Live data from Hacker News

Dead Startup Toys

deadstartuptoys.com

121–130 of 211 posts

Re: Dead Startup Toys

#121

Did One Laptop per Child truly fail as a startup? It was always a nonprofit, so of course it didn't make money. While the technology was lacking in many respects, it did serve a lot of children at the time, and proved the market that Chromebooks came to later dominate with a similar approach (linux-based OS with minimal resources at $100-300 price point).

Even 8+ years ago, OLPC was taught as a case study in business school. It was a largely failed project.

It's a pretty classic example of a CEO who was very capable at establishing business partnerships but had such a rigid view about the problem they were trying to solve. They never really proved that the 1:1 concept actually had merit, but ended up being so invested in quantity over quality.

In developing countries, the computers were too simple to teach effective computer skills. And in undeveloped countries, the laptops did nothing to address actual education problems.

Chromebooks have the benefit years of Chrome apps being developed to solve actual problems. They also give up a lot of the goofy ideas like hand crank recharging or mesh networking and etc.

Re: Dead Startup Toys

#123
I want one of those soccer balls with an inbuilt dynamo. Or those tiles tested in UK schools that harvest power from footsteps. I'm thinking of a similar website for all the failed products that tried to use children as a source of electricity.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Empower_Playgrounds

https://techcrunch.com/2013/02/28/the-soccket-is-an-electric...

https://theswitch.co.uk/energy/guides/technology/energy-harv...

Re: Dead Startup Toys

#125

Did One Laptop per Child truly fail as a startup? It was always a nonprofit, so of course it didn't make money. While the technology was lacking in many respects, it did serve a lot of children at the time, and proved the market that Chromebooks came to later dominate with a similar approach (linux-based OS with minimal resources at $100-300 price point).

Chromebooks simply took over the netbook market which was already established by the time OLPC got some publicity. I think OLPC failed because it became more about proving that tech and "bold ideas" from silicon valley could change the world, instead of seriously addressing issues in the third world – it reminds me of the PlayPump.

https://news.climate.columbia.edu/2010/07/01/the-playpump-wh...

Re: Dead Startup Toys

#127
post #44

Earlier quoted context omitted.

>Did One Laptop per Child truly fail as a startup? I'd say it kind of did (as did Netbooks as a technology for the most part as well). It's smartphones really that won the segment that OLPC was primarily targeted at. Chromebooks became fairly big in education but primarily AFAIK in developed countries.

"Netbooks as a technology for the most part" I know people that created books and websites on a netbook, who got though school and business meetings with them. I never seen that for a smartphone.

People absolutely get through school and business meetings with smartphones.

If you visit a community college or know someone who teaches at one, a surprisingly high percentage of students do their homework and write papers entirely on their phone. It's kind of amazing.

Re: Dead Startup Toys

#128

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I mean, they had to somehow procure stock from startups that are long out of business. Items nobody actually wants, so what's the point of having _more_ items nobody actually wants? (EDIT: oh. whoops. they're miniatures haha)

They are not selling the actual products of these startups but rather super cute miniaturized versions that they made.

Some of these items barely existed in the first place. You can get a Juicero, probably, but good luck getting your hands on an honest Theranos device. Few existed, and most of those are probably in the hands of the federal prosecutors charging Holmes with fraud.

Re: Dead Startup Toys

#129
post #45

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Did you press 'F' to pay your respects though?

In case anybody thinks this is offtopic: pressing F does indeed do something on that page (be warned: there is sound). There's an inscription in the marble below the list of products that implores you to pay your respects to capitalism.

The irony being that this website is the product of a startup that is itself valued at an eye-watering 100M..

Re: Dead Startup Toys

#130
post #116

If you've got thick enough skin to hear a bunch of highly offensive and hilarious Canadian cursing, AvE on YouTube tears down a Juicero machine.

Great recommendation, I learned a lot when I first watched that video. I learned bits and pieces about product design, material science, the nature of startups and venture capital, some introspection occurred, I learned to love again, and a whole bunch of new slang I will neither remember nor understand.

A Rosetta stone exists - https://avedictionary.com/browse/
Post reply on HN