I'm not saying you're entitled to a paycheck - a company has the right to fire you for your differences in politics. But if you frame it as a relationship, communication can help both sides as long as it's done with some mutual understanding. There are times companies listen to their employees and change their stance. And if they don't then you still have the ability to leave. That said it also matters how differences in views are expressed, I doubt there are many cases where yelling is effective..

Re: Google fires employee who protested Israel tech event, shuts forum

#127
post #61

Earlier quoted context omitted.

[flagged]

The ICJ didn't rule on whether or not Israel was committing genocide. It said Israel needed to take the steps to not commit genocide. https://www.reuters.com/world/middle-east/key-takeaways-worl...

But it remains a court order in which carries the full weight of the ICJ.

https://global.upenn.edu/perryworldhouse/news/explaining-int...

Re: Google fires employee who protested Israel tech event, shuts forum

#128
post #61

Earlier quoted context omitted.

[flagged]

ICJ was not asked to convict Israel of committing genocide. That was not in the initial ask. The ask was to force Israel to stop its military operation. The ICJ's provisional verdict was _actually pretty bad_ for Israel: "The aforementioned facts and circumstances are sufficient to conclude that at least some rights of the Palestinians to be protected from acts of genocide and related prohibited acts in Article 3 of…

[flagged]

Re: Google fires employee who protested Israel tech event, shuts forum

#129
post #86
post #2

> Google fired an employee who disrupted an Israel executive’s conference keynote this week, CNBC has learned. Rightfully so. Name me the big tech company who wouldn't fire such an employee instantly.

The employee clearly wanted to be fired, wanted to vilify the company, and wanted the news to broadcast the matter. Who in their right mind who says “I refuse to build technology that ____” wouldn’t already be planning to quit barring outrageous hypocrisy? Who in their right mind screams it out in the middle of a presentation without expecting to be dragged out?

Quite possible, in which case he's likely achieved his goal.

Personally I don't think firing him helps Google's PR, rather it makes them look even more "evil". (To clarify, I am NOT saying that it is unexpected for a company to fire such a person. Expectations != what's the morally correct != reality, I'm just commenting on a part of the equation.)

Re: Google fires employee who protested Israel tech event, shuts forum

#130
post #74

Is there a word for the "If I don't get paid for building a baby-killing-machine someone else will" type of regressive attitude that many self-deluded contrarians exhibit in the tech industry? Many such people would be diligent VW/Mercedes/Tesch and Stabenow/Degesch employees during WW2.

[flagged]

Imagine being such a pseudo-contrarian that you say you'd be an employee of the makers of Zyklon B (Tesch and Stabenow/Degesch) with the words "I would, with no regrets".

This is "Professionalism" to you, jfc.

Post reply on HN