Refinancing at 2.5% is the closest I have ever been to winning the lottery. I can't imagine trying to buy a house or finance a car right now, especially with dealers charging crazy ADMs. Something is going to have to give.
I wish there was a p2p lending program where I could make some cash and people with good credit could borrow for better rates than banks offer.
U.S. mortgage interest rates jump to 7.16%, highest since 2001
121–130 of 297 posts
Re: U.S. mortgage interest rates jump to 7.16%, highest since 2001
#122Financial Ignoramus here - looking back - were ultra low rates a mistake? It seems insane that this number has grown so much since even last year. Would slowly growing them over a longer period have been better than these huge jumps? It seems wrong that I refinanced a 500k mortgage last year and I would be paying ~35% less per month than someone who did the same thing today.
The truth is were rates not "low" the US would have probably have entered a period of either extremely slow growth, recession or out-right deflation over the last decade. Reason being there is such a thing as the neutral rate of interest which is basically the interest rate require to keep inflation at a constant pace if you go above or below that inflation is likely to start increasing or decreasing.
What central bankers are basically trying to do is keep core inflation somewhere around 2-3% so the value of money is stable, but it also doesn't pay to horde cash. Then when you get to that 2% target you want to try to keep rates around the neutral rate of interest to remain at that 2% inflation target.
This idea that I suspect you're heard that interest rates were "ultra low" assumes that there is some normal rate of interest which there isn't - the average rate is different for different economies. The appropriate interest rate simply depends on the economic conditions - specifically growth trends. As real economic growth slows interest rates will naturally need to fall which is why they have been trending down in the US and other developed economies for decades now.
Now where I think people are specifically going wrong here is that there is no dangerous or irresponsible level for interest rates. What's dangerous about interest rates isn't the level, but the change. For example were interest rates closer to 5% over the last decade then they suddenly shot up to 20% in 2022, that isn't any better than what we see today. Because what matters here isn't the specific rate of interest, but how affordable debt is and that affordability can only be assessed in a relative manner.
So where mistakes are made imo is in excessively sharp cuts to interest rates followed by excessive hikes. I'd argue that yes, what's been happening since Covid has been so extremely irresponsible it's almost beyond belief. But if you're going to claim interest rates were "low" you need to explain what you mean. Do you mean relative to the neutral rate or relative to what they were during a pervious period in time when economic conditions were completely different? The former is a valid conversation to have, the latter simply asserts that the historic average, or the rate at some specific point in time is the correct rate for today which is an argument that holds little merit.
Re: U.S. mortgage interest rates jump to 7.16%, highest since 2001
#123If rates go from a low of 2% up to, say, 9%, then in order to keep the mortgage payment the same, the price of a $400,000 house would have to drop to around $230,000. This assumes a 30-year fixed rate mortgage, and the details will vary depending on money down, etc. but the basic fact remains that house prices will need to fall by a lot, down to levels of 5 years ago or more, before the current interest rate hiking c…
Most of the people I speak to who locked in Current renters will have lower potential to save on a monthly basis, only to get 30-40% off on their first home with a >7% interest rate. If you sum the lost savings from rent plus the additional interest payment, it is uncertain whether that is the best strategy. That is also assuming real estate prices in certain regions wont hold stronger value, which they probably will…
Most people don't plan on selling their house when they buy it. Life usually forces you into the situation.
Re: U.S. mortgage interest rates jump to 7.16%, highest since 2001
#124Several comments here state very confidently that either the commenter does not plan on moving for many years, or someone they know has similar plans. The problem with this line of thinking is to keep a brave face when the house is underwater, meaning that the house can not be sold without going into debt to pay it off. As "homeowners" approach that point, panic starts to take hold. Nobody wants to be trapped in a ho…
It is recommended that when you buy a house you buy it long term 5+ years. It is recommended that when you purchase index funds as investment you buy and hold long term 5+ years. The reason for this is because prices will fluctuate SHORT term, but generally are very stable long term and provide a return on investment. If we take a look at the current situation, even if someone becomes underwater on their house, they…
US history over the last 3 decades suggests otherwise.
Re: U.S. mortgage interest rates jump to 7.16%, highest since 2001
#125Earlier quoted context omitted.
A credit union I used for my house which had competitive rates has very good rate for new auto loans. It is about 4.09% for 4-5 years.
I'm sorry are you saying 4.09% is a good rate? Anything 2% or lower is a good rate, my house was 4% back in 2019.
Re: U.S. mortgage interest rates jump to 7.16%, highest since 2001
#126Isn't there "midterm" elections coming up in two months in the US? Aren't moves like spiking the rent to induce mass unemployment likely to benefit the Republican party? It can't be a winning strategy.
https://www.reuters.com/markets/europe/central-banks-raise-r...
Re: U.S. mortgage interest rates jump to 7.16%, highest since 2001
#127Great news - affordable housing is around the corner! This will also deep-six people speculating on real estate or buying homes to AirBnB them (won't be profitable). All good news.
They only become "more affordable" if you have money to buy without a mortgage. So if you're saying they're more affordable to the rich, sure. But I assume you mean the average home buyer.
Re: U.S. mortgage interest rates jump to 7.16%, highest since 2001
#128Earlier quoted context omitted.
Most of the people I speak to who locked in Current renters will have lower potential to save on a monthly basis, only to get 30-40% off on their first home with a >7% interest rate. If you sum the lost savings from rent plus the additional interest payment, it is uncertain whether that is the best strategy. That is also assuming real estate prices in certain regions wont hold stronger value, which they probably will…
Demand was high. It’s dropped by 50% since the peak with inventory up by over 2x from the low
There's so many predictions but my take is simple, the only thing for sure is that prices are not going up anytime soon again.
I'm still renting as I moved around a lot for jobs. I've saved hundreds of thousands of dollars, and intend to strike in 2023. I'm still looking for deals in the meanwhile, but most of these sellers are bitter that the market from even at ~5% in the summer is gone. And by and large the buyers disappeared in March in my region.
At a certain point, prices do have to match the cost of borrowing money. That's the trap of cheap loans. Those that got ~3% loans are stuck in whatever home they chose without a loss. They can't sell because most used that cheap money to pay ahead on decades of gains. Finding a sucker at 7%+ is going to be impossible, because short-term minded people simply don't have the money or means. And there's only so many generous and wealthy fathers to go around. Even those dads or investors don't want to take a risk in a market that hasn't bottomed out yet.
Once again, as always, cash is king.
Re: U.S. mortgage interest rates jump to 7.16%, highest since 2001
#129Isn't there "midterm" elections coming up in two months in the US? Aren't moves like spiking the rent to induce mass unemployment likely to benefit the Republican party? It can't be a winning strategy.
The Fed is independent in the sense that monetary policy and related decisions are made autonomously and are not subject to approval by the federal government. However, its governors are appointed by the President and must be confirmed by Congress. (citation: investopedia)
In parallel, when you're running the government, ideally you're running for the long-term well being of the country...
Re: U.S. mortgage interest rates jump to 7.16%, highest since 2001
#130We have a great house with a 2.75% mortgage. It would be hard to leave now, because a similar house would be a much higher monthly mortgage. Stuck, but thankfully we really love it and not plan on leaving.
The house isn’t the most amazing thing out there, just a run of the mill mass built suburb house, but it’s such a huge upgrade over the apartments I had been living in and the payment is much lower than the rent I had been paying, and more importantly it’s mostly static (no increase to brace for impact for each year), so for now I’m pretty happy to be “stuck” with it.