Live data from Hacker News

The cameras worked fine, but their maker said they had reached their end of life

wsj.com

121–122 of 122 posts

Re: The cameras worked fine, but their maker said they had reached their end of life

#121

Earlier quoted context omitted.

> at that point the repairs are likely beyond more than a subset of people. Replacing a hard drive trivial, though. But in any case, if someone doesn't want to do such maintenance every decade or so, there are repair shops that will do it for them.

A hard drive under constant write load is unlikely to last a decade. And replacing them in some of these devices isn't trivial (even if the physical connector is straightforward, how many of them understand receiving a new drive that needs formatting, how do you get to the panel to do it, etcetera etcetera). In isolation, the smartest thing a hardware vendor could do is make this process difficult so you give up and…

Interesting. The video system that I use is a cheap one (and doesn't require internet access, but optionally supports it -- I don't even have it on a network of any sort at all).

Replacing the hard drive in it couldn't be easier. You do have to remove four screws to get into the box, but once there, you just unplug the old one and plug in the new one. When you power it up, the box notices that the hard drive is new and asks you if you want it to be prepared for use (with requisite warnings about losing any data that may be on it). If you click "Yes," it does what it needs to do and starts using it.

Aside from opening the case, my grandmother could handle this without any problem at all.

I simply assumed that better systems than mine would be as easy, but perhaps I assumed too much.

Re: The cameras worked fine, but their maker said they had reached their end of life

#122
post #3

This problem will only be solved by legislation. If countries seek to reduce e-waste they need to force electronics makers to ensure a minimum length of support on the same conditions as existed on the date of sale - say 10 years.

More government regulations?

Why not?
Post reply on HN