Live data from Hacker News

Firefox appears to be flagged as suspicious by Cloudflare

lwthiker.com

121–130 of 191 posts

Re: Firefox appears to be flagged as suspicious by Cloudflare

#121
I have been seeing this issues also, very odd, workarounds I tried do not get around the issue.

>If this behavior gets adapted on more sites, we can expect even more users leaving Firefox

But I will just not go to the sites instead of using something other than Firefox.

Re: Firefox appears to be flagged as suspicious by Cloudflare

#122

Earlier quoted context omitted.

But that's the issue. It's not my problem. My problem is maximizing the user experience for most of my users, and that involves squashing usability bugs common to all browsers and adding features that have been requested, not keeping up with the Gecko quirks-du-jour. (Speaking of "quirks-du-jour", the problem eventually "solved itself." The next major iteration of Firefox fixed a rendering regression and resolved the…

So a tragedy of the commons? See it is your problem to offer something to the general public then serve only the defacto monopolist instead of web standards. Because with each small compromise we each contribute to the problem until it reaches a breaking point. All the while those on the margins suffer, some with no real alternative. For ex in poorer areas where they cannot afford a computer that runs Chrome (which h…

Some people simply have no sense of community or civic duty. Everything is all about them, all the time. If they stand to profit from antisocial behavior, they won't hesitate.

Re: Firefox appears to be flagged as suspicious by Cloudflare

#123

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Quoted post unavailable.

Why jump to attacking them? Occam's razor applies, and there's no proof Cloudflare explicitly is targeting Firefox specifically, unless you somehow have internal access to their source and know there's checks explicitly looking for FF there.

I would take a more measured stance. I don’t think Cloudflare is explicitly targeting Firefox. I don’t even think they are aware of what this does in Firefox. (You can definitely design systems that don’t hardcode something but still clearly only affect it.) The likely explanation to me is that Firefox blocks cookies or something and Cloudflare marked this as suspicious. It shouldn’t, but it does.

Re: Firefox appears to be flagged as suspicious by Cloudflare

#124
post #11

Quoted post unavailable.

Because it works super great at throttling malicious traffic and solves a hard problem real site admins have.

Amount and severity of malicious traffic is greatly overestimated by many.

Re: Firefox appears to be flagged as suspicious by Cloudflare

#125

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Really? I'm a firefox user too and whilst I occasionally bump into some situation as you describe where I need to hop onto Chrome, I genuinely can't remember the last time this happened. Nope, actually - sometime last year, with some poorly-coded gig ticket purchase thing, if I remember right. I was able to check the code and amend some stupid niggle in WebDev tools to get around it. Not saying I should have to accep…

For a while now I can't even access WhatsApp Web [1] through Firefox. It gets stuck on the loading page and keeps refreshing itself forever. I have to resort to Chrome whenever I need WhatsApp on my laptop. [1] https://web.whatsapp.com

If you time, please file a bug report on Mozilla’s webcompat.com with the steps you took and a screenshot. Mozilla’s webcompat developers will try to debug the website, reach out to the website’s web developers with a proposed fix, and until the website is fixed, add a site-specific intervention or UA override in Firefox itself, if possible.

Looks like there are already a couple bug reports about whatsapp.com, but not the forever-refreshing page you see:

https://webcompat.com/issues?page=1&per_page=50&state=open&s...

Re: Firefox appears to be flagged as suspicious by Cloudflare

#126
post #68

I use Firefox Focus on my phone (opens links from apps in a private session - generally a great idea!) and always get this 5 second delay (which is often actually 10 or more seconds). I never considered that it's a Firefox-only thing!

Are you using Firefox Focus on Android or iOS? Does the 5-10 second delay happen on all websites or a specific one?

Re: Firefox appears to be flagged as suspicious by Cloudflare

#127

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Why jump to attacking them? Occam's razor applies, and there's no proof Cloudflare explicitly is targeting Firefox specifically, unless you somehow have internal access to their source and know there's checks explicitly looking for FF there.

I think you mean Hanlon's razor, but that adage is a farce. Every scoundrel in the world knows the trick of pretending it was all a mistake. Skepticism is warranted.

I can't see why Occam's razor wouldn't apply: don't postulate more entities than are necessary to explain the facts. Specifically, there is no reason to postulate some kind of anti-Firefox elements within Cloudflare when it's simply explainable as a mistake.

(There's a reason Hanlon's razor was given that name, I'm pretty sure, and that's because it's not too dissimilar from – essentially it's a much-more-situation-specific subset or variant of – Occam's razor. But I don't think "attribute to stupidity" was what the parent comment was suggesting.)

Re: Firefox appears to be flagged as suspicious by Cloudflare

#128
post #62

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I've used Firefox and Mozilla for what, 20 years? And I've never bumped into a situation like this. Some very clearly shit internal IT systems had pathetic IE requirements, but never one that said sorry go get chrome

They don't always say "go get chrome" but one example that still happens to me is logging in to Outlook email at work, if I use Firefox I get a hobbled "basic HTML" interface, if I masquerade as Chrome on Windows I get the full UI and it all works perfectly. Google drive is another one, where some things stop working depending on the user agent I'm presenting.

My health insurer won't let me login using Opera, a Chromium based browser, and suggests I install Firefox or... Chrome.

UA sniffing is soooo 2008.

Re: Firefox appears to be flagged as suspicious by Cloudflare

#129

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Why jump to attacking them? Occam's razor applies, and there's no proof Cloudflare explicitly is targeting Firefox specifically, unless you somehow have internal access to their source and know there's checks explicitly looking for FF there.

It's pretty simple to check. Go to https://www.g2.com/ in various browsers. That's what I did when I read the article. Here are my results: Firefox: Javascript challenge Chromium: No javascript challenge Edge: No javascript challenge How could you call this anything but an attack against firefox? edit: Seems cloudflare has responded[1] and they claim it is a setting set up by the site author. So this attack is done b…

Went to g2 from Germany. Got challenge, but was fast. Maybe 0.5secs. No challenge after closing and going there again. Maybe a geolocation thing, because of botnets, ddos, war, whatever?

edit: with FF OFC.

Re: Firefox appears to be flagged as suspicious by Cloudflare

#130
post #2

I mean, with that market share, popularity among open source fans... it's an easy group to target and filter oddballs. I'm a Firefox user and I'm used to this treatment at every step of the way, no matter if it's about software, airports, opening a bank account so I can receive a salary, etc. Fundamental things everyone wants to do are being made hard to do the right way. It's always anti privacy, anti self repair, a…

Really? I'm a firefox user too and whilst I occasionally bump into some situation as you describe where I need to hop onto Chrome, I genuinely can't remember the last time this happened. Nope, actually - sometime last year, with some poorly-coded gig ticket purchase thing, if I remember right. I was able to check the code and amend some stupid niggle in WebDev tools to get around it. Not saying I should have to accep…

Google Cloud Console works only in Chrome for me. I've been accessing it with Vivaldi for years, then I got the you broke my internet sad robot icon since a few months ago. Firefox loads the page but most of it is blank. I played with the controls of my privacy plugin with no benefit. It could be my configuration.
Post reply on HN