Live data from Hacker News

Cloudflare R2 storage: Rapid and reliable object storage, minus the egress fees

blog.cloudflare.com

121–130 of 220 posts

Re: Cloudflare R2 storage: Rapid and reliable object storage, minus the egress fees

#121
post #54

For those who don't want to wait, there's DigitalOcean Spaces ( https://www.digitalocean.com/products/spaces/ ). Disclaimer: I haven't used it, but planning to, since I already use their VPS.

Scaleway also provides a similar service. Had an issue recently (deleted a bucket, and couldn't create another bucket with the same name) and their support replied back in minutes .

Scaleway S3 was slow as hell for small files last time I tried, is it better now?

Re: Cloudflare R2 storage: Rapid and reliable object storage, minus the egress fees

#122

Not sure why this is more appealing than Wasabi? As far as I can see, Wasabi is cheaper, has great speeds, fantastic S3 compatibility, their dashboard is a joy to use so what is the actual "special" thing here? I mean sure, it's a good thing to have more competition but the way everyone here is describing the situation makes it seem as if Cloudflare is going to be the cheapest & the best.

My understanding with Wasabi is that it is only intended for up to 100% egress. It doesn't look like r2 has this limitation. Though I can't imagine egress is actually completely free beyond a certain point.

Re: Cloudflare R2 storage: Rapid and reliable object storage, minus the egress fees

#123
Very generous offer from Cloudflare. I signed up.

The main question: how can Cloudflare make this into a sustainable business?

* cost/gb is cheaper or same as s3, gcp, azure

* no egress charges to customers, but they still have to pay for transit when they cross an AS!

what is the hidden angle Cloudfare is using here?

Re: Cloudflare R2 storage: Rapid and reliable object storage, minus the egress fees

#124
post #123

Very generous offer from Cloudflare. I signed up. The main question: how can Cloudflare make this into a sustainable business? * cost/gb is cheaper or same as s3, gcp, azure * no egress charges to customers, but they still have to pay for transit when they cross an AS! what is the hidden angle Cloudfare is using here?

I don't know/think there is a hidden angle.

Eg. What could be the hidden angle of providing domains at cost ( which they do).

I think it's a matter of having a more complete cloud suite and expanding their portfolio while gaining market share.

Clarification: I don't think they do this at cost. Just cheaper than the big 3.

Re: Cloudflare R2 storage: Rapid and reliable object storage, minus the egress fees

#125
post #123

Very generous offer from Cloudflare. I signed up. The main question: how can Cloudflare make this into a sustainable business? * cost/gb is cheaper or same as s3, gcp, azure * no egress charges to customers, but they still have to pay for transit when they cross an AS! what is the hidden angle Cloudfare is using here?

Cost/GB is three times that of Backblaze, bandwith is generally too cheap to meter (outside aws, gcp, azure who use egress costs for lock-in).

The offer is no doubt competitively prized, but it's no doubt much more lucrative than people using Cloudflare as a CDN for their s3/b2/azure/whatever.

Re: Cloudflare R2 storage: Rapid and reliable object storage, minus the egress fees

#126
Am I reading this right that this is pretty much aiming to be a full competitor to S3? Or is this a more limited special purpose tool? I didn't really follow what Cloudflare is doing, so I only know them as a CDN. Are private buckets possible with this?

We all knew that the big players are really maximising their profits on the egress charges, so I can see that this left some potential for someone to step in. No egress charges at all still sound a bit too good to be true, but it would be nice as that's just one parameter less to think about.

Another interesting aspect are CloudFlare Workers. As far as I can tell they're not a full replacement for something like AWS Lambda if e.g. I need to do a bit heavier stuff on the data in R2. Being able to do heavier processing close to the actual data would be really interesting as well.

Re: Cloudflare R2 storage: Rapid and reliable object storage, minus the egress fees

#127
post #123

Very generous offer from Cloudflare. I signed up. The main question: how can Cloudflare make this into a sustainable business? * cost/gb is cheaper or same as s3, gcp, azure * no egress charges to customers, but they still have to pay for transit when they cross an AS! what is the hidden angle Cloudfare is using here?

> no egress charges to customers, but they still have to pay for transit when they cross an AS!

Can somebody TL;DR what does being member of the "bandwidth alliance" mean?

Re: Cloudflare R2 storage: Rapid and reliable object storage, minus the egress fees

#128
post #123

Very generous offer from Cloudflare. I signed up. The main question: how can Cloudflare make this into a sustainable business? * cost/gb is cheaper or same as s3, gcp, azure * no egress charges to customers, but they still have to pay for transit when they cross an AS! what is the hidden angle Cloudfare is using here?

> no egress charges to customers, but they still have to pay for transit when they cross an AS! Can somebody TL;DR what does being member of the "bandwidth alliance" mean?

> what does being member of the "bandwidth alliance" mean?

Cloud providers normally have huge profits on egress data ( outgoing) and not incoming data ( to attract giving them your data).

This additionally incentives customers to stay within a certain cloud and not using competing products based on costs ( since egress costs to a 3rd party makes the price difference obsolete)

Cloudflare ( i think) started the bandwidth alliance to make these prices more fair. As in: work together, have direct network connections and reduce customer billing.

AWS didn't want to join as they are n°1 currently: https://blog.cloudflare.com/aws-egregious-egress/

Re: Cloudflare R2 storage: Rapid and reliable object storage, minus the egress fees

#129
post #106

This is interesting ... For the longest time we tried to convince people that they should have an off-amazon archive of their S3 data ... we even ran an ads to that effect in 2012[1]. The (obvious) reason this isn't compelling is the cost of egress. It's just (relatively) too expensive to offload your S3 assets to some third party on a regular basis. So if R2 is S3 with no egress, suddenly there is a value propositio…

> So if R2 is S3 with no egress, suddenly there is a value proposition again. That doesn't appear to be what they're doing, they don't seem to have changed their existing operating model at all: > R2 will zero-rate infrequent storage operations under a threshold — currently planned to be in the single digit requests per second range. Above this range, R2 will charge significantly less per-operation than the major pro…

This is about the operation, not about bandwidth the way that I read it. All providers have prices for bandwidth and prices for different "tiers" of operations (store, retrieve, delete, list, etc). The way I read it is that bandwidth is always 100% free, and storage operations are free under a certain threshold. I hope I'm right ;)

Re: Cloudflare R2 storage: Rapid and reliable object storage, minus the egress fees

#130

Not sure why this is more appealing than Wasabi? As far as I can see, Wasabi is cheaper, has great speeds, fantastic S3 compatibility, their dashboard is a joy to use so what is the actual "special" thing here? I mean sure, it's a good thing to have more competition but the way everyone here is describing the situation makes it seem as if Cloudflare is going to be the cheapest & the best.

https://wasabi.com/rcs-pricing-faq/

>If your monthly egress data transfer is greater than your active storage volume, then your storage use case is not a good fit for Wasabi’s free egress policy

>If your use case exceeds the guidelines of our free egress policy on a regular basis, we reserve the right to limit or suspend your service

Unless I am misreading, wasabi can shut you down if your egress is high.

Post reply on HN