Live data from Hacker News

Electricity Prices by Country

electricrate.com

121–130 of 312 posts

Re: Electricity Prices by Country

#121
post #92
post #51

If you are asking yourself why prices in Germany are so high: It's mostly the price surge of natural gas after Russia cut off deliveries in retaliation to sanctions in the wake of the war against Ukraine. About 50% of the price per kw/h in Germany is set by an auction system. Electricity providers are bidding at any given point in time to provide energy for the grid. The lowest price per kw/h wins. BUT: because no on…

> all bids that are necessary to satisfy the demand are considered and the final price is set by the most expensive bid within that range What’s the logic here? Why not just accept bids in order of ascending price until demand is met?

Because then, providers would try to guess the highest bid and bid $1 lower. As every bidder would miss once in a while, that loss would be factored in prices, and raise prices overall.

This bidding system ensures that everyone can publish their lowest bid with no fear of losing out, and by doing so, it maximizes publicly available data so regulators and TSOs have a good idea of what is actually available and which investments are necessary.

Re: Electricity Prices by Country

#122
post #99

Is the price in Germany so high because they made the somewhat rash decision to shut down their existing nuclear generation and move back to fossil fuels? Given their location in the world I'm guessing both solar and wind are marginal producers.

Wind and solar are far from marginal: 50% renewables in 2022: https://www.energy-charts.info/charts/energy_pie/chart.htm?l... Prices are also lower than in France, but not the residential prices which are affected by taxes and fees while capped in France.

Maybe that was the wrong word. Wind and Solar would be more expensive per kWh due to the geography than in countries like Sudan.

Re: Electricity Prices by Country

#123
post #81
post #68

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Household prices are meaningless in this context, because they are artificially kept low in France and sometimes are affected by taxes and fees elsewhere. Here are spot marked prices: https://tradingeconomics.com/france/electricity-price https://tradingeconomics.com/germany/electricity-price

Interesting. In many states in the US, cost per Kw/H is lower for businesses, even very small ones, than for residences.

Kw/H -> kWh

It really is quite impressive to write a 3-letter unit with 4 errors.

Re: Electricity Prices by Country

#124
post #84

One little thing that stuck out: The USA leads the way in terms of household electric usage in the world – an average US household consumes approximately 975 kilowatt-hours of electricity each month, three times more than for example the United Kingdom. Which got me wondering how big US domiciles are versus those in the UK. Turns out: lot of big-ass houses here in the US. https://shrinkthatfootprint.com/how-big-is-a-…

Not only that, I used more heating in LA than in France (900m above sea level) because all the places I lived at had single pane windows that couldn't even physically close

Re: Electricity Prices by Country

#125
post #121
post #92

Earlier quoted context omitted.

> all bids that are necessary to satisfy the demand are considered and the final price is set by the most expensive bid within that range What’s the logic here? Why not just accept bids in order of ascending price until demand is met?

Because then, providers would try to guess the highest bid and bid $1 lower. As every bidder would miss once in a while, that loss would be factored in prices, and raise prices overall. This bidding system ensures that everyone can publish their lowest bid with no fear of losing out, and by doing so, it maximizes publicly available data so regulators and TSOs have a good idea of what is actually available and which i…

[deleted]

Re: Electricity Prices by Country

#126
post #51

If you are asking yourself why prices in Germany are so high: It's mostly the price surge of natural gas after Russia cut off deliveries in retaliation to sanctions in the wake of the war against Ukraine. About 50% of the price per kw/h in Germany is set by an auction system. Electricity providers are bidding at any given point in time to provide energy for the grid. The lowest price per kw/h wins. BUT: because no on…

> It's mostly the price surge of natural gas after Russia cut off deliveries

I already paid twice as much per kwh as my friends who stayed in France, that was the case since 2017

Since the Russian gas episode I pay 3-4x more

Re: Electricity Prices by Country

#127
post #110
post #84

One little thing that stuck out: The USA leads the way in terms of household electric usage in the world – an average US household consumes approximately 975 kilowatt-hours of electricity each month, three times more than for example the United Kingdom. Which got me wondering how big US domiciles are versus those in the UK. Turns out: lot of big-ass houses here in the US. https://shrinkthatfootprint.com/how-big-is-a-…

I'd guess that a far bigger factor is that the US has a much higher percentage of houses the use electricity for room heating. I believe that it is similar for water heating. In the US there is also a high percentage of houses that use electricity for the stoves and oven and for clothes drying. A brief didn't turn up how much electricity is used for those things in the UK, but if it is like much of the rest of Europe…

>In the US around 26% of houses use electricity as their only energy source, compared to around 9% for the UK.

Something that was interesting to me when I moved from California to central Oregon was that nearly everything was powered by electricity. I didn't even know anybody with a gas stove in Oregon.

Re: Electricity Prices by Country

#128
The article seems to claim a source of data, yet then goes on to publish conclusions wildly inconsistent with that source data.

In the Netherlands we currently pay on average ~0.40€/kwH which is about $44. That should earn it a place at the top of countries paying the most. According to the article, it's not even in the top 20.

And that's me low balling the 0.40€/kwH as for over a year now it has fluctuated between that and > 0.60€. And it's with energy taxes temporarily lowered, it would have been even higher otherwise.

Re: Electricity Prices by Country

#129
post #74

I'm incredibly lucky to live in Quebec, Canada: 100% green hydro power at low rates. Tarif D has the first 40kwh at 6.509 Canadian cent/kWh, then 10.041 [0] It's also state owned. From what I've seen it's the best combo of green and pricing in the world. 0: https://www.hydroquebec.com/residential/customer-space/rates...

Same in Seattle.

100% hydro.

Zero emissions.

0.11 USD per kWh.

Owned and operated by the City of Seattle, not a profit-making corporation.

Re: Electricity Prices by Country

#130
post #54

Earlier quoted context omitted.

To think there were nuclear reactors already built and running perfectly fine in Germany. That were closed down presumably for ecological reasons. Burning coal and natural gas instead.

Not just any coal, but lignite, the nastiest, dirtiest kind of coal. Definitely greener than nuclear. /s

And yet Germany has fewer CO2 emissions per kWh of electricity produced than the USA.
Post reply on HN