Live data from Hacker News

Epic says Apple will reinstate developer account

9to5mac.com

121–130 of 653 posts

Re: Epic says Apple will reinstate developer account

#121

Earlier quoted context omitted.

It won't end, Apple is too big now, the alternatives are: 1. Split Apple into smaller companies 2. Operate Apple like an utility company They did this to themselves, and it's only downhill from this point.

> They did this to themselves What...by being successful?

No, by being anti-competitive. Most countries have laws against monopolies, and it was naive to expect that countries would wait until you destroy the competition to enforce those laws.

Re: Epic says Apple will reinstate developer account

#122
post #77

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Yes, and that's why monopolies must die, in practice desolved by governments. Once you buy a smartphone today you and everybody who wants to do further business with you are at the mercy of a monopolist. For Apple 100%, for Google only 98% because you could side-load. But not a secure and practical solution today.

I don't think monopoly is the right word here.

True. I like the term "gatekeeper" the EU defines and uses.

Combined with the "must be very big" requirement it better fits what is going on in the tech world.

Re: Epic says Apple will reinstate developer account

#124
post #3

This is just so weird to watch. Apple is literally throwing a tantrum on a continent-wide stage. Like, it's one attempt at escalation after another, and they keep losing (either their legal fights, or their nerve) and having to reverse course. Like, there's no strategy at all here? Just keep swinging and hope you land a blow that breaks through the armor? This is how my 15 year old plays VR games.

[flagged]

Re: Epic says Apple will reinstate developer account

#125

Earlier quoted context omitted.

As was said, this is normal in the US. Private businesses can refuse service to anyone for any reason. There's that paint color that is allowed to be used by all but one person because the inventor doesn't like them. On the other hand, I'm definitely not saying this is okay or sane just because it's standard practice in the US. It's also how we got legalized segregation and we had to pass laws carving out exceptions…

> Private businesses can refuse service to anyone for any reason. There are enough really obvious counterexamples to that statement that I wonder why you'd write it.

Indeed. I think this "Private businesses can refuse service to anyone for any reason." as been repeated so many times, that a lot of people think of it almost as a tautology.

In particular in this case, we have many pass example where even in the US, companies have be found to violate anti trusts law be either refusing or strongly conditioning doing business with a third-party.

Re: Epic says Apple will reinstate developer account

#126

Not trying to start a flame war, I'm asking this earnestly. Where does this command over hardware (USB-C mandate), software (sideloading/AppStore), and prices (recent 2bn decision) end?

It won't end, Apple is too big now, the alternatives are: 1. Split Apple into smaller companies 2. Operate Apple like an utility company They did this to themselves, and it's only downhill from this point.

> Split Apple into smaller companies

Curious, how would you split them up? A lot of their stuff is very intertwined, I guess Beats, Shazam are easy to split into their own, but the rest?

Re: Epic says Apple will reinstate developer account

#127

I’m so tired of this Apple tax, I think nobody would be this annoyed if Apple were saying 10% or something around that. 30% is more than most companies pay in tax on profits and this is a tax on revenue. I don’t think abusing your market position like some kind of protection racket should be allowed and if you don’t like it we’ll delete your App is quite frankly just as bad as the mafia smashing in shop windows. I do…

[flagged]

Re: Epic says Apple will reinstate developer account

#129
post #77

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Yes, and that's why monopolies must die, in practice desolved by governments. Once you buy a smartphone today you and everybody who wants to do further business with you are at the mercy of a monopolist. For Apple 100%, for Google only 98% because you could side-load. But not a secure and practical solution today.

I don't think monopoly is the right word here.

So you change your smartphone every time you are not happy with Apple or Google Android?

Yes, you have a choice once every couple of years while you might want to install an app several times a year. Free markets would also be the wrong word to describe the situation.

Re: Epic says Apple will reinstate developer account

#130
Apple’s behavior largely makes sense given what a huge share of their profits their racketeering of customer access earns them. If you ever wanted to see regulation pains as the cost of doing business, this is it.

But banning epic was just pathetic baby behavior.

I hope epic launches the epic game store for iOS and its dogshit but cheaper and the gacha gravy boats all jump ship

Post reply on HN