Live data from Hacker News

CSVCHAIN - NFTs backed by CSV technology

csvchain.com

121–130 of 171 posts

Re: CSVCHAIN - NFTs backed by CSV technology

#122

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Maybe I misunderstand your point but intellectual property can only exist under a legal system, this seems like a shallow 'gotcha'

No, it's a thorough gotcha for a shallow topic to which money has given the illusion of depth. If you need a centralized entity to enforce the rights associated with a decentralized system, the decentralized system is unnecessary. We've long had solutions for the purchase of digital assets on any platform you choose, with ownership and usage rights enforced by the state.

[deleted]

Re: CSVCHAIN - NFTs backed by CSV technology

#123
post #108

Quoted post unavailable.

Who would drill a hole in a human being?! Seriously though, implying that somebody having sex with multiple people makes them worthless is horrible. Also, if someone and their partner have incompatible expectations or boundaries then they should break up. What's forcing you to stay with your hypothetical wife? Seems like she'd be better off without you anyway.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Trepanning

Re: CSVCHAIN - NFTs backed by CSV technology

#124
post #98
post #81

Has anybody ever thought of something like a real world NFT? Imagine if you took a bunch of dried plant pigments and mixed them with oil and smeared them onto a canvas. Because it is physical it couldn't be duplicated or double-spent and it has a simple materials-based minting cost. I don't think anybody has done this before and there is probably a large market for buying and selling something like this. These are ea…

I got you fam: https://github.com/william-fields/witless#ntf-support

Thanks, bestie

Re: CSVCHAIN - NFTs backed by CSV technology

#125
post #81

Has anybody ever thought of something like a real world NFT? Imagine if you took a bunch of dried plant pigments and mixed them with oil and smeared them onto a canvas. Because it is physical it couldn't be duplicated or double-spent and it has a simple materials-based minting cost. I don't think anybody has done this before and there is probably a large market for buying and selling something like this. These are ea…

Creating physical art when it can be done digitally is a waste of resources

Re: CSVCHAIN - NFTs backed by CSV technology

#126

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Ah, but that only gives you the actual image, not the CSVCHAIN NFT that proves it is your image.

right clicks inspects content

Yeah. Like I said. You now have a copy of the image.

But prove to me that you are the one and only owner of your copy of the image.

That's what the CSV NFT gives you.

Re: CSVCHAIN - NFTs backed by CSV technology

#127
This is roycoding, the creator of CSVchain. Thanks everyone for checking it out.

Just so you know, I currently have a bit of a backlog of requests to manually process.

This was all very unexpected. I made this recently and then today started getting messages that Matt Levine wrote about something similar in his newsletter today. I tweeted at him and he then tweeted about it to his large following. So here we are on HN!

If you've contacted me, I promise to message you back, but it might take a day or so.

Re: CSVCHAIN - NFTs backed by CSV technology

#128
post #81

Has anybody ever thought of something like a real world NFT? Imagine if you took a bunch of dried plant pigments and mixed them with oil and smeared them onto a canvas. Because it is physical it couldn't be duplicated or double-spent and it has a simple materials-based minting cost. I don't think anybody has done this before and there is probably a large market for buying and selling something like this. These are ea…

This is not a good metaphor for NFTs. The content of any NFT can be perfectly duplicated by anyone. The only part of an NFT that matters is the signature. A better analogy would be musicians signing CDs / vinyls, sports players signing player cards / equipment, etc.

People buying NFTs created by nobodies are simply getting scammed. The physical metaphor here would be like paying a random amateur sports player to sign some equipment.

Re: CSVCHAIN - NFTs backed by CSV technology

#129
post #86

Critical security flaw: right-clicking is enabled!

I don't understand why people view the ability to copy something as a negative with NFTs. Everything can be copied. Even physical objects can be copied. Why does a museum buy a Van Gogh when they can just commission a replica, or easier yet, take a photo and print it on canvas?

Re: CSVCHAIN - NFTs backed by CSV technology

#130

Earlier quoted context omitted.

C'mon now.

The point of this joke site is to say "look NFTs are just a set of records", while missing the whole point of trustless, censorship resistant, append only, peer to peer ledgers The thing is, we saw these jokes about Bitcoin 10+ years ago. Its easy to point fun at things that one doesn't really understand. I imagine lots of people see this joke and go "Ha! See! You dont need a blockchain" while missing the point entir…

This site is not trying to be some kind of meaningful commentary on NFTs and blockchains.

It is just to have fun!

Don't take my word for it, look at the hilarious comments in this discussion.

No one took it seriously and thought "NFTs are just a set of records" or "you don't need a blockchain."

Post reply on HN