Which version of JDK should I use?

Here's a list of the things that were available in JDK 8 and no longer are: https://advancedweb.hu/a-categorized-list-of-all-java-and-jv...

When you stumble upon something like that, at best you can import a Maven dependency with a version that has what you need, at worst you need to rewrite the code to use another library or set of libraries.

If you have any low level logic like custom class loaders written against older JDK versions (think before 8), then they'll be forwards compatible until 8 for the most part, but will break afterwards. Coincidentally, reading code that deals with low level logic is also not easy to do, especially if it's not commented well.

If you rely upon reflection, or use advanced language features (like the JasperReports framework for generating PDFs, which also has a build step for building the reports), in some cases things might compile but not work at runtime due to class mismatches.

Many frameworks need new major versions to support newer releases than JDK 8, for example Spring Boot 1.5 needs to be upgraded, so you're also dealing with all the changes that are encapsulated by your dependencies. In another project that i also migrated, needed to rewrite a lot of web initialization code for Spring Boot 2.X.

Not only that, but with those framework changes, certain things can break in the actual environments. For example, if you package your app as a far .jar, then you'll no longer be able to serve JSP files out of it. It makes no sense, but packaging it as a .war which can be executed with "java -jar your-app.war" will work for some reason.

I some other libraries, method names remain the same, but signatures change, or sometimes things just get deprecated and removed - you have to deal with all of that, which is especially unfun in code that isn't commented but that the business depends on to work correctly. Throw in external factors such as insufficient coverage of tests and you're in for an interesting time. I'm not saying that it's a type of environment that should be condoned, but it's the objective reality in many software projects.

Oh and i hope that you're also okay with updating all of your app servers (like Tomcat) or JDK installs on the server as well, especially if you depend on some of the Tomcat libraries to be provided and for your frameworks/libraries that depend on them being present at runtime to accept those new versions effortlessly. It all feels very brittle at times.

This is especially a nightmare if your servers were configured manually - personally i'm introducing Ansible and containers to at least isolate the damage of Ops rot, but it's been an uphill battle since day 1.

Here's an exceedingly stupid one: sometimes there are checks in code to make sure that you're using the right version of JDK (or even the Oracle JDK), which get confused with the larger versions. It's easy to fix when it's your code, but really annoying when it's external tools - personal nitpick.

Addendum: here's something that i expected to break, but didn't. We use myBatis as an ORM. It has XML mapper files that define how to map entities and construct queries against the DB based on that. Also, it uses Java interfaces and dynamically calls the underlying XML code as necessary. So essentially you have an interface, which has a corresponding XML file in which you have quasi-Java code (e.g. checking what parameters are passed in to the query) that's used alongside a number of tags to dynamically build SQL queries. Here's an example: https://mybatis.org/mybatis-3/dynamic-sql.html

Instead of something breaking in myBatis, what broke actually was Hibernate in the newer versions of Spring. Oh, and Flyway for DB migrations simply used to work with a particular Oracle DB version as well.

I'm in the middle of a migration to 11 and my general approach has been to get it compiling on 11 while targeting 8 with (--release 8). That seems to catch a great many things that would otherwise fail. The hardest part thus far was figuring out the appropriate libs to replace Java 8 ee stuff, mostly wrt soap and xml. I'm hoping moving to 11 goes smoothly but we'll see. I'm hoping to have the artifacts to a point where they can run on either 8 or 11 without issues.

Why didn't they just keep AdoptOpenJDK? That was a good name IMO.

All of this is currently being implemented in project Valhalla...