Live data from Hacker News

Tesla plans to build a new car factory in Texas

arstechnica.com

121–130 of 163 posts

Re: Tesla plans to build a new car factory in Texas

#121

Hours after Electrek's story ran, three news organizations—TechCrunch, CNBC, and the Associated Press—all published stories stating that Tesla was still considering Tulsa, Oklahoma. Tulsa is a better choice for one reason: Being able to say "Tesla Tulsa." Or "The Tulsa Teslas." Or "I wanna test a Tulsa Tesla." Maybe instead of a tax break, the city could offer to change its name to Tesla. Cities have changed names fo…

Maybe they should consider Tuscaloosa for the same reason.

Re: Tesla plans to build a new car factory in Texas

#122

Isn't this just Elon Musk getting into one of his superfluous fights, only this time California being the somewhat-random opponent? Musk has been completely unhinged the last few weeks, and it doesn't seem to be wise making such large decisions in anger, especially considering the reason for his anger is, even if justified, unlikely to reoccur. I'm quite the Musk fanboy, but he's always had this very strange anger is…

> Musk has been completely unhinged the last few weeks The most logical guess I can make is he on some new drugs that's starting to damage his brain. Some form of synthetic or maybe good ol heroin.

I don't agree with his behavior but I don't feel how he's recently acted is extreme for him. The whole covid-19 quarantine has been painful for everyone, and it obviously causes a specific pain point for Tesla because of state and county-specific orders. Him flipping out about it is mostly expected, or at least more expected than his random $420 tweet, or his concerted effort to keep talking/emailing about Vernon Unsworth months after the cave rescue.

Re: Tesla plans to build a new car factory in Texas

#123

I get the feeling this was already planned. Freemont doesn't have much spare land to increase manufacturing capacity. California has to be more expensive (Labor, Regulations) than manufacturing in Texas. Even if you'd need to fly your R&D team between Texas and California, you'd still be saving money

In some vague "regulations" way, possibly, but the published hourly rates of Tesla Fremont workers are not especially high. (I just googled the average as being less than twenty dollars, which can't possibly be right, but I do remember the figure being low by autoworker standards) The thought that they might pay even less in Texas is depressing.

> I just googled the average as being less than twenty dollars, which can't possibly be right,

It's right. You don't go to Tesla to make tons of money or have a good work-Life balance, you're there to contribute to a passion project with like minded individuals with certain known sunk opportunity-costs: this includes salary. (The engineering and software people are paid well, or so I'm told, but most of the bulk is on the factory side.)

In terms of compensation its not great, but at least they're honest about it; you do get somewhat generous stock options if you stay/last there for over a year, really good health care plans, and depending on the department all the hours you could possibly want or handle. I knew going in my schedule would be 60+ hours, I just didn't see it happening within a swing-shift model so had to decline the offer.

Job security, however, is not exactly a given either. Mass layoffs have been a regular occurrence, one occured right after my first interview process and many have sought to unionize so its a contentious affair even to this day, as Germany ended up getting a Union due to strict EU/DE Auto Union pressure.

> The thought that they might pay even less in Texas is depressing.

Why? Cost of living differs quite a bit in the US. While in Texas in February for my SpaceX interview I knew I was going to have to go down in salary in relation to my current role, but I was assured by several locals that my salary estimates could net a 2-3 bedroom in town with no problem, whereas I have roommates back home.

Besides, where else would I want to be than at the Factory where feeling bad about salary figures feels entirely moot and misses the entire point of why you go to these places?

> I get the feeling this was already planned. Freemont doesn't have much spare land to increase manufacturing capacity.

It was, in February Elon was already teasing about where the new Giga factory was to be located, with Texas being mentioned. Fremont factory has been over capacity even before 3's assembly line change(s) and optimization. I don't if you can find it anymore but there were pictures of Employee parking being the most chaotic thing ever, cars taking every square inch.

The supply chain guys were all pretty sore about those days, but Tesla started bussing people in from the Woodland Park building and many people just commuted that way.

As 3's numbers started to get rolling things got more and more creative, and they ended up getting more parking/staging space near the area. That much was documented [1], and people even commissioned drone pilots to do regular fly-overs over the Factory as more and more progress was being made. I haven't looked, but I wonder if people are that excited about Y.

1: https://teslamotorsclub.com/tmc/threads/found-a-lot-of-model...

Re: Tesla plans to build a new car factory in Texas

#124

Isn't this just Elon Musk getting into one of his superfluous fights, only this time California being the somewhat-random opponent? Musk has been completely unhinged the last few weeks, and it doesn't seem to be wise making such large decisions in anger, especially considering the reason for his anger is, even if justified, unlikely to reoccur. I'm quite the Musk fanboy, but he's always had this very strange anger is…

> I'm quite the Musk fanboy

Still? I can understand still being a fan of Tesla or SpaceX, but I'm suspicious of anyone that's followed Musk's behavior recently and is still like "that's my guy!"

Re: Tesla plans to build a new car factory in Texas

#125
post #110

Earlier quoted context omitted.

> Going full alt-right MAGA is going to cut his customer base in half, at least in the US and Europe. Putting my best effort to be charitable here: he could be opening up a whole new market that is opposed to tree-huggers, fuel efficiency and Priuses. Texas loves trucks, the Cybertruck will be henceforth known as the Freedom Cybertruck and the Texas Edition will come with a complementary "Come and take it" sticker. "…

this is an awesome take- musk has been playing 4d chess all along, getting hard-core conservatives to buy into renewable energy..

This is a very charitable interpretation of Elon Musk's recent outbursts.

Re: Tesla plans to build a new car factory in Texas

#126
post #30

"But Musk is said to want to start construction extremely soon and aims to have Model Y vehicles coming out of the plant by the end of the year." That is just delusional.

I think the rule with Elon Musk is all his estimates are extremely optimistic and you need to multiply them by two or three to get closer to reality. But I'm sure it serves a purpose in giving his employees an aggressive target to aim at. Even if they miss it, at least they probably got there sooner.

Perhaps they got there sooner, but at what cost to their health, relationships, and sanity?

Re: Tesla plans to build a new car factory in Texas

#127

Earlier quoted context omitted.

https://workinjurysource.com/workplace-injury-statistics-201... > States with Non-Fatal Workplace Illness and Injury Rates Above the National Average: > California > States with Non-Fatal Workplace Illness and Injury Rates Below the National Average: > Texas It's completely possible that Texas is less adversarial/bureaucratic or similar than California, but whatever they're doing is working. Though it could be cultur…

That statistic is nearly completely useless for comparison. For starters, it's measuring non-fatal illnesses. If your regulatory regime is converting otherwise fatal accidents to non-fatal ones, then you're going to have higher rates despite being safer. (Historically, this has happened: the introduction of helmets in WW1 caused head injury rates to go up... because people who otherwise died now lived with a head inj…

> For starters, it's measuring non-fatal illnesses.

This actually helps to mitigate your other point, because all types of industries can have non-fatal injuries from things like overexertion or slips on wet floors but fatal injuries are dominated by dangerous industries like mining, transportation and agriculture that differ by state.

The fatal injury rate between states is quite incomparable in particular because motor vehicle accidents are the leading cause of death among working-aged people, and the rate will be higher in states that are more spread out because workers in all industries there log more vehicle miles for work (and at higher average speeds).

> Finally... there's no mention of the degree of difference at all.

Texas can't be worse if it's better.

Re: Tesla plans to build a new car factory in Texas

#128
post #110

Earlier quoted context omitted.

this is an awesome take- musk has been playing 4d chess all along, getting hard-core conservatives to buy into renewable energy..

This is a very charitable interpretation of Elon Musk's recent outbursts.

tongue in cheek. lately musk has reminded me not to have heros :(

Re: Tesla plans to build a new car factory in Texas

#129

Isn't this just Elon Musk getting into one of his superfluous fights, only this time California being the somewhat-random opponent? Musk has been completely unhinged the last few weeks, and it doesn't seem to be wise making such large decisions in anger, especially considering the reason for his anger is, even if justified, unlikely to reoccur. I'm quite the Musk fanboy, but he's always had this very strange anger is…

This might come as a shock to you but most people do not care what the political opinions or behavior of a car manufacturer's CEO are. Likewise the internet does not at all reflect the views of your average person, and I would wager that despite Tesla fanatics being very aware of Musk and his eccentric behavior, most Tesla owners moving forward won't even know or care who the CEO is as they rollout to mass market. This won't make a dent in his customer base. Musk is beyond reproach at this point, his "fuck you" warchest is too big.

Re: Tesla plans to build a new car factory in Texas

#130
post #46

Earlier quoted context omitted.

> But I'm sure it serves a purpose in giving his employees an aggressive target to aim at. Even if they miss it, at least they probably got there sooner. That only works until the employees quickly realize the estimates are impossible bullshit, and stop taking them seriously.

Well that’s where management steps in and doesn’t let you disregard the deadline. It makes for a miserable work experience but you can probably achieve a lot that way.

> Well that’s where management steps in and doesn’t let you disregard the deadline. It makes for a miserable work experience but you can probably achieve a lot that way.

That's the kind of management that would go whip the sea for disobedience.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Xerxes_I#Invasion_of_the_Greek...

> According to the Greek historian Herodotus, Xerxes's first attempt to bridge the Hellespont ended in failure when a storm destroyed the flax and papyrus cables of the bridges. In retaliation, Xerxes ordered the Hellespont (the strait itself) whipped three hundred times, and had fetters thrown into the water.

Post reply on HN